3 ms·
I thought the phrase "Titles are 80% of the work" did not match the exposition in TFA. Consider these three interpretations: 1. "Titles are 80% of the work" de
by braythwayt 9y ago
I thought the phrase "Titles are 80% of the work" did not match the exposition in TFA. Consider these three interpretations:
1. "Titles are 80% of the work" describes how much effort he puts into the title, and how much he suggests.
2. "Titles are 80% of the value" describes how much value readers personally get from your work, regardless of whether they share it or not.
3. "Titles are 80% of the signal that determines whether a blog post is shared on social media" describes how much they drive sharing, and suggests that a good title is worthy of a non-trivial amount of thought.
I personally feel he was trying to say #3, and definitely not trying to say #2. But he literally wrote #1, and somebody might be deluded into reasoning as follows:
If you ought to spend 80% of your time on the title, and if it's responsible for 80% of the sharing, and all you care about is sharing, then it follows naturally that you want to put 80% of your time into it (#1), and that since you only put 20% of your time into the content, and since it only contributes 20% to whether you get ephemerally famous, it needn't provide more than 20% value to the reader (#2).
But despite that, I feel he was trying to say #3 only.
- ppeetteerr 9y agoYou're correct, but the wording is the kind of cheap, buzzwordy advice that we regularly see online. The post literally opens up with "I want to cross-pollinate a tweetstorm on lessons I’ve learned..." Instead of spending so much time on the headline, he could have spent some more spellchecking. Don't get me wrong, a good title will draw me in, but the content better match my expectation if I am to come back for another post.
- braythwayt 9y agoCertainly. I might have written, "A good title is necessary, but not sufficient. But still necessary! So don't neglect it." But then again, that might not get as many retweets as, "Titles are 80% of the work." Popularity is merciless and entirely orthogonal to quality.