9 ms·
>The amount of negative press this received nearly cancels out all the positive news from Quantum's release barely a month ago. I call complete and total BS on
by unethical_ban 9y ago
>The amount of negative press this received nearly cancels out all the positive news from Quantum's release barely a month ago.
I call complete and total BS on this. I may not be on the EFF echo-chamber, and I agree they handled this poorly, but this absolutely does not concern me after hearing the way th add-on behaved. They made a mistake in communications and behavior that should have been expected, but as they said, it did zero data collection and performance impact. It was a screw-up they have fixed via process.
If people are so upset at Firefox for a mostly innocuous mess-up that was quickly caled out and clarified/fixed in the future, that they would dump Firefox for the hero of privacy Chrome, they are very foolish in my opinion.
- nvr219 9y agoI agree completely. I'm not leaving Firefox over this. They made a silly mistake, with no sinister motivations (can't confidently say the same about any other major browser)
- blub 9y agoYes, one silly mistake would not be so bad. But they also ramped up their telemetry and also installed cliqz. Three strikes... and I'm using Safari, because this seems to be the least bad right now. Pretty lame from Mozilla. Edit: forgot about Pocket.
- dmix 9y agoIt's a good example of the outrage culture we live in, and have incentivized on social media, being taken very seriously when it reality the issues have very little real affect on peoples lives... Firefox handled a mess up very well. The extension was always opt-in and never extracted any data. It came from a trusted source regardless via another layer of opt-in experiment beta testing. Yes it wasn't cool they chose poor language and didn't fully consider the implications of installing a 'fun' experiment. But lets keep our shirts on. Quantum has been more than rewarding and this minor PR issue is hardly deterring me from using Firefox... especially compared with Chrome being built by the biggest ad company in the world.
- blub 9y agoIt is pretty outrageous to have one's computer and information be at the mercy of every software developer out there who thinks it's their divine right to collect information about you and how you use their product, to force install software on your computer and generally treat you - the customer - with contempt. So yes, people will be outraged. We're sick of being taken advantage of by dishonest companies and individuals because the US privacy laws are a complete joke.
- ddalex 9y agoOne caveat, you are the consumer, not the customer. Subtle, but important difference.
- rmrfrmrf 9y agoI think my issue is that everything about this plugin — from the marketing tie-in, to the rollout, to the effects of the plugin itself once activated — all indicate a complete breakdown of core values. Creating a plugin that modifies content on your screen and injects HTTP headers is egregious enough (just look at the response Comcast got for doing it), but doing it for a TV show tie-in? How did that idea even make it through one round of approvals, much less land on every Firefox user’s machine? Users trust web browsers to deliver the exact content that was requested — that’s why we have gpg signatures, hashsums, and HTTPS. It’s arguably a core tenet of the web. IMO the reaction of the tech community can only be expected in response to such a deep violation of trust.
- ufo 9y agoThere are plenty of people who don't care about the santicity of delivered web content, as can be seen by the popularity of things such as the cloud-to-butt extension. And I am sure that the die hard Mr robot fans that are the target audience for this ARG wouldn't have seen anything wrong with that extension. As you said, the real issue here is the terrible decision to push this to everyone.
- balladeer 9y agoHere's another perspective - I am not coming to Firefox over this. After literally years of struggle with Chrome and Firefox I finally switched to Safari (recently I switched to iPhone so on mobile too) and yes for personal browsing, on a Mac, this is really better than any other browser out there and Quantum felt as good. No, I don't have benchmarking scores, but I am speaking from an end user point of view. I was a lifetime Firefox user - started browsing on it when I bought my first laptop in 2007 and never touched anything else until Pocket happened and after testing Quantum for a few days I was so happy that the Firefox is back. I don't think so. I guess I will sit this one out. It's not an isolated incident. They have been doing it constantly since Pocket.
- blacksmith_tb 9y agoAre you using uBlock[1]? It seems like an awkward process to go through, compared to FF (or Chrome/ium)... 1: https://github.com/el1t/uBlock-Safari https://github.com/el1t/uBlock-Safari
- balladeer 9y agoYes, I use this extension. Update etc aren't as smooth in Chrome/FF but I haven't faced any major issue. GitHub issues section is quite active and there are helpful users.
- pooper 9y ago> I'm not leaving Firefox over this. Of course, I am not leaving. The CMO should be leaving!
