16 ms·
More than half of all private wealth has been inherited in most of Europe
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y ago> Fascinating chart: more than half of all private wealth has been inherited in Germany, UK, Switzerland, France — trend: rising fast! > Ever less private wealth is accumulated through own work, increasingly more through inheritance. A massive part of people's motivation to work is to provide for their children. That an increasing portion of wealth is inherited rather than build in an individual's working life-time is indicative that the system is function as intended. The graph seems to indicate there was a bit of a golden area after WWII up until the early nineteens, and that the nations included on the graph are returning the regular state of affairs. But what does any of this mean?
- nickthemagicman 9y agoAs always it's about moderation. Saving wealth to take care of your children is one thing but this much seems excessive and ultimately means that inequality will continue to increase as wealth is trans-generationally hoarded. Massive inequality also portends social unrest, plagues due to people who can't afford medical care, wars, etc etc
- zokier 9y agoModern inheritance should be inherently dissipative, as the estate is repeatedly divided among the heirs, amplified by death/inheritance/estate taxation. The problems arise when the wealth accumulation overpowers the dissipative effect of inheritance, combined with increasingly absurdly high wealth levels that go far beyond providing for children and grandchildren. As for the "golden area" you mentioned; yes, the war(s) did function as great equalizing wealth redistribution force. Arguably bit of a blunt instrument to accomplish that.
- humanrebar 9y agoWealth naturally dissipates through the generations. What has changed the most is the birth rate of the wealthy. If they went back to having a dozen children apiece, wealth would dissipate at least an order of magnitude per generation.
- ridgeguy 9y agoDepends on laws and customs. Primogeniture concentrates inherited wealth in firstborn (usually male) offspring. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primogeniture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primogeniture
- goliatone 9y agoOT but I grew up in a place where first borns would inherit the land that was good for farming and other siblings would get the less desirable land, usually on the coast. Apparently it would make siblings tear each other apart because the difference in land had a huge impact on a family’s wellbeing. Eventually, with tourism, the value of land flipped, making families that owned land by the coast become wealthy. Talk about external factors affecting upward mobility.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- user5994461 9y agoWars, sickness and starvation have been great equalizers. The last ones were decades ago and there is no sign of it coming back any time soon. We're living in unprecedented times.
- jopsen 9y agoOr was it the social-democratic politics that follow war, sickness and starvation? Or if you're right-leaning maybe you would argue that it was the high growth that was a great equalizer. Or perhaps a mix of these. I don't see social-liberalism going away in Europe. And while growth might not be same as it used to be, technology is likely to keep disrupting established businesses.
- twblalock 9y agoWealth grows fast enough due to investment that splitting it up between children won't dissipate it.
- nugget 9y agoWouldn't the trend towards fewer children and smaller families decrease the dissipative effect? In the extreme case of a "one child" policy, inheritance would be amplified because the wealth of both parents (and presumably four sets of grandparents) would flow to a single individual. Similar to assortive mating, if wealthier families had fewer children relative to poorer families, then this would worsen inequality over time.
- rabidrat 9y agoOften stated as "the rich get richer and the poor have children".
- jopsen 9y agoThe War, maybe.. or perhaps the social-democratic policies that followed in many countries after the great depression and the war.
- lagadu 9y agoIt helps that wealthier people have fewer children, so wealth dissipation affects poorer people dis-proportionally.
- crdoconnor 9y agoA massive part of people's motivation to work is to provide for their children. >That an increasing portion of wealth is inherited rather than build in an individual's working life-time is indicative that the system is function as intended. No, it just signals that the tax system treats unearned income and wealth more favourably than earned income. Political choices. How you feel about that depends upon how you feel about in increase in unearned income flowing to the wealthy I guess.
- julian_1 9y ago> the tax system treats unearned income and wealth more favourably than earned income. The income was taxed when it was earned. What reason is there to tax it twice? > how you feel about in increase in unearned income flowing to the wealthy I guess. Or about how you feel about the government's use of it's citizen's resources. Why should wealth earned by the breadwinner of the family, not remain with the family? It's arguably better than expropriating citizen's wealth to fund expaditionary warfare.
