3 ms·
We're not sleepingwalking into war. Rather, it's just that everybody in the U.S., liberal and conservative, scholar and layman, is in willful denial about the s
by wahern 9y ago
We're not sleepingwalking into war. Rather, it's just that everybody in the U.S., liberal and conservative, scholar and layman, is in willful denial about the stark choices we face.
Negotiation is not an option: North Korea has been racing in earnest to both build a bomb and a delivery vehicle since at least the 1980s. Their entire social and political system is predicated on radical self-reliance. This notion plays itself out in every facet of their system, from the cult of personality to the structure of their corrupt economy. It's neither coincidence nor mere opportunism that North Korea has proliferated both nuclear and ballistic missile technology across the world for decades. Nuclear weapons technology simultaneously offers them both military and economic security. North Korea will never willingly give up nuclear weapons. They can't. The political regime and relinquishing nuclear weapons are effectively mutually exclusive.
That leaves 3 stark choices: a nuclear North Korea[1], war, or Chinese-forced regime change.
But no mainstream American political party will accept a nuclear North Korea, especially given North Korea's proven desire and ability to proliferate. And China, for various complex reasons, has been steadfast in refusing to topple the regime. That means American politics has been moving inexorably toward war with North Korea and will continue doing so unless and until war breaks out or China capitulates. In the meantime--which could extend (and hopefully will extend) into the indefinite future--we'll just put our heads in the sand and ignore the very thing we keep swearing we'd never accept.
The denial exhibits itself in weird ways. The conservatives keep shifting attention to Iran. North Korea is light-years ahead of Iran in terms of being both a nuclear threat and in manifest capacity to proliferate nuclear weapons. But war with NK is simply unpalatable, and as conservatives prefer unilateralism to compromise their only political move has been to ignore NK and focus on Iran, whom they're currently comfortable bombing.
Liberals, by contrast, both refuse to entertain a military solution[2] and refuse to admit that a negotiated settlement has eluded negotiators for decades. The Clinton, Bush, Obama, and even Trump[3] administrations have pursued compromise in earnest. Only the most cynical of observers would argue that the U.S. hasn't pursued a settlement in good faith. But NK's bait+switch in the 1990s, increasing intransigence, and continued proliferation have made negotiation increasingly difficult for each successive administration. Good faith does not mean gullible. And, in any event, it's no mystery why NK won't sign away their nuclear capability.
Obama's deal with Iran really screwed everything up. The deal meant conservatives could no longer shift attention to Iran, which had benefitted the liberals by making the perennial failures with NK less pressing (and memorable).
Of course, Obama made the deal with Iran precisely because NK was the actual immediate threat, and kicking the Iran problem (such as it was) down the road was the intelligent strategic choice. But as a Muslim Kenyan, perhaps only Obama was capable of seeing the obvious truth that every real American denies.
Unfortunately, the deal had the effect of turning the NK situation into a crisis overnight, despite literally nothing changing. NK has been on the exact same trajectory it's been on for decades. The time for freaking out was when they began exploding nuclear devices 10+ years ago, not the next stepwise iteration of their missile technology.
Because America is not capable of accepting a nuclear NK, either formally or informally, and because NK is not capable of forgoing a nuclear deterrent, the options are stark. That doesn't mean war is inevitable, only that the direction is inevitable. The end game, should it arrive--as opposed to the crisis, with ever increasing risks of conflict in East Asia, being drawn out indefinitely--is either war or a deal with China that realigns power in the Pacific.
The upshot is that the only country to be negotiating with is China. What will it take for the Chinese to topple the North Korean regime? It might take a lot because, even if they're amenable to a deal, we probably overestimate their ability to force regime change.
[1] Which we already live with, technically. North Korea currently just lacks first-strike capabilities. Which surely they'll remedy in the next year or two.
[2] Which, strategically, could be useful in negotiating with China. A credible imminent threat of war (stick) combined with a realignment of power in the Pacific (carrot) might bring China around.
[3] Rex Tillerson's recent, frantic offer for "unconditional", bilateral talks is evidence of this. We can't blame the hardline tactics of the Bush or Trump administrations. The diplomats have been earnest, and if the diplomats saw light at the end of the tunnel no administration would be able to hide that. But even diplomats from the Clinton and Obama administrations have no idea how to proceed.
