4 ms·
Heartily agreeing. If the Reals are fundamentally the set of all points that make up a line, the "imaginary numbers" are the set of all 2d points in a plane. Tu
by roenxi 9y ago
Heartily agreeing. If the Reals are fundamentally the set of all points that make up a line, the "imaginary numbers" are the set of all 2d points in a plane. Turns out there was never a call to limit numbers to living in a straight line, but our notation was settled on before we realised that. I'm got grumpy just earlier this evening that the first 9 negative numbers didn't get their own glyphs.
i is basically "rotate by 90" in the same way -1 is "head left from 0 instead of right"
- globuous 9y ago> If the Reals are fundamentally the set of all points that make up a line, the "imaginary numbers" are the set of all 2d points in a plane I'm not sure that's true. It's a very good way to visualize complex numbers at first, but the set of points in a 2D plane does not define complex numbers. That's a very interesting question actually, what is the difference between R^2 != C ? Here's someone's attempt at showing this (top answer): https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/444475/whats-the-difference-between-mathbbr2-and-the-complex-plane https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/444475/whats-the-di... To me, trying to visualize complex numbers is an easy way to forget that R^2 != C.... They look the same but don't behave the same way (how do you multiply to members of R^2 with each other ? you need to define it, whereas multiplication in C is already defined). C doesn't behave like 2D vectors either. Since multiplying 2 complex is not the same as multiplying 2 vectors (whatever that means) although their components could be the same. structure structure structure.
- zardo 9y ago>(how do you multiply to members of R^2 with each other ? you need to define it, whereas multiplication in C is already defined) You can use the geometric product, and C falls out as a result.
- yequalsx 9y agoComplex numbers along with the Quaternions are the only finite dimensional associative division algebras that properly contain the reals. The interesting thing is that the 2d real space can be equipped with a multiplication operation that works. This isn’t always possible to do on a finite dimensional real vector space. It happens to be true that this field called the complex numbers is a two dimensional real vector space. It took humans quite a long time to come up with 0 and negative numbers. There’s no way the jump to the complex numbers was going to be as easy and it isn’t as simple as, “numbers in 2d”. Why isn’t 3D a finite dimensional associative division algebra?
- Meegul 9y agoYou speak of a multiplication operation that "works", also stating that it's not always possible for a finite dimensional real vector space. Doesn't the definition of a real vector space require multiplication that "works" (through the scalar multiplication requirement) or are you referring to the multiplication between vectors within that space "working"?
- yequalsx 9y agoMultiplication of vectors. That’s the meaning of the algebra word in the phrase, finite dimensional associative division algebra. In R^3 you can’t define multiplication of vectors in a way that works. That is, in a way that each vector can be multiplied by itself and in which each vector has a multiplicative inverse while preserving the real vector space structure.
- Meegul 9y agoThanks! I'm still in the process of really grokking linear algebra as I only just took a class on it, so this is helpful.
- sjy 9y agoThe set of all points in a plane is ℝ², not ℂ. ℂ has many special properties that aren't shared by ℝ²,[1] so while you can think of ℝ as just the number line, ℂ is more than just a plane. [1]: https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/444475/whats-the-difference-between-mathbbr2-and-the-complex-plane https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/444475/whats-the-di...
- posterboy 9y agoin the same way the imaginary numbers are more than the real number line, i * ℝ != ℝ.
- beagle3 9y ago> Turns out there was never a call to limit numbers to living in a straight line There is no reason to limit to the plane either[0]. Or four dimensions for that matter[1]. Complex numbers have ways in which they are "more fundamental" than quaternions in the same ways that reals are "more fundamental" than complex numbers. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quaternion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quaternion [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Octonion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Octonion