4 ms·
There was no danger of harm. In fact, though this was a stupid decision by the surgeon, I'm of the opinion that he should not be removed from his post. He was
by dotancohen 9y ago
There was no danger of harm. In fact, though this was a stupid decision by the surgeon, I'm of the opinion that he should not be removed from his post.
He was proud of his handiwork and signed off on it. Have we enough skilled surgeons to remove them for a harmless boast? Reprimanded, sure, but removing him from his post is both an over reaction and unfair to society which is already lacking in skilled healthcare professionals.
- y7 9y agoHe is not just a mechanic operating on inanimate objects, his "handiwork" was the insides of a person. Letting vanity get to your head and signing your initials inside of them is a gross violation of the autonomy of that person -- they never consented to such a thing.
- WillReplyfFood 9y agoThe insides of a person loose a lot of there holyness and gloriousness, that law ascribes to the object, when you have it in your hands every day- and if the plumbing doesent work out close the lid on some meatsack with sticks in it.
- btian 9y agoIf he wants to leave handiwork he should be an artist or something. Don't be a surgeon.
- rdiddly 9y agoApparently there are enough surgeons that this guy has plenty of time for extracurricular activities inside an open incision.
- pgsandstrom 9y agoHis "stupid decision" shows a complete lack of judgement. I would never trust anyone with my life if they are capable of doing something as absurd as this.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Siemer 9y agoI would, especially if I was on a waiting list. A punishment that does not remove him from his job would benefit everyone in this case.
- askvictor 9y agoPeople who are specialists in one thing might make terrible judgements in other things. Your excellent judgement in designing software doesn't make you an excellent driver.
- khedoros1 9y agoWhen my bad judgment as a driver impacts my decisions as a programmer too, I don't expect that to slide. If his ego/vanity changes the actions that he takes when performing surgery, that sounds like a problem to me.
- ramblerman 9y agoExcept this isn't how we make decisions in our society. What if he hits a kid with his car, should we let him off the hook there too because 'he is needed by society'
- drops 9y agoYou're comparing a victimless "crime" with injuring someone. That doesn't make any sense.
- ramblerman 9y agoIf it's important to the analogy then lets say we caught him driving super drunk but he hadn't hurt anyone yet. Should we let him off the hook?
- DanBC 9y agoThat's a poor analogy, because people driving super drunk have the potential to cause very great harm. If we're sticking to car analogies he wrote his name in the dirt on the back of a truck, but the dirt was abrasive and so he also scratched his initials into the paint.
- ramblerman 9y agoSo he didn't increase the risk to the patient in any way, however small? That is, a patient who gets signed upon and one who doesn't following the exact same procedure for the rest are at an identical risk?
- benchaney 9y agoYou think branding people is a victimless crime?
- overlordalex 9y agoAlthough, this does happen[1]: > Oxford student given suspended sentence for stabbing boyfriend > Judge had reportedly earlier told Lavinia Woodward a prison term could damage her prospects of becoming a heart surgeon [1] https://www.theguardian.com/law/2017/sep/25/oxford-student-lavinia-woodward-gets-suspended-sentence-for-stabbing-boyfriend https://www.theguardian.com/law/2017/sep/25/oxford-student-l...
- lokimedes 9y agoThe guy should lose his authorization for this. It is part of a bad culture among medical doctors, where they both torture themselves and apparently others as well. The profession as a whole should really wake up or they will face a similar reaction as taxi drivers did with the introduction of Uber and Lyft. Nobody want’s to be forced to be a customer in businesses that supersede customer trust for ego.