- youdontknowtho 9y agoI may seem naïve but I'm kind of constantly surprised that people take this attitude with open source. Nothing is stopping one of these people from building FF from source and having exact total control over how it behaves. Instead they farm that part out and then get upset when this group of people who have alleviated you of that work make a mistake? It's just extreme entitlement.
- EpicEng 9y ago>Nothing is stopping one of these people from building FF from source and having exact total control over how it behaves. Yeah, but since it doesn't have an entire dev team committed to it, the fork dies and/or you're using an out of date browser with all sorts of security vulnerabilities and incompatibilities. Some attempts with actual resources behind them: Cyberfox - dead PCXFirefox - latest merge was FF 53. Using outdated plugins (e.g. Sumatra PDF from 2014!) Waterfox - dead Pale Moon - Still alive. Removes a host of features (e.g. Accessibility and Parental Controls) in the name of performance, yet performs horribly in benchmarks. Slow to adopt new features. Besides, who's going to use these? A tiny fraction of the population consisting of people reading this thread and threads like it? Who cares? So yeah, you _could_ "just" fork FF, but it won't get you anywhere. And why the hell am I doing this? I have much better things to do with my time than maintain my own damn web browser. I am constantly amazed at comments like this which are so obtuse as to be comical.
- axlprose 9y ago> Waterfox - dead Since when? It's last commit was 5 days ago: https://github.com/MrAlex94/Waterfox https://github.com/MrAlex94/Waterfox
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- interfixus 9y ago> Waterfox - dead I never would have guessed. Browsing this thread and writing this comment in my sparkling brand new Waterfox 56. > Pale Moon - Still alive [...] Slow to adopt new features Slow or reluctant by design. A fork from way back before FF started dismantling its UI. Many new 'features' will never be adopted by Pale Moon. Snark is fine, but please base it on fact.
- TAForObvReasons 9y ago> they would dump Firefox for the hero of privacy Chrome Wrote this in a previous discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15940491 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15940491 >> updates have been known to re-enable it if you turn it off ... But it doesn’t matter - you’re going to re-enable it on the next update. > It's surprising how ... trustworthy Chrome is in this regard. My default search engine is set to DDG and through countless updates Chrome has never once attempted to reset it to Google. Even though Chrome has every incentive to break privacy settings, even though Chrome has every incentive to revert the default search engine to Google, they don't.
- rodorgas 9y agoIt’s very sad that they reset some privacy preferences on updates. It can be explained by incompetence or bad faith, but coming from Mozilla I'd rather assume incompetence.
- qbaqbaqba 9y agoIt's not sad: it's illegal - as long as the EU is concerned.
- mintplant 9y agoIn its default configuration Chrome's sync service uses transport-only encryption, not end-to-end, so that Google can read all your history, cookies, and so on. Their privacy policy [0] allows Google to mine this data for its own purposes. I would wager a very, very small proportion of Chrome's userbase manually enables the end-to-end sync encryption option buried in the settings; even technically-minded friends I've told about this are usually surprised. So Chrome's privacy settings are already broken by default, in nearly the worst way they could be. [0] https://www.google.com/chrome/browser/privacy/index.html https://www.google.com/chrome/browser/privacy/index.html, "Signed-in Chrome mode"
- TAForObvReasons 9y agoYou completely sidestepped the issue at hand: >> [Firefox] updates have been known to re-enable it if you turn it off ... But it doesn’t matter - you’re going to re-enable it on the next update. You can choose to opt out of Chrome's phoning home in the privacy settings and they haven't tried to revert those settings in an update (and given their track record, I have no reason to believe they will try to surreptitiously change the settings in a future release)
- axlprose 9y agoIt isn't just about the recent PR mishap, it's about a long string of events that have gradually tried their users' patience and erroded their trust: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qMALm1VthGY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qMALm1VthGY It's also disingenuous to present a false dichotomy with Chrome, as if there weren't any other privacy-focused alternatives out there: https://www.waterfoxproject.org/ https://www.waterfoxproject.org/ https://brave.com/ https://brave.com/ https://iridiumbrowser.de/ https://iridiumbrowser.de/ https://www.palemoon.org/ https://www.palemoon.org/ https://www.gnu.org/software/icecat/ https://www.gnu.org/software/icecat/
- space_fountain 9y agoDo any of them have a decent chance of success? Or are they doomed to struggle to copy chromes features. Doomed to break because no one tests against them?
