7 ms·
Internal Emails Show Twitter Struggled to Interpret Its Rules Unverifying Trolls
- wybiral 9y agoNot everyone is eligible for verification. That naturally puts them in the position of having to prioritized verification, but based on what? If it's only meant to prove identity then they should follow the lead of Keybase and verify yourself by proving control over other accounts.
- neaden 9y agoThe core problem is that verification comes with perks. If veryifing someone just meant "Yep, it's that person alright" I don't think there would be all these issues with twitter saying "Yep, this is really the spokesperson of the KKK" or something similar. But because there are perks it comes off more as Twitter endorsing the person as someone who has interesting things to say.
- golemotron 9y agoThis is a symptom of the times. Even mentioning an idea is seen by many to be endorsement.
- Swizec 9y agoIn the age of publicity it doesn't matter if you agree or disagree with an idea, it matters that you helped it spread. I don't know that there's a fix for that.
- bkeroack 9y agoThe very assertion that you must protect people from exposure to various ideas is deeply problematic and against everything the Enlightenment taught us.
- arkades 9y agoThe Enlightenment didn’t envision ML-assisted data-guided state-actor-resourced propaganda efforts. The Enlightenment imagined rhetoric and persuasion as something like single combat: one man’s reason pitted against another. It didn’t imagine massively resources organizations throwing millions of dollars at studying quirks of human cognition so as to optimize the short-circuiting of reason itself. I’m a proponent of Enlightenment values, but the bottom line lessons that we derive from those values were derived in a wildly different context. An Enlightenment for the modern day may very well look different than “old school” Enlightenment. It may very well one day shape up to being open-minded about what socioeconomic datasets you let your pet AI graze on, rather than being foolish enough to ingest slogans from all comers.
- QAPereo 9y agoYou’re not wrong, but it’s also true that at various times the written word and advances in its production and distribution were seen much the same way. Any new technology which represents a massive improvement in communication is going to radically change society in unpredictable ways. Needless to say, rapid and irreversible change is monstrous to live through especially if you’ve historically enjoyed the advantages of a previous system.
- alien_at_work 9y ago>The Enlightenment didn’t envision ML-assisted data-guided state-actor-resourced propaganda efforts. So the solution is to fight those things (with e.g. laws and education), not bring back taboos. How many times must we re-learn the lessons of the past? Censorship is not the path forward and even if you disagree, surely you can understand that, at an absolute minimum, we can't let random noisy members of the internet, or certain specific monopolies make the descision on what ideas can't be thought or expressed.
- Swizec 9y agoI didn't say you have to protect them. I did say you might want to not spread ideas you disagree with. It's one thing to debate with friends at a bar. It's another to retweet something to your 6,000 followers and adding "lol dumb". At least some of those followers will disregard your comment and just absorb the message. Just like my maths professor in high school would say. I'd show you how most of you do this wrong, but then you're just going to remember the wrong way. Let me just show you how to do it right. Then there's the argument that any signal of approval (share, comment, retweet, engage) tells algorithmic timelines that this message gets much engagement and sharing it to a broader audience. A key tenet of human cognition is that we agree more with things we hear more often. You can convince people of pretty much anything through sheer bruteforce of Being Everywhere. Doesn't matter if those who share agree or disagree, just that they shared.
- psyc 9y agoThe fix is not to take this “dangerous meme” stance.
- QAPereo 9y ago...Because that’s how Twitter used it. They didn’t offer verification to any verifiable person, it was a “big thing” with benefits. By design I would guess.
- mc32 9y agoYeah. If it was simple user verification, they would have long time ago verified the likes of Assange. Obviously they use it as a political tool, because they do verify other activists they are more in line with.
- ceejayoz 9y agoYeah, I'm no Assange fan, but his situation exposed clear issues with the capricious way verification was (or wasn't) handed out.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Banthum 9y agoEven more blatant was un-verifying Milo Yiannopolous. How can a person become not-themselves when they've been verified to be themselves already? It made it incredibly obvious that "Verified" actually means "Morally approved by Twitter Inc."
- none_to_remain 9y agoThe fun thing to do here is hold them to this - consider any reprehensible statement by a bluecheck to be Twitter-approved.
- crescentfresh 9y agoI don't twitter. What are the perks?
- thinkingemote 9y agoIn the article it lists a few, such as better SEO, spam white listing etc
- ImSkeptical 9y agoWhy wouldn't they just have a blue check for "identity verified" and a green check for "Valued Community Member". Give your racists, weirdos, trolls, etc the blue check and no perks if you can identify them, and reporters, politicians, whatever the green check and the perks. I really hate how big companies get paralyzed over problems like this. A small group would have solved this the same day the realized it was an issue.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- wklauss 9y ago> Why wouldn't they just have a blue check for "identity verified" and a green check for "Valued Community Member". Because then we will be having this same conversation about Twitter mismanagement of green checks. Identity is not the problem. What bigots, racist, nazis and political actors are demanding is status, not recognition. Milo followers know he is who he say he is.
- StavrosK 9y agoBut that's exactly the problem. Twitter started the blue check as verification and then it slowly transitioned to mean "valuable member", through, I imagine, employees taking small steps at a time ("hey, we only blue check famous people, so we might as well report that on the shareholder meetings"). Thus, the blue check slowly became something different than intended, and realizing this and having a second check for that ("blue is only for verification!") would have solved the problem.