- rtpg 9y agoDouble taxation doesn't mean anything in this context. We tax transactions, not specific euros. Income tax when an employer pays their employee. Inheritance tax once the money goes from the deceased to the heirs. These are separate things! And no different than, say, VAT on that iPhone. Sure it's between family members , but in the vast majority of cases all parties are independent adults. The land you inherit is not "justly yours". It was the previous owner's thing. You are getting it but it is not your divine right, except that you won the birth lottery by being born into this family. Of course a lot of families also have smaller domains, and it makes since to have some lower limit... But let's not forget people affected by inheritance tax are overwhelmingly very rich. Most of the population ends up with nothing.
- julian_1 9y ago> The land you inherit is not "justly yours". It was the previous owner's thing. You are getting it but it is not your divine right, except that you won the birth lottery by being born into this family. Of course those arguments apply to governments as well, since they don't derive their law-making authority by claim to divinity - at least in modern times. Why should a government be specially privileged over a citizens wishes to provide for their family and/or community after death?
- jondubois 9y agoWhat's interesting about this is that it barely scratches the surface. Assets and money are just some of the things that people inherit from their parents. Many people inherit their entire careers from their parents through social connections - These people would probably be classified as 'self made' which makes the statistics seem more benign than they actually are. I bet if you counted out all those people who were raised with a silver spoon, the percentage of real 'self made' people would probably be less than 1%.
- ryanwaggoner 9y agoFortunately, we don’t have to rely on guesses, we have measures of economic mobility. In particular, how likely is it that someone born into a particular quintile moves to a higher (or lower) quintile? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socioeconomic_mobility_in_the_United_States https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socioeconomic_mobility_in_th... Answer: it’s not great and getting worse, but not as dire as you portray.
- ekianjo 9y agoRelevant part: > If a parent's income had no effect on a child's opportunity for future upward mobility, approximately 20% of poor children who started in the bottom quintile (in the bottom 20% of the US range of incomes) would remain there as poor adults. At the other end of income spectrum, if children were born into wealthy families in the top 20%, only 20% would stay in that top income category if their mobility opportunities were equal to every other child's in the country. > But long-term income statistics show this isn't happening. Mobility opportunities are different for poor and wealthy children in the US. Parental incomes and parental choices of home locations while raising children appear to be major factors in that difference. According to a 2012 Pew Economic Mobility Project study[19] 43% of children born into the bottom quintile (bottom 20%) remain in that bottom quintile as adults. Similarly, 40% of children raised in the top quintile (top 20%) will remain there as adults. Looking at larger moves, only 4% of those raised in the bottom quintile moved up to the top quintile as adults. Around twice as many (8%) of children born into the top quintile fell to the bottom.[19] 37% of children born into the top quintile will fall below the middle. These findings have led researchers to conclude that "opportunity structures create and determine future generations' chances for success. Hence, our lot in life is at least partially determined by where we grow up, and this is partially determined by where our parents grew up, and so on."[20]
- erdle 9y agothat's kind of why my family left... failed revolution in the 1800s...
- mbroncano 9y agoYeah, thankfully that's hardly the case everywhere else /s
- nicolashahn 9y agoI was just discussing this as a result of watching this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-asltUUvcGU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-asltUUvcGU in which they discuss the result of the western capitalist system loosely resembling a meritocracy, except in the case of inherited wealth. An exceptionally productive individual can generate billions, but then when he dies the money goes to his heirs which may not have done anything to deserve commanding that much wealth other than having been raised by (and having the genetics of) the exceptionally productive individual, which is a far cry from being exceptionally productive themselves. My thought was to create a cap on inheritance. Enough so that the heirs would be able to live a normal middle class life without working, but not be disgustingly wealthy like the parent. ~$5 million seemed like enough to live off interest for a lifetime. I don't think productivity would be disincentivized too much by this, as the productive individuals still get to use their wealth as long as they're living. It'd probably be pretty difficult to plug all the loopholes but I think it's worth thinking about. edit: another thing, we could lighten some other taxes (income, property, whatever) for this increased death tax such that the overall government tax income remains roughly the same, to make the proposal more palatable. Overall, everyone keeps more of their wealth, and the playing field is leveled and we're a bit closer to an actual meritocracy.