- axlprose 9y agoIf your goal is utmost privacy like many of these projects are providing, you're already going to expect and experience some breakages regardless. Any browser is going to struggle against the top two behemoths, so I'm not sure why exactly that would be an argument to just accept it and continue using products by companies that have lost your trust. Are end users supposed to compromise their ethics just because web developers aren't in the habit of testing against their browser of choice yet? That just seems like an awfully 'silicon-valley-centric' view of the world. What does this "success" thing have to do with ditching a product that had violated your trust anyway? Are businesses in most other industries viewed this way? Am I expected to stop buying food from local producers just because the big-box food suppliers are more ubiquitous? To me, all that matters is sustainability, and IceCat has been going strong for 12 years, PaleMoon has been consistently developed for 8 years, and Waterfox for 6 years. So that's enough for me to at least give them a shot.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- 9y ago
- madeofpalk 9y agoMaybe it's both? This move is a complete slap-to-the-face for everything that Mozilla and Firefox supposedly stands for, and would be heartbreaking for the developers to hear that this is going on in the wake of all the work around "Quantum" and everything else they've won with recently. But really, this Mr Robot news went no further than an article on The Verge (I presume it even got there?). More importantly, those that care are able to think critically of the situation and don't really have anywhere better to go.
- frik 9y ago>> The amount of negative press this received nearly cancels out all the positive news from Quantum's release barely a month ago. > I call complete and total BS on this. Well it's the truth. Use "Google News" and search for Firefox. You will see much more news sites write about the fiasco last weekend then about a faster Firefox. And guess what, rather rude comments came from employee trying to clean up by voting down comments hours too late. It's time to fire the responsible marketing manager/exec. Mozilla is setup as a non-profit org but acts like a unicorn startup, playing rich and flying in all employees every 6 months, that also happened on that very day, so the corporate drones couldn't response and clean up the outcry in time.
- blub 9y agoThis is one more anti-privacy move from Mozilla in a series of such moves. I am now using Safari and have to keep an eye on the family computer to see what crap Mozilla decides to install next. The nice thing about ethical organisations is that you can have peace of mind and don't have to worry about how they're going to screw you when their marketing department runs amok. Because of cliqz, the annoying telemetry (aka spyware) and this incident, I don't trust Mozilla any more. Moving to Chrome would indeed be silly, bit it doesn't mean things are rosy.
- catach 9y ago> This is one more anti-privacy move from Mozilla in a series of such moves. It definitely sucks, but I don't see how it was anti-privacy at all. The extension didn't transmit data anywhere, it just modified web pages.
- Vinnl 9y agoIt didn't even do that unless you explicitly turned on a flag in about:config.
- xenophonf 9y ago> it just modified web pages That's Mozilla taking another step down a very slippery slope. "It didn't hurt anyone" doesn't excuse ethical or moral wrongs. Given Mozilla's stated commitments to privacy and integrity, their choice here violated them.
- sangnoir 9y ago> It definitely sucks, but I don't see how it was anti-privacy at all. It definitely increased the attack surface area[1] with no upside for 99.9%[2] of Firefox users. 1. It's a juicy target: an addon that can modify the content of any page a user visits? It doesn't take much of an imagination to think of how this could be subverted. 2. My conservertive guess of the fraction of Fx users not interested in Mr Robot easter eggs; I probably ought to add a couple more "9"s
- stordoff 9y agoOn the other hand, I was in the process of moving over to using Firefox as my main browser, and this has me reconsidering that decision. Chrome is far from perfect (and chances are I'll move to Firefox or some fork anyway because the main process in Chrome keeps seemingly pegging one core [constant 20-25% CPU usage]), but they haven't made the obvious mistakes Firefox has (adding Pocket to the default browser, the handling of this extension) and I generally feel it stays more out of your way (probably a personal dislike of mine, but I wasn't fond of opening Add-on settings and it presenting a list of suggested stuff to install).
- Vinnl 9y agoIndeed. I get that people are upset about this, and might even switch to Pale Moon/Waterfox/what have you, but those that switched to Chrome? Whatever your reasons for switching are, privacy really cannot be it.
- catach 9y ago> Whatever your reasons for switching are, privacy really cannot be it. In a universe where no one is ever wrong about facts, sure.
- tapoxi 9y agoI switched to Chromium, because I get the performance of Chrome without any surprises.
- TremendousJudge 9y agocongratulations
- option_greek 9y agoMay be you don't have any sensitive info being accessed day in and day out but some of us do. And we trust firefox with it. I panicked when I saw the add-on because I use the same browser for trading as well.