10 ms·
What are the complex numbers, really?
- techno_modus 9y ago> So what are the complex numbers, really? If by reality we mean the real world (not mathematics or some abstract model) then the article does not actually answer the question what the complex numbers are really -- they describe what complex numbers mean mathematically (geometrically, algebraically, number theory). Here are some interpretations of imaginary and real parts in terms of the real (physical) world: o Time vs. space. This means that they have to be measured using different constituents with different properties. For example, space is reversible and periodic (we can return to the same point where we were before many times while it is not possible to return to previous point in time). o Periodic vs. monotonic behavior. For example, rotation frequencies or oscillators (electric or physical) vs. linear motion.
- jonsen 9y agoWell the article does mention: If beauty doesn't motivate you sufficiently, then take solace in the fact that the properties of some differential equations which arise in physics and engineering are determined by polynomials you can build out of them, and the systems modelled by these differential equations are stable if the real part of all the roots are negative. Google for control theory to see lots more. and This turns out to be a useful way of thinking about alternating current, and you can analyse AC circuits using complex arithmetic in much the same way as you use real algebra to analyse DC circuits. and ... did you read it all?
- jwilk 9y agoFrom the HN guidelines: Please don't insinuate that someone hasn't read an article. "Did you even read the article? It mentions that" can be shortened to "The article mentions that."
- techno_modus 9y agoThis turns out to be a useful way of thinking about alternating current, and you can analyse AC circuits using complex arithmetic in much the same way as you use real algebra to analyse DC circuits. "Userful way of thinking" and "analyse" something is not a real object strictly speaking - it is a process or phenomenon (no doubt complex numbers are useful here). But can you say what kind of real object or property a complex number represents or measures? For example, an integer can represent the number of apples and their weight is represented by a real number. What property of a real object can be expressed, for example, as 50i ?
- jondubois 9y agoI think the best description of what a complex number really is was 'a bookkeeping device'. The other descriptions were merely circular references to other mathematical inventions. The bookkeeping explanation is still not satisfying for me though.
- akvadrako 9y agoWhy not? Everything you can do with complex numbers, you can also do without them - they just make things easier.
- snaky 9y ago"By making our numbers 'more complicated', the methods we use to work with those numbers may become more simple."
- ColinWright 9y agoBy making our programming languages more complex, we make our programs easier. By pushing the common complexity into a shared location, problems become easier to solve. Complex numbers really do factor out a lot of the complexity from many problems, at comparatively little cost. When people say they don't "get" complex numbers, usually they mean they've seen them mentioned, but have never actually done anything with them. It's like staying that you've read a book on lisp and don't get it. Using these things is an essential part of coming to understand them.
- techno_modus 9y ago> When people say they don't "get" complex numbers, usually they mean they've seen them mentioned, but have never actually done anything with them. What people complain about is that they do not have a (real or hypothetical) device which can display its measurements as a complex number while they do have devices which measure properties in terms of integer, rational and real numbers.
- mathgenius 9y ago> Periodic vs. monotonic behavior. Another way to say this: imaginary versus real exponentials.
- rom16384 9y agoIn Physics the complex i is used for different purposes, which makes it seem more complex that it really is. My favorite explanation of complex numbers is the paper "Imaginary Numbers are not Real – the Geometric Algebra of Spacetime" [1] which shows what the complex i actually is in terms of Clifford Algebras. [1] http://geometry.mrao.cam.ac.uk/1993/01/imaginary-numbers-are-not-real-the-geometric-algebra-of-spacetime/ http://geometry.mrao.cam.ac.uk/1993/01/imaginary-numbers-are...
- asavinov 9y agoI like this idea of representing inner (dot, scalar) product and outer product as one construct with two constituents which behaves like a complex number. This analogy with geometry makes complex numbers more realistic.
- jonsen 9y agoThere's a phenomenon where I think you can sense the physical reality of complex numbers. When to propagating waves meet, and they are of opposite phase, they cancel out. At the meeting point the combined amplitude becomes zero. Despite of apparently total cancelation the two waves emerge undisturbed on the other side of the "silent" point. A wave can be described with rotating complex numbers of constant modulus. The two waves will each have its own modulus intact even at the point of cancelation. So the sum-to-zero real value is not really real.
- sxp 9y agoI'm wary of anyone who tries to explain complex numbers without pictures. The best explanation of complex numbers that I've ever seen is http://acko.net/blog/how-to-fold-a-julia-fractal/ http://acko.net/blog/how-to-fold-a-julia-fractal/. I wish that explaination existed when I was struggling with my Electrical Engineering classes in college.
- arkj 9y agoThank you for the brilliant link. I've been looking for a good explanation on complex numbers to share with a few struggling students.
- Grue3 9y agoI'd rather be wary of explaining mathematical concepts with pictures. Pictures are known to be highly misleading and force the reader to imagine a thing in a certain way. For example, most pictures of triangles have all 3 angles being acute. This leads people into forgetting the case when one of the angles is obtuse.
