3 ms·
> Congress isn't sitting idly by either. The bill, H.R.4585 - Save Net Neutrality Act of 2017, has already been proposed, and more will come. After the FCC anno
by shmerl 9y ago
> Congress isn't sitting idly by either. The bill, H.R.4585 - Save Net Neutrality Act of 2017, has already been proposed, and more will come. After the FCC announced its decision, Colorado Congressman Mike Coffman, a Republican, immediately announced, "This conversation belongs in #Congress."
Watch out for those in the Congress pushing a law that would actually cement in place fake net neutrality, that doens't really prevent any monopolistic abuse.
I suspect it was the plan of monopolists all along. They knew well, that blantant actions of FCC won't fly, but they hoped their corrupt influence on the Congress would allow them to pass a "law" that would let them run amok with anti-competitive and user fleecing behavior.
Example of where it can be heading: https://web.archive.org/web/20171215060507/http://corporate.comcast.com/comcast-voices/its-time-for-congress-to-act-and-permanently-preserve-the-open-internet https://web.archive.org/web/20171215060507/http://corporate....
Read carefully what Comcast lobbyists are writing. They describe their own plan pretty well.
Why would someone like Comcast who fought tooth and nail against FCC net neutrality rules, suddenly be so interested in passing a law that "solidifies" and "permanently preserves" it? Only because they hope that they'll manage to solidify something that doesn't do anything, while "putting the discussion to rest" (i.e. making fixing it much harder, than simply restoring previous FCC rules again).
- ikeboy 9y agoComcast doesn't say that they want Congress to implement title ii regulation. You're mixing up 2 different things.
- shmerl 9y agoI explained above what they are saying. They want two things: prevent strong net neutrality protections and prevent it practically permanently. For that they are now pushing for a fake law about it. Their logic is, that repealing a garbage law is usually much harder, than for FCC simply passing some new regulation. Look at how long DMCA-1201 persists, despite it being an obvious garbage.
- ikeboy 9y agoYou said "Why would someone like Comcast who fought tooth and nail against FCC net neutrality rules, suddenly be so interested in passing a law that "solidifies" and "permanently preserves" it?" You seem to be ignoring the obvious response, which is that they're fine with NN regulations as long as it doesn't come with the overhead of Title II.
- shmerl 9y agoPoint is, they are pretending they are pro-net neutrality, while in essence they are completely against it. It's their usual smokescreen tactic, to fool those who would fall for such weasel talk. Saying they are fine with NN regulation, but only when it's actually not doing anything to protect NN, is fallacy. So let's be clear - they are simply lying through their teeth.
- ikeboy 9y agoYou keep on saying some version of this but aren't giving any reason to actually believe this. What would you expect to see differently in a world in which they wanted Congress to pass clear NN rules?
- shmerl 9y ago> What would you expect to see differently in a world in which they wanted Congress to pass clear NN rules? They should stop lying and admit they are simply against net neutrality to begin with. But I don't expect them to, naturally, since they are professional lairs. Anyway, my point was that the public should be aware about this sneaky attack on net neutrality, veiled as "support" for it.
- ikeboy 9y agoYou aren't answering the question. You've given zero reason to think they're lying except asserting it over and over.
- michaelfgolden 9y agoThis. The long game for monopoly isps has been to get this in front of a favorable congress since the title II rule was enacted. Would be hard to imagine a more favorable congress than the current one, which in anticipating a wave in 2018, are all on the hunt for wingnut welfare.