5 ms·
This response by the battery is really interesting. And it is certainly helping the Australian grid. However, it is worth noting that the Australian grid, Sout
by roenxi 9y ago
This response by the battery is really interesting. And it is certainly helping the Australian grid.
However, it is worth noting that the Australian grid, South Australia's in particular, is so woefully mismanaged that almost anything goes. South Australia is in the running for the most expensive electricity in the world [1].
As far as I've been able to tell, we aren't building coal or nuclear because there are outrageous political risks (opposition party & green lobby policy will probably make them uneconomic in the next decade); we aren't building anything else because because the economic option is coal. I think there is some sort of fracking ban that seems to have caused a gas shortage - I don't really understand that.
Long story short; Australia has looming electricity generation problems due to government policy and this battery is helping, but it is not fixing them.
[1] http://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-11-17/curious-adelaide-the-problem-of-power/9158240 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-11-17/curious-adelaide-the-p...
- ImaCake 9y agoMy understanding is that no one wants to build new coal power plants because renewables are going to be cheaper regardless of any government subsidies.
- Jedd 9y agoIf you're including regulatory oversight (or lack of) under the 'management' heading, I'd definitely agree. "Since 2009, the electricity networks that own and manage our “poles and wires” have quietly spent $45 billion on the most expensive project this country has ever seen. Allowed to run virtually unchecked, they’ve spent vast sums on infrastructure we don’t need, and have charged it all to us, with an additional fee attached. The spending was approved by a federal regulator, and yet the federal government didn’t even note it until it was well underway." [1] > As far as I've been able to tell, we aren't building coal or nuclear because there are outrageous political risks ... That adjective 'political' is not needed there, and serves to distract from the bigger, actual risks attached to those obsolete technologies. (With my usual caveat that I'm assuming people using the word nuclear mean only fission.) > .. we aren't building anything else because because the economic option is coal. Is it technically still an 'option' if you think there's only one? Anyway, we (Australia(ns)) are not special. Coal is not a sensible choice -- economic or otherwise -- anywhere on the planet. Unfortunately many places, including here, haven't comprehended that yet. Or rather, the people that run the country -- both within and outside of the government -- prefer the extant power generation and delivery infrastructure for a variety of fairly obvious reasons. [1] https://www.themonthly.com.au/issue/2014/july/1404136800/jess-hill/power-corrupts https://www.themonthly.com.au/issue/2014/july/1404136800/jes...
- shard972 9y agoNuclear is obsolete to what? As far as I understand, nuclear is the replacement for coal, nothing else comes close to being able to provide a stable constant supply in large quantities. What else can take the role of supplying the bulk of electricity to grids that doesn't also have it's own environmental concerns?
- will_hughes 9y ago> Nuclear is obsolete to what? As far as I understand, nuclear is the replacement for coal, nothing else comes close to being able to provide a stable constant supply in large quantities. The article pretty clearly demonstrates that grid-scale battery storage systems are able to provide very fast reaction times. More battery storage systems, along with other forms of energy storage such as Solar-Thermal and pumped-hydro can take daytime generation and make it usable at night. They're proven workable grid-scale technologies. Large widely distributed deployments of Wind generation can also provide a lot of capacity. For those who claim wind doesn't always blow - well, it's always blowing somewhere. Having a lot more individually smaller generators plus energy storage will inherently permit a more stable grid - one smaller generator tripping offline doesn't cause a massive issue.
- nl 9y agoWhat else can take the role of supplying the bulk of electricity to grids that doesn't also have it's own environmental concerns? Gas fire plants Hydro Pump Solar Liquid salt storage Geothermal Wind + Large Scale Solar + Storage Tidal Decentralized PV solar plus decentralized storage. There are enormous numbers of combinations of solutions which don't involve coal or nuclear. Both coal and nuclear power are slow to respond to changes in demand (or supply problems), and both are very expensive centralized solutions. Much more efficient solutions can be built using smaller numbers of smaller, faster, cheaper power stations (ie, gas fired) plus a diverse combination of other sources.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoStart a business then! But I think investors may be hard to find - because most of that hasn't proved cost effective.
- nl 9y agoWe are building plenty of gas fired plants. And a fracking ban didn't cause the gas shortage (whoever told you that has a pretty serious agenda!). Australian gas reserves are the second biggest in the world and relatively easy to access. The "problem" is/was that they are tied up in long term export agreements.
