3 ms·
Thats not studies on sexless-ness, but rather plain discrimination. There are many such studies, some which favor men and some which favor women, but all falls
by belorn 9y ago
Thats not studies on sexless-ness, but rather plain discrimination. There are many such studies, some which favor men and some which favor women, but all falls within typical gender roles and expectations. Sexless-ness and gender roles are opposites.
Lets bring in other similar studies. Physiologist that work for the juridical system and makes decisions about the mental status of accused criminals. Identical submitted profiles with female names received twice the number of judgments on being criminal insane than men, resulting in more lenient punishment and more time in medical care. Physiologist outside of the juridical system has also got similar studies where identical profiles of clinical depressed people, and women are twice as likely to be correctly diagnosed. A female name is more likely to get social support while being homeless, and similarly if you test judges who decide over family disputes you see a clear bias.
Neither of those involve a society which practice sexless-ness. All dictate that professionals (including those in government) treat both women and men equally. Culturally we do not practice sexless-ness and we are nowhere near in abolishing gender roles. What the studies do prove is that gender roles has still a major impact on people in professional positions and rules of equality do not trump peoples expectations when the only clue to a gender is a name.
- fatbird 9y agoThere are many, many studies of the justice system in the U.S. showing very biased outcomes depending on factors like gender or race. Practicing sexless-ness is, as you observe, what's supposed to be done already ("All dictate that professionals... treat both women and men equally"). Do you think we believe that we're practicing sexless-ness and then not doing so in practice? Or that there are unconscious or systemic effects at play as well that conscious dedication to sexless-ness isn't affecting?
- belorn 9y agoI do not think anyone is practicing sexless-ness at all. While the law says that they should treat both women and men equally, people still perceive women as women and men as men. That in turn carries with a huge number of cultural expectations and values. Race has a similar problem, through here it seems to be a proxy for social economical status (class), which then leads to the cultural expectations and values. In both cases it seems very conscious behavior, and when it comes to diversity work its explicitly so. Few are still preaching that you should not see gender or race, and those that do are generally attacked for doing so. Gender roles are emphasized and highlighted in practically all form of news and cultural media, occasionally reversed for the shock or comedy effect. Its very explicit and conscious.
- fatbird 9y agoYou're conflating an intent to practice sexless-ness with the actuality of it. You're right that we're not practicing it--everywhere we look we see inequity that's obvious tied to gender (or race, or disability...). But we think we are, or at least that we're trying. We've spent a century disassembling laws and customs that treat women differently, and yet the inequities remain. Why are you so hostile to the idea that we're not all that conscious of our lack of sexless-ness in application? That the inequities of sexism are at least partly systemic and not a conscious choice to be discriminatory?