- nickthemagicman 9y agoI love this. It's about moderation. That's how.the estate tax is supposed to function.
- crdoconnor 9y agoMost of this wealth probably has nothing to do with merit. For every Steve Jobs there's a whole bunch of people who did nothing more than sit on property that appreciated in value and yielded rents. The tax system seems to prefer this to actually earning money for some reason.
- nicolashahn 9y agoTrue, and almost everyone would be unaffected by the law I proposed. If you have two children, you'd need >$10 million in assets for it to affect you. I guess what I proposed is a fix for just the super-rich's inheritance, but it's low hanging fruit and there's a lot of it.
- ajeet_dhaliwal 9y agoWon’t this eventually happen in the United States too? What’s stopping it other than a later start. There’s more entrepreneurial spirit perhaps but the sons and daughters of wealth creators will still inherit.
- gbacon 9y agoRead the chapter “Economic Outpatient Care” in Thomas Stanley’s The Millionaire Next Door to learn how poorly on average American millionaires pass to their children the skills necessary to build wealth.
- askvictor 9y agoAmericans, perhaps. But whole nobility (more of a European thing) thing is in part to preserve these skills across generations.
- eksabajt 9y agoI'm not certain about the figures for wealth mobility, but intergenerational income mobility is already worse in the United States than in Europe and has been for some time. https://wol.iza.org/uploads/articles/176/pdfs/intergenerational-income-persistence.pdf https://wol.iza.org/uploads/articles/176/pdfs/intergeneratio...
- kiliantics 9y agoPiketty showed in Capital that most modern work about the trends in economic inequality was flawed. We usually think of the industrial revolution and modern era as periods where power and wealth became much more fairly distributed. However, if you go far back enough into the records, as he did, you can see a clear trend of concentration of wealth even now in the current system. The trend was briefly disrupted by the two world wars which were so destructive to our economies. The necessary reconstruction led to massive wealth redistribution and evened the playing field somewhat. It seems that the graphs in this tweet are another confirmation of Piketty's observation.
- gbacon 9y agoHow then is it possible that some four in five American millionaires inherited no more than ten thousand dollars, according to The Millionaire Next Door by Thomas Stanley?
- kiliantics 9y agoA millionaire is hardly wealthy these days. Upper middle class rich, sure. But not "an estate to leave to my heirs" rich. Someone who got a good middle class start, went into the right career, and had everything work out pretty well (no major financial misfortune or an injury or sick family member) while saving responsibly, can become a millionaire in a few decades today. They can probably afford a nice house, which their kids can carve up to have their own nice middle class start. This group of people is still insanely privileged but it is nothing on the obnoxious levels of real inherited wealth in the upper crust.
- ataturk 9y agoSpeaking as one, I can tell you that having a couple million takes the edge off of everything in life. You don't sweat buying a house or pretty much any new car anytime you want it. The monthly bills are in the noise as far as concerns in life. I still go to work every day but I won't be working until age 65, that's for certain; not full time, anyways. My kids will be able to be entrepreneurs if they wish, they have a comfortable fallback that I never had. Less stress in life is a good thing. What's different today is that inflation and high taxes have wrecked the middle class. The truly rich are the $100M and billionaire types whose wealth has run away from the rest of the people. Almost none of the truly wealthy are that way because they were smart (merit) only a few are. The rest . got rich either because they were lucky or because of some angle they could exploit such as favorable connections or regulatory capture. Above them, Old Money rules the world by at least one order of magnitude.
