51 ms·
My initial reaction was 'awesome', very cool, and just what the publishing industry needs. I hate the idea that each publisher is going to try to create their o
by pedalpete 16y ago
My initial reaction was 'awesome', very cool, and just what the publishing industry needs. I hate the idea that each publisher is going to try to create their own 'app' and we'd end up with huge images and inconsistent layouts, etc.
However, is a column/page based layout really the best we can do with modern UIs? Pages between different sites/articles makes sense, but within a single article, I always found it to be a sacred cow. Same with columns. I know columns are faster to skim, but isn't there something better?
Maybe this is just a way to get a foot in the door with publishers so you are giving them something familiar, but I think a new standard will be introduced into the publishing world to better fit the technology now that we are no longer bound by the limitations of paper.
- fortes 16y ago> However, is a column/page based layout really the best we can do with modern UIs? This is a great question, with no clear answer yet (requires more experimentation in my opinion). One issue I've run into when designing for this is that, without columns, it's hard to use the full width on wide screens. You're left with a ton of blank space on either side of your content. Once you flow text into columns, you end up needing to page, because scrolling and columns don't mix (you'd have to scroll down to the end of the first column, then scroll back up to the beginning of the next -- it's terrible).
- dhimes 16y agoFrom the parent: Maybe this is just a way to get a foot in the door with publishers so you are giving them something familiar I think this is an important point. If you can get your foot in the door by making them comfortable, you can drive a new UI with their help: private beta, asking for feedback, etc.
- nsfmc 16y ago> I hate the idea that each publisher is going to try to create their own 'app' and we'd end up with huge images and inconsistent layouts, etc. This variety is exactly what is amazing about books, magazines and all media: imagine if wired looked like the new yorker. The whole point of 'new media' is not abandoning design, otherwise we'd just read our blogs and websites in w3m. The point of treesaver (from what i glean) is not to abandon design, but merely to provide a basis for creating a more sensible ui for engaging with rich media that adapts to the viewport. The revelation that this design offers is adapting multiple variations of the design based on the current viewport size. (as a dynamic version of http://www.alistapart.com/articles/responsive-web-design/ http://www.alistapart.com/articles/responsive-web-design/) I wrote about this but without a generic demo a while back here: http://nsfmc.tumblr.com/post/647010330/pages-the-fold-and-measures http://nsfmc.tumblr.com/post/647010330/pages-the-fold-and-me... and also here http://nsfmc.tumblr.com/post/468243524/revisiting-newspaper-typography http://nsfmc.tumblr.com/post/468243524/revisiting-newspaper-... good work, and if people run with this sort of usability and create multiple, good looking apps, all the better.