- Falkens_Maze 9y agoCompletely agree. It's what Prof. Susskind states in one of his lectures on QM explaining quantum fields. Eventually pictures and mental abstractions break down, and it's better to not visualize. At some point, one's limited biological brain will be unable to fully perceive or visualize some mathematical object. That's where intuition comes in.
- 9y ago
- agnivade 9y agoI feel a better explanation of them was given in "Shadows of the mind" by Roger Penrose where he explains how they play a vital role in Quantum Theory which impacts real-life behavior.
- harpocrates 9y agoI think this actually misses the biggest point. Complex numbers are special because they are an algebraic closure of the real numbers (what makes the real numbers interesting should be more obvious), and because Zorn's lemma tells us that such a closure is unique (up to isomorphism). In other words, complex numbers are precisely what you need to add to real numbers in order to always be able to solve polynomial equations. TL;DR: complex numbers are the unique algebraic extension to the real numbers
- akvadrako 9y agoWhat do you mean by closure?
- mfukar 9y agoAlgebraic closure of a field. See the fundamental theorem of algebra.
- enord 9y agoSimply put: It's when you extend the mathematical system by applying an operation to all eligible elements in the system (for example by redefining which elements are amendable to a given operation, like sqrt(-1)) Logic example (transitive closure): given "A->B", "B->C" in a sytem then your system can be extended to also contain "A->C" if you decide to interpret "->" as transitive.
- joppy 9y agoA field is algebraically closed if whenever you have a polynomial with coefficients in that field, all the roots of the polynomial also belong to the field. For example: The field of rational numbers is not closed since it does not contain the roots of x^3 - 3 (since we can prove the cube root of 3 is irrational). The real numbers are not closed since they do not contain the roots of x^2 + 1. The complex numbers however, are closed. An algebraic closure of a field is an embedding of that field into a closed field. For example, the rational numbers into the complex numbers, or the real numbers into the complex numbers. The second case is special: while rational numbers have many possible closures, the only closure of the real numbers is the complex numbers.
- cousin_it 9y agoThe miracle of complex numbers is that they have two seemingly unrelated but very nice properties: 1) Every non-constant polynomial has a root 2) Every holomorphic function is analytic The only connection I know is that (2) implies Liouville's theorem which implies (1), but it doesn't seem any less miraculous.
- mfukar 9y agoNot miraculous at all. The motivation for complex numbers came out of trying to solve cubic polynomials (Tartaglia, Cardano).
- mbid 9y agoWhat does that have to do with every function being analytic? Anyway, you can solve every cubic polynomial in the algebraic closure of Q, which is far less than C, so you don't need to construct the complex numbers for that.
- contravariant 9y agoThe closest link I found from (1) to (2) uses differential geometry and in particular the exterior algebra. Using the exterior derivative df = (df/dx) dx + (df/dy) dy. it is possibly to define (identifying C with R^2) a function to be holomorphic when it can be written df = g (dx + idy) for some function g. From the properties of the exterior derivative you then get 0 = d(df) = d( g dz) = df' ^ dz, which implies that dg = h dz for some h, hence g is holomorphic as well. Defining the complex derivative of 'f' to be 'g' at least shows that any holomorphic function is infinitely complex differentiable. I haven't quite managed to figure out why this definition of the complex derivative coincides with the limit of f(w+z)/z as z->0 with z complex, but it should follow from the algebraic properties of C. Showing holomorphic functions to be analytic is somewhat trickier, but you can probably use that the above definition of holomorphicity and Stokes' theorem together imply Cauchy's integral theorem (every integral around a loop vanishes).
- mathgenius 9y agoRob talks about how complex numbers are just another kind of "fake number" on top of negative numbers, fractions, square roots... And this is a good thing to point out. But there is one further thing to note, which is the inherent ambiguity between i and -i. We can't tell these apart. John Conway says this well, when asked about the square root of -1 his reply is "which square root of -1 do you mean?" (paraphrasing.) This ambiguity is where Galois theory starts. Analogous "theories of ambiguity" arise all throughout mathematics (Galois connections). This is really fascinating stuff, with deep connections to quantum physics...