- 6502nerdface 9y agoA theory... It takes time to create wealth, and a lot more time elapsed before the current generations than has elapsed (or will) during the current generations, thus perhaps it’s not surprising that as time goes on, most of the accumulated wealth around us is from previous generations. Furthermore, when a person dies, their wealth can either be destroyed/lost, inherited by heirs, bequeathed to some institution, or absorbed into the state/public... by measuring only “private wealth” as TFA does, we don’t see those latter two routes for the flow of wealth across generations, thus biasing our view toward the inherited component of wealth.
- askvictor 9y agoWhile you raise a very interesting point, I suspect that overwhelmingly wealth is passed down to children; it's a pretty basic human instinct to look after your clan. Though I would like to see some data to be sure.
- marxwasright 9y agoIt is quite sad, but predictable, that people are trying to silence your voice with their votes. Piketty’s observations dovetail nearly with this article. And a world where r>g, and inherited wealth dominates is a world of economic inefficiency; where lucky sperm dominate all aspects of life regardless of their talent or their value.
- dang 9y ago> It is quite sad, but predictable, that people are trying to silence your voice with their votes Would you please read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html, which ask you not to post like this? The parent comment has actually been decisively upvoted. It takes time for the community verdict to become clear. Also, the "people are trying to silence your voice" thing is an internet trope that is best left elsewhere. We're hoping for thoughtful, non-repetitive discussion on this site, not boxing matches. Edit: actually, since it looks like you're using this site for ideological battle and have done it multiple times before, I've banned this account. Please don't create accounts to break the HN rules with.
- gbacon 9y agoThe flawed thinking that wealth is a pie of fixed size wherein gain by one is necessarily another’s loss is known as mercantilism and was long ago discredited as bunk economics.
- justicezyx 9y agoOr it was what they want you to believe.
- ataturk 9y agoI think the matter is well documented. Wealth is not a zero-sum game. However--you have countries that deliberately hold people down. Everyone wants safety nets and such. That all has a huge effect on individual upward mobility.
- justicezyx 9y agoWealth might not be a zeronsum game, but we need to prevent someone to play it as such. Imagine an economy where wealth is accumulated more and more to a few, then even the total wealth grows, how everyone enjoy them equally? If not equally, the inequality soon will make wealth zero sum anyway.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoWhen I was stationed in Germany in my twenties as an American military wife, the Berlin Wall came down and the Two Germanies reunited. An East German aunt went to visit West German relatives, then visited relatives who had immigrated to the US. She said that "Compared to East Germany, everyone in West Germany looks rich. Then you go to the US and everyone looks like on (the nighttime soap) Dallas." My maternal grandmother came from a low level German noble family that sold the family title when they fell on hard times. Given my aunt's assessment of wealth distribution in relation to nationality, I guess mom made the right decision coming here. (Edited to clarify my nationality in response to a question. I did not realize I left that out. Oops.)
- bradfitz 9y ago> I guess mom made the right decision coming here Where's here? Oh, from your Hacker News profile -> Twitter profile (https://twitter.com/doreen_michele https://twitter.com/doreen_michele) which says "Southwest Coastal Washington".
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- BatterMarkupL 9y agobradfitz: eighteen years later and still too personal.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dang 9y agoI'm sure you were just making polite conversation but it's maybe not so great to follow two pointer hops to someone's personal details. People have many reasons for being sensitive about these things. I've never thought about it before, but your comment made me realize that maybe the best thing is to feel free to mention what's in someone's HN profile but leave it at that. On the other hand, I broke that myself only this afternoon: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15947396 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15947396. So I don't know.
- alexnewman 9y agoThat's what a real estate bubble does
- myth_drannon 9y agoI wonder how the tendency of Russian oligarchy to move their family to UK, Switzerland skews the charts
- contingencies 9y agoThe Chinese have a saying 富不过三代 which means "wealth does not survive three generations".