- stephen_g 9y agoYeah, the contracts are ridiculous. Santos et. al. are locked in to exporting too much of our production to countries like Japan (more than they even need anymore I beleive), there isn't enough of the gas produced being sold domestically so prices locally have jumped significantly, but at the same time the international price has dropped so I don't think the export is even breaking even, and I've read that at this point we could import the surplus back from Japan (that we sold them originally) for less than what we pay on the domestic market! This is a huge problem because gas is required for a lot of our industry, but also because of where it sits in the energy pricing mix, the gas price almost entirely determines the price of electricity - https://www.macrobusiness.com.au/2017/07/truth-behind-electricity-price-increases/ https://www.macrobusiness.com.au/2017/07/truth-behind-electr... The economists at MacroBusiness (I linked an article from their site above) believe a gas reservation policy (requiring the producers to sell a larger portion of their supply on the domestic market) could fix a lot of this.
- nl 9y agoI don't think the export is even breaking even That's not true. They signed long term supply contracts with a price that was profitable. at this point we could import the surplus back from Japan (that we sold them originally) for less than what we pay on the domestic market! This is true. That's the problem with long term contracts! But on the other hand they did guarantee the revenue needed to develop the gas fields.
- caf 9y agoA large amount of the exported gas is coming from pre-existing East Coast fields eg. Bass Strait that were already developed. What's new is the liquefaction LNG export terminals.
- icc97 9y agoThis is not the first time I've heard Australians complaining about the green lobby. From what I understand one of the major problems Australia is the sheer distance the electricity has to travel and the infrastructure required for such a small population. Solar power seems such an obvious choice, yet many Australians seem to be against it.
- greglindahl 9y agoIn Australia, being green or anti-green is a big part of politics. The party currently nationally in power is anti-green. Interestingly, because of the combination of great solar conditions and long distances, if you want to build a house in the middle of nowhere, it's cheaper to buy solar and a battery than hook into the grid.
- nl 9y agoI don't think anyone (except the coal lobby) is against solar power. It does have a problem that we do have nights here in Australia, and it is only recently that batteries have got close to the break-even point in terms of cost. We also have large amounts of wind power, but again it comes at the cost of not being on 100% of the time. Again, storage can solve that as it continues to drop in price.
- prawn 9y agoHousehold solar is very popular at least. I think many Australians would appreciate that we are in a good position to exploit solar potential, but pitched as part of the green/renewable solution, it's quickly tied into tribal politics and people get a bit silly.
- thisrod 9y ago> we aren't building coal or nuclear because there are outrageous political risks This is a one sided way of putting it. The people who build coal plants in Australia say that they've stopped doing it because of climate change. The plants need to run for decades to pay off the cost of construction. The business people expect that, whoever is in charge of Australia, power plants will have to stop burning coal before then. The people who build nuclear plants say that there aren't enough Australians to buy their electricity, so anyone who tried to sell nuclear power in Australia would lose money. Again, regardless of the politics.
- nickik 9y agoI guess in another market somebody would bet on the nuclear and hope to draw people with lower prices. Lets see how deep the confections are. But since build those monsters is such a long process and the approval alone is so difficult already. If you want to develop something new, you can add a couple years to the project. The hope is China, they are selling mid-sized pebble generators and they should start producing them pretty soon for delivery in a couple of years.
- BLKNSLVR 9y ago> we aren't building coal or nuclear because there are outrageous political risks Wrong. We aren't building coal or nuclear for reasons of economics. The high electricity prices are partially due to gold-plating the poles and wires due to very odd 'oversight' agreements in which any investment in poles and wires infrastructure had a guaranteed return on investment - it allowed the infrastructure owners to increase their charges to cover the poles and wires investment, almost no matter how much they invested, so they went LARGE. High power prices are also partially due to the generators gaming the market in times of high power usage and low wind / solar generation. Making use of loopholes in the 20-year old rules. Loopholes that didn't exist when everything was coal, but caused by the fact that the rules haven't been updated to reflect the inclusion of wind and solar into the generation mix. The "Market Operator" had been asleep at the wheel for years. Politics is getting in the way of building Wind and Solar , not the other way round.