- dsacco 9y ago> Rob talks about how complex numbers are just another kind of "fake number" on top of negative numbers, fractions, square roots...And this is a good thing to point out. I agree. I think complex numbers are best explained in the context of motivations for number systems (and I made a comment explaining complex numbers this way about a month ago[1]). This way takes longer than just answering the question, “what’s a complex number?”, but it also builds a better intuition of why complex numbers aren’t silly (or at least, why they’re only as silly as anything that isn’t a natural number). If you can get a student to be okay with the idea that we define new number systems to resolve problems in prior ones, you can get them to be okay with a construction of complex numbers from the reals, just as they’ll accept a construction of the irrationals from the rationals, and integers from the naturals, etc. I find that a really rigorous (albeit...spartan) first pass for understanding complex numbers can be developed by reading through Chapter 1 of Rudin’s Principles of Mathematical Analysis. He doesn’t go quite as far as developing Peano arithmetic from first principles, but he does build up the number systems successively, beginning with the natural numbers if I recall correctly. That was the first book I read where I felt like I really understood what complex numbers were, because up until that point I was only dealing with them algebraically using an explicit i in the form a + bi. Rudin’s development of the complex plane and representation of real and complex numbers as points (a, b) is much better for intuition, in my experience, and it lights the way to an even deeper intuition of what complex numbers are in the context of Euclidean spaces later on. That said, Rudin is terse to the point that many would call him pretentious, so if there is another book that does the same thing with better exposition, that might be a better choice... > But there is one further thing to note, which is the inherent ambiguity between i and -i. We can't tell these apart. John Conway says this well, when asked about the square root of -1 his reply is "which square root of -1 do you mean?" (paraphrasing.) It’s been a while since I did this exercise, but if I recall correctly this ambiguity is part of the proof that we cannot order the complex field, right? We end up with an absurdity because i should be greater than -i, but i^3 = -i, which evidently resists coherent ordering. And similarly i x i = -1, but -i x i = 1. ____________________________ 1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15729381 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15729381
- hawktheslayer 9y agoThose of us EEs will know it's j.
- gaze 9y agoThe phrase “what IS it” has always bugged me in mathematics. The answer to that is always “what we defined it to be.” The question math answers is “what does it do.”
- dsacco 9y agoI think a lot of the problem in mathematics education is motivation. Students (and people learning math in general) encounter two problems: 1. They don’t realize what you’re saying, i.e. number systems and mathematics in general are built from definitions, not observations, and any definitions work as long as they’re compatible with what we’ve already proven, 2. If they realize #1, even implicitly, they still do not know why mathematical definitions are motivated. A student might say, “Okay so I understand what complex numbers are, but why do we have them? What’s the point of all of this?” In my opinion, new mathematical concepts should be taught by placing them in the context of the least complicated thing the student already knows, then motivating them by demonstrating what problem they resolve. In the case of complex numbers, this can be explained to a student via analogue to the irrational numbers, which are the set of all numbers p/q where p and q are positive integers. We “invent” and define irrational numbers to resolve real world problems involving numbers that cannot be in the integral or rational systems. Similarly, we define complex numbers to resolve real world problems involving negative numbers on a plane, and so on...
- roywiggins 9y agoThe definition of complex numbers is not arbitrary, though. It falls out of the way real numbers work, and it's pretty much predetermined once you start investigating "impossible" roots of polynomials. Interesting questions are 1) why do we care about polynomials and 2) how do polynomial roots motivate complex numbers.
- Retra 9y agoWell any reasonable person will know that those are the same question.
- bandrami 9y agoThey're phase. It means something periodic is happening to something.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoI don't think that's what they are. It's merely one of the things they're used for.
- Retra 9y agoPhase is only one component of a complex number.
- calebm 9y agotuples
- godelski 9y agoI think the easiest way to explain complex numbers is to first ask a question, "How do you multiply two dimensional numbers?" The other person always comes up with some answer like (a0+b0)x(a1+b1) = a0a1 + b0b1 or the factorization. You can easily show that this isn't consistent, and usually the student quickly starts looking for answers to prove you wrong. It becomes quickly easy to talk about how complex numbers can be used to work in two dimensions, and being able to explain concepts like closure and fields without using those words. There is no need to jump to quaternions (which is 4D, not 3D, and the point has been missed here), like the author does. There is a much simpler case that people are more familiar with. The problem with the article is that it does not gauge its audience well. As another commenter mentioned, pictures help. With this discussion on two dimensions you can use a lot of great graphics out there and talk about the beauty of Euler's formula. These topics all generalize, but it is ludicrous to talk about the generalization first.
- rrauenza 9y agoWelch Labs has a wonderful series on youtube on imaginary numbers, "Imaginary Numbers Are Real": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T647CGsuOVU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T647CGsuOVU I like to tell my kids that imaginary numbers aren't really imaginary .. that in many ways they're more real than the Reals.
- dude01 9y agoI think this is the best explanation for complex numbers I've ever seen: https://betterexplained.com/articles/a-visual-intuitive-guide-to-imaginary-numbers/
- qubex 9y agoI had the good fortune that my high-school mathematics teacher introduced complex numbers as “compound numbers”, with two “components” that defined a point on a plane, one of which was multiplied by a “orthogonal coefficient” that just happened (fabula mirabilis!) to be the square root of minus one that so vexed us when solving certain types of quadratics. Totally nonstandard terminology, but pedagogically very sound approach that was totally at odds with the official syllabus... she just “filled us in” with ‘synonyms’ a while later so that we would not be totally baffled when sitting our exams (the IB). It has served me well ever since.