- skybrian 9y agoOn the other hand, I liked this argument that checkmarks should verify facts about people, not just their names: https://medium.com/@yonatanzunger/the-hard-lessons-of-blue-checkmarks-c12094ed4a9c https://medium.com/@yonatanzunger/the-hard-lessons-of-blue-c...
- kjrose 9y agoPretty much. If the checkmark didn’t have benefits then it becomes gray. The only way it becomes neutral is if they genuinely mean it as a validation. Ie even the most dispicable person gets one if they are validated.
- thinkingemote 9y agoJust a query, forgive me, why not use the word "ban" instead of perma-suspend. A suspension means a kind of state between other states. Permanent suspension doesn't make sense to me with this context. perhaps it's an American English thing?
- _alias 9y agoI don't think it's an American English thing. It does clarify that a suspension is temporary. Using ban instead would make the difference between a ban and suspension more ambiguous imo.
- topspin 9y ago"perhaps it's an American English thing" It's an American mental gymnastics thing. When we're not inventing euphemisms to obscure our purpose we use straightforward words like "ban".
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- QAPereo 9y agoTo be fair that’s hardly American... it’s human. Remember the “Prosperity Sphere” for one notable example?
- mattmanser 9y agoThe Americans are notorious for it though, especially anything to do with invading a country or justifying killing a bunch of innocent people.
- waterhouse 9y agoOrwell seems to indicate that some of the British were notorious for it at one point, too. From "Politics and the English Language"[1]: "Consider for instance some comfortable English professor defending Russian totalitarianism. He cannot say outright, ‘I believe in killing off your opponents when you can get good results by doing so’. Probably, therefore, he will say something like this: ‘While freely conceding that the Soviet regime exhibits certain features which the humanitarian may be inclined to deplore, we must, I think, agree that a certain curtailment of the right to political opposition is an unavoidable concomitant of transitional periods, and that the rigors which the Russian people have been called upon to undergo have been amply justified in the sphere of concrete achievement.’ The inflated style itself is a kind of euphemism. A mass of Latin words falls upon the facts like soft snow, blurring the outline and covering up all the details. The great enemy of clear language is insincerity. When there is a gap between one's real and one's declared aims, one turns as it were instinctively to long words and exhausted idioms, like a cuttlefish spurting out ink." [1] http://orwell.ru/library/essays/politics/english/e_polit http://orwell.ru/library/essays/politics/english/e_polit
- gozur88 9y agoTwitter could have avoided so many problems by sticking to verification as they advertised it - that the blue check mark just meant you were who you said you were and nothing more. It should have provided no benefits other than followers know they're following the right person. Using it as a stamp of approval is an absolute minefield for a public company. So far the competition is, well, incompetent, but eventually somebody's going to come along and take advantage of these kinds of mistakes.
- topgunsarg 9y agoThey could just have a second badge like LinkedIn does for "influencer" or something of the like, that would convey the current benefits of the verification badge.
- anigbrowl 9y agoWhich would be subject to all the problems with the Verification checkmark...
- faceplanted 9y agoYes, but it would at least stop getting in the way of Twitter's usability like the current button does, they could verify all the celebrities and political activists that they haven't yet who people want them to, and then they could go bestowing perks on people they like, or pay them money.
- jeffmould 9y agoOr like Facebook has with two different levels/color verification checkmarks. A gray check for verified business which doesn't mean much other than they verified a phone number, or a blue check for verified person/business/etc.. of greater importance.
- jxramos 9y agoGood point, seems like a failure to decouple independent concepts. Bad design, bad implementation.
- matt4077 9y agoI feel like these quotes simply show a reasonable, deliberative process. Of course there was confusion regarding the meaning of verification–they admitted as much. These emails are exactly what I would have expected. They also do not contradict Twitter's public statements. Quote: “verification was meant to authenticate identity & voice, but it is interpreted as an endorsement or an indicator of importance.” Is that not exactly what happened?
- malvosenior 9y agoThey may have agonized about removing Milo’s check but they’ve been handing them out willy nilly for a few years now. There are tons of business people and friends of Twitter employees with the blue check. People who would not be known outside of their social circle yet they get “verified” as if they were under any risk of impersonation whatsoever. My personal observation is that these random blue check people skew very heavy to the left of the political spectrum, but I have no data to back that up. Certainly the people I’ve seen are much less notable than Milo though.
- fatwa 9y agoYou can click on any Trump tweet and see a myriad of bad jokes from blue-checked journalists who live in New York
- golemiprague 9y agoThey should just keep verification as a technical thing, verifying that someone is who he claims to be, they can charge a small amount for the procedure and that's it, everybody happy. As for all the other banning stuff, just take a queue from much smarter people, the founding fathers and apply the first amendment to Twitter. This way people can say whatever they want and they will not have to deal with all those procedures of who to ban and why. The American high court already ruled what is included in this first amendment so just follow their ruling and ban people if the break the low, simple.
- retox 9y agoOne man's terrorist is another's freedom fighter.
- KasianFranks 9y agoMaybe because it was created by trolls, voyeurs, like facebook. Unlike Google.
- glasz 9y agothe verification check is completely useless for me. it has forever been. is that just me? everything twitter management does is just complete selfish bullshit. they should be a 50 people operation and do one thing: publish 140 char messages and show ads. problems solved.