3 ms·
You can make a good argument that before agriculture, people lived in a "steady state" hunter gatherer society for at least hundreds of thousands of years, to w
by BurningFrog 9y ago
You can make a good argument that before agriculture, people lived in a "steady state" hunter gatherer society for at least hundreds of thousands of years, to which they were extremely well adapted adapted evolutionarily.
Let's repeat that because it's important and counterintuitive: Those conditions were ideal for us because our species changed to fit the conditions.
What's happened since is a crazy rollercoaster ride of life conditions changin much faster than evolution has any chance of keeping up with, and premodern society in the sense of preindustrial can in no way be presumed to be ideal.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 9y agoUmm, if you're gonna parrot vague evo-psych-anthropological arguments, they need to be more solid that this.
- euyyn 9y agoIdeal in the sense of "outcompeting the other animals of the time in terms of breeding". Far from ideal in the "I'd like to be happy" sense.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> for at least hundreds of thousands of years, to which they were extremely well adapted adapted evolutionarily. Hundreds of thousands of years is not a really long time in evolutionary terms, and evolution doesn't necessarily, even given a long time, get out of a good-enough local optimum to “extremely well adapted”. It's also debatable whether conditions in which humans evolved are really a steady state. More to the point, humans being ideal for the conditions—what the argument from evolution suggests—is not the same as the conditions being ideal for humans.
- BurningFrog 9y agoI thought about responding to these critics, but they don't really say much beyond "you never know!"/"don't be too sure!", so I'll leave things as is.
- jules 9y agoSpecies don't change so that the conditions become ideal for that species, species change so that the species is (close to) ideal for dealing with that environment. This is a very important distinction. Certain plants may grow in the desert with very little water, but that doesn't mean that they don't grow faster with more water.
- whack 9y agoDidn't people in early Hunter-gatherer societies have drastically lower life-expectancy, height and IQ as compared to modern humans living in industrialized nations? Evolution may not value those traits all that much, but we certainly do.
- BurningFrog 9y agoTrue, but it's not like diet is the only thing different between their lives and ours. I think violence, poverty and disease were the bigger factors. All I'm claiming is that our digestive system is adapted to what we had to eat where our species evolved.