4 ms·
I was recently having a discussion with the founder of a very successful company. I was asking him how they got their start and their initial customers. They
by jedberg 9y ago
I was recently having a discussion with the founder of a very successful company. I was asking him how they got their start and their initial customers. They were not from the Silicon Valley originally.
He said it was slow going at first, until they moved to the Bay Area and started going to meetups. He said that meeting potential customers in person was what really accelerated their initial adoption, far more than their write-ups in the press or their "free customers" from their accelerator program.
My point is, that will be hard to replicate anywhere else for a long time. The density of startups and the opportunities that presents will be hard to have somewhere else -- it's a chicken and egg problem.
I had a friend who started a VC in Montreal. You know what happened as soon as the companies got successful? They took a round from a VC in the Bay Area and then moved here. They kept their dev office in Montreal for the "cheap labor" but made their HQ here.
I suspect that is what will happen with these investments too. Most of the companies will probably leave Ohio when they get successful.
And then they'll exit and have a bunch of money to invest where they now live -- the Bay Area.
- ourmandave 9y agoAnd it's probably cheaper to live in Ohio and fly to the office than pay SV rents.
- sidlls 9y agoIt isn't, unless we're talking a few flights per month at most.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI think you have to specialize on a certain industry, not just tech in general. Minnesota has quite a few startups in medical tech and there are big med tech companies there too that buy these startups. Same in Boston. That's an industry SV simply doesn't understand and being in SV is not an advantage. Banking may be a similar case.
- irrational 9y agoSame thing with athletic/outdoor apparel/footwear. There are so many companies headquartered in Portland, Oregon in this industry. It started with Nike, then Adidas and Columbia Sportswear. Now it seems like you can't throw a crampon without hitting another athletic/outdoor apparel/footwear startup.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI can imagine Walmart alone could sustain a bunch of logistics startups in Arkansas or wherever they are.
- new_hackers 9y agoyes, and the northwest arkansas corridor is a very pretty part of the country. But apparently for tech, they don't https://www.technologyreview.com/s/429589/walmarts-new-high-tech-labs-youre-not-in-arkansas-anymore/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/429589/walmarts-new-high-...
- tomhschmidt 9y agoNot sure what you're implying -- Adidas is German and both Adidas and Columbia pre-date Nike.
- cylinder 9y agoNot sure where you read a claim that Adidas was started in Portland. Adidas North America hq is located in Portland. https://www.adidas-group.com/en/group/headquarters/ https://www.adidas-group.com/en/group/headquarters/
- irrational 9y agoColumbia Sportswear is headquartered in Portland (just a mile or two north of Nike headquarters). Adidas USA is headquartered in North Portland.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- philsnow 9y ago10-30% of their exit will go back to ohio to be reinvested, too. that 10-30% goes a hell of a lot farther out there, where office rent is 1/10th and engineers cost 1/2 as much as bay area.
- yesimahuman 9y agoThe situation you describe will be positive for the Midwest. Many of those engineers at the dev office back home have options and, should the company have a successful exit, are well positioned to start new companies or angel invest, and do it where they are. This isn't going to happen overnight, and more teams and founders will stay put and still be successful over time. Plus, engineering is core to many tech startups. It's a big change in the industry that they are successful having the dev teams back home and bay area investors are cool with that! (disclaimer: I'm the founder of a midwest-startup with coastal VC)
- heymijo 9y agoYou're right. There has been no fundamental change, either internal to SV or external, to cause Silicon Valley to lose its status as the epicenter of the technology world and the unparalleled access to capital that the region enjoys [0]. Interestingly, Cleveland in the early 20th century provides a case study that compares favorably to modern Silicon Valley. The key? Access to capital. First, we have John D. Rockefeller and Standard Oil. Why did Rockefeller move Standard Oil's headquarters from Cleveland to New York City? Two main reasons: 1) a concentration of financiers that he needed to continue to grow his business and 2) oil was flowing to large port cities as the international markets grew exponentially lessening Cleveland's importance in the network. [1] These were both rational reasons for moving and the second represented a fundamental shift in the oil business. A research article into Cleveland's entrepreneurial decline in the 20th century points to a similar finding: "Additional contributing factors may include the destruction of the complementary financial institutions that had supported entrepreneurial ventures in the region and changes in the regulatory regime that advantaged New York and made it difficult for regional capital markets like Cleveland‘s to recover their earlier vibrancy." [2] In the early 1900's Cleveland was described as such: "It was also an important entrepreneurial center, with well-developed, largely informal, networks linking inventors to new sources of capital and to product markets." [2] This sounds a lot like Silicon Valley and especially what you describe in your comment. [0] Yes, cases could be made that housing in the Bay area, unfavorable immigration climate, increased competition from abroad, and even the maturation of the current mobile environment represent viable threats to the long-term entrepreneurial dominance of the Valley. [1] Titan: The Life of John D. Rockefeller by Ron Chernow [2] The Decline of an Innovative Region: Cleveland, Ohio, in the Twentieth Century by Naomi Lamoreaux and Margaret Levenstein http://www.econ.ucla.edu/people/papers/Lamoreaux/Lamoreaux472.pdf http://www.econ.ucla.edu/people/papers/Lamoreaux/Lamoreaux47...
- mycall 9y ago> There has been no fundamental change, either internal to SV or external, to cause Silicon Valley to lose its status as the epicenter of the technology world and the unparalleled access to capital that the region enjoys [ What about climate change and the impending major droughts in the next 5-10 years?
- zitterbewegung 9y agoYea, so incubators in other places serve as a new filter for startups. Makes sense.
- Apocryphon 9y agoI hope your friend's company in MTL isn't this one: https://www.busbud.com/blog/benefits-of-being-a-montreal-startup-developer/ https://www.busbud.com/blog/benefits-of-being-a-montreal-sta... It's a little disheartening whenever this kind of braindrain happens. This prevents other ecosystems from forming.