3 ms·
That's an interesting idea. You'd still have an issue if the process has a very high standard deviation or a lot of outliers. You almost need some sort of usefu
by WorldMaker 9y ago
That's an interesting idea. You'd still have an issue if the process has a very high standard deviation or a lot of outliers. You almost need some sort of useful UX for the error bars of the progress (+/- 3%, +/- 15 minutes), but if polling statistics seems to prove anything, error bar UX is something that we have never been able to build in a way that a person with no to little statistical background can appreciate.
Tangentially, I've experimented with a different sort of "learning progress bar", in that I think one UX problem we face is that we've learned the hard way that linear progress bars aren't allowed to go backwards/shrink. It confuses/angers too many users to watch a progress shrink and gives the wrong impression that something has gone wrong or is being rolled back (that progress is somehow "lost").
This is a problem because a lot of our problem solutions are recursive and we don't have a full estimate of the problem scope until we've recursed the full depth to the leaves of the problem tree.
My experiment [1] was with the idea that with a radial progress bar you can "shrink" it, but still give an indication of "forward" progress (clockwise movement in this case). You get to take advantage of the fact that perceptually people can tell the difference between small increments linearly, but not small increments radially (the reason why pie charts are actually not particularly great UX if you need someone to perceive subtle differences). It seems like a "best of both worlds" approach in that in the task discovery phase it acts like a "spinner" and as discovery completes it becomes more of a progress bar, and if for some reason a bunch of new tasks are discovered mid-flight you get a hybrid of the two.
[1] GitHub: https://github.com/WorldMaker/compradprog https://github.com/WorldMaker/compradprog ; Blog post: http://blog.worldmaker.net/2015/03/17/compradprog/ http://blog.worldmaker.net/2015/03/17/compradprog/ ; Demo site is currently broken (hello tech debt from 2015), sorry