- ramphastidae 9y agoCan you explain to this liberal American what is so wrong with North Korea having nuclear weapons? I realize a lot of nasty bluster has been exchanged between the U.S. and N.K., but besides their post-occupation invasion of South Korea in 1948, are there tangible examples of N.K. military invasions or attacks on other nations since its founding? N.K. is poor, vulnerable and under constant threat of destabilization by the West. In today's geopolitical landscape, the only way to defend against being "liberated" by the U.S., as Iraq or Libya was, is to have a nuclear weapon. If you were N.K., wouldn't you do the same as an act of self-preservation?
- maxharris 9y agoCurrently there are nine nations that have nuclear weapons. How long do you think you'll survive in a world where fifty nations have them? Mutually-assured destruction doesn't prevent catastrophe if the majority of at least one nation's leadership truly believes in the afterlife!
- wahern 9y agoI think there are many excuses, but the biggest and most reasonable issue is proliferation. North Korea has sold not only its ballistic missile technology, not only chemical weapons technology, but nuclear weapons technology. See, e.g., https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/will-north-korea-sell-its-nuclear-technology/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/will-north-korea-... Now, you might argue that it only does this because of sanctions. But NK has repeatedly eschewed normalization in favor of pursuing it's weapons programs. The examples of nuclear proliferation in the article above occurred _before_ sanctions were even imposed. The problem is the regime: normalization of economic ties would result in the downfall of the Kim regime. The entire social and political structure of the country is built around the militarist cult of personality. The country has pursued the same path for over 50 years, 3 rulers, and the (de jure or de facto) transition of every other Communist and authoritarian regime from the post-WWII era. It's not a coincidence that is has, singularly, survived. And it's totally naive to think the regime would change now. The regime has persisted only because of it's radical rejection of normalization with the world. That rejection of normalization doesn't mean a rejection of all international economic ties. But for various reasons the safest trade is black market trade as the scope is more easily controlled from the top. That said, I think it's reasonable to accept a nuclear NK, as long as you're honest about the nuclear proliferation risk. Believing that NK could keep nuclear weapons without proliferation of nuclear tech would be willful denial. A realistic scenario is NK selling nuclear tech with the West expending resources to take it off the streets again, like the War on Drugs. Yet like the War on Drugs the result will be a lot of death as the U.S. often prefers using bullets to money, especially internationally. Over years and decades it will hasten the relative decline of American power as the perpetual conflict exposes the U.S. as ineffectual. China, like now, just sits on the sidelines watching the U.S. burn through political capital faster than cheap Chinese imports. (Which is one of several reasons China isn't eager to see either NK regime change or even the removal of nuclear weapons from NK. Interests in China and, especially, Russia see significant value in the pressures the NK problem imposes on the U.S.) And that scenario excludes the issue of Japan remilitarizing. I think that aspect is overemphasized, partly because it's easier to articulate than it is to articulate the increase in amorphous geopolitical conflict that would be caused (and has been caused) by the steady supply of NK arms, including WMD arms, in the global black market. In short, a nuclear NK inevitably means nuclear proliferation because the regime favors (and must favor) black market trade to sustain itself. Depending on your calculus, that could easily be the least worst scenario. But by no means is it a nice outcome, and it's not the kind of strategic compromise Americans are amenable to, especially in modern times. IMO, the path with the least violence is Chinese engineered regime change. Say, Kim Jong-un disappearing on a trip to Beijing. But that's the most difficult outcome to achieve because it requires Americans not only being realistic about the alternatives, but also making some very hard and (most importantly for domestic politics) explicit strategic compromises with China in the Pacific. I imagine the U.S. would have to be prepared, at least in principle, to capitulate on Taiwan or the South China Sea (or both), and then hope negotiators could secure a less costly quid pro quo. FWIW, I think a lot of countries, including some European countries, are prepared to accept a nuclear NK today, either formally or informally. But there is no tidy resolution to the problem of proliferation except to either deny or ignore it. It's easier to ignore if you're not the U.S., because everybody around the world has basically relied on the U.S. to stop and punish proliferation. If you remember the Syrian chemical attacks, the British, French, and Germans excoriated Obama for not retaliating, yet none were prepared to retaliate themselves.[1] [1] That's another example where Obama's (belated) strategic clarity had the unintended consequence of exposing something unspeakable about the global order.