- Banthum 9y agoOur version is: shirtsleeves to shirtsleeves in three generations.
- closeparen 9y agoHave there been three generations in China since the Communist revolution?
- contingencies 9y agoYep, just! Wealth certainly didn't survive that one, except by moving to Taiwan, and its economy is tanking right about the three generation mark...
- onion2k 9y agoThe wealthiest people here in the UK tend to come from families who were given estates by the crown in the 14th and 15th centuries. That saying may be true in China, but it isn't universal.
- joshuaheard 9y agoThis doesn't surprise me at all. Based on my observations, I would say that at least the bottom 80% lives solely on income from labor, and accumulates no wealth. Of the upper 20%, some live below their means, some earn slightly more from their labor than necessary to live, and others make enough to accumulate capital. Once you begin to accumulate capital, you earn money from the capital itself. Some accumulate enough capital to earn enough income to quit earning income from labor entirely. Some use the excess capital income to accumulate even more capital. Capital is then passed down to heirs. So the accumulated capital is about equal to new capital generated.
- juicyfroot 9y agoWhat's wrong with giving your childrem your inheritance? A bunch of communists are brigading to redistribute your family's hard earned money.
- juicyfroot 9y agoCould it be that some people, some families, actually invest...instead of buying cheap plastic shit Shakes head
- skookumchuck 9y agoI suspect a lot of inequality is due to better access to wider markets. How rich could you get if your marketplace was just your village? Now, with the internet and cheap global transport, an entrepreneur has access to the globe, and so can make much more money.
- fgjjgutjvnu 9y agoEverything belongs to somebody, and everybody dies eventually, converting their property into "inherited property". So isn't this equivalent to saying "more than half of things belong to private people", or the other way round, "almost half of everything belongs to governments"?
- woodpanel 9y agoThis statistic is from the DIW, a German think-tank which is known for it's left leaning/biased views. It cost them their membership in the country's "council of economic experts" once. PS: That doesn't mean that the claim is false. But you could - as is often the case - draw different conclusions from the data. E.g. that the European countries have heavy welfare and tax burdens that reduce social mobility and the chances of earning private wealth through work.
- wutbrodo 9y ago> E.g. that the European countries have heavy welfare and tax burdens that reduce social mobility and the chances of earning private wealth through work. I agree with the general principle, but the US has lower social mobility IIRC than most of the EU countries. My current model is that whatever flaws our model has are currently dominating Europeans' reduction of social mobility. Given how much better we integrate immigrants (especially in the parts of the economy that are high growth, like urban coasts), I wonder how much US social mobility is overstated. We didn't have a lot of money when I was growing up and my sister and I are both in a pretty high percentile of income, so we'd certainly show up as a data pt of social mobility. But my parents are upper class in "the old country", they both have master's degrees, and their kids' income relative to their human capital isn't really a central example of social mobility.
- mapleoin 9y agoHow is "UK, Germany, France and Switzerland" most of Europe? Those aren't even the four richest countries in Europe. The title implies this is the case for all of Europe, but the link only claims this for four countries.
- scotty79 9y agoThis seems natural to me. Wealth might be either inherited or gathered from people that are not wealthy and that usually requires some excuse (for example giving them temporary access to some limited resource you own like roofs or capital or selling them something you can make cheaply in large quantities at low cost). It stands to reason that most wealth is inherited as inherited part grows gradually by gathered part (which is limited by human lifespan and pace of development of technology that creates new value). Some inherited part is list due to gambling (on business mostly) but that just lowers pace of growth.
- pmontra 9y agoMaybe what follows is naive but wealth is not destroyed when somebody dies, it passes on to heirs. If there isn't an economic boom the share of inherited wealth is going to be larger and larger as time passes. Even succession taxes don't destroy wealth, they distribute it and probably most of it becomes private again (salaries to public servants and private suppliers of public works.) An extreme example: in Egypt they're making money out of the Pyramids, non inherited businesses (tourism) on the top of inherited public property.