3 ms·
In the US people can change the government peacefully with a vote. But that process only gives them two choices that largely represent no one but corporate inte
by ianai 9y ago
In the US people can change the government peacefully with a vote. But that process only gives them two choices that largely represent no one but corporate interests. I hope at some point the US adopts a better voting system.
- cannonedhamster 9y agoNo real change has ever happened in America without blood being spilled. * Labor unions had state militias called on them and thousands were massacred at the hands of private security agencies during the Mine Wars * Women had to die in the Triangle massacre before safety became a concern. * Martin Luther King along with tons of other black people needed to die just to be considered humans. * Vietnam required the Kent State Massacre. * How many children and civilians have we had die needlessly at the hands of the police? You can't get a jury to convict them. The American government has never represented the people. It will take nothing less than large amounts violence to change the country if history is any indicator of the future.
- dvtv75 9y agoWhat was the Triangle massacre? I can't find much about it.
- Avshalom 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triangle_Shirtwaist_Factory_fire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triangle_Shirtwaist_Factory_fi...
- harimau777 9y agoI'm guessing he's referring to the Traigle Shirtwaist Factory fire. Basically the management locked the women working at the factory in because they thought they would sneak out instead of working. So when a fire broke out the women couldn't escape. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triangle_Shirtwaist_Factory_fire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triangle_Shirtwaist_Factory_fi...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- azemetre 9y agoWell when it comes to corporate interests you literally have the GOP party shut down Net Neutrality while the DNC has made preserving NN a party platform and plan on acting legislation when they gain back control. Claiming that both sides favor corporations is to deny reality when it comes to voting records. Republicans have consistently passed legislation that hurt consumers and benefit corporations, another recent example was banning consumers ability to start class action lawsuits against banks. You have the DNC legislature that was enabled to create the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, a bureau that the GOP voted whole-hardheartedly against and continue to weaken now that they control Congress and the Senate. You have the GOP that put a pro-corporate Justice on SCOTUS that thinks employees should be punished when they aren't willing to risk their life in literal life and death circumstances in ransAm Trucking v. Administrative Review Board. I'm sorry but there is clearly one party that cares about people and it ain't the fucking GOP.
- Asooka 9y agoWhichever party won the election would be the one bought by corporations and championing repeal of net neutrality, while their opposition would be for net neutrality.
- NotSammyHagar 9y agoBut that is not what happened when obama was pres. When is party, the dems were the majority, they did things against corps. He wasn't perfect, but a lot of his behavior was organized around pushing things through that plenty of corps hated, like the consumer financial protection bureau.
- siruncledrew 9y agoI think many Americans (especially younger ones) are at the point where they are jaded by the act of voting. Sure, I can cast a vote for someone, but what difference does it make in changing the government? The government isn't like some small-town legislature where single people can stand up and closely represent their fellow citizens. Everyone is taking money from someone at the end of the day to get elected, and that someone is rich people. Us "normal people" are worthless to political representatives at the end of day - it doesn't matter what the party is. Honestly, getting votes from people is just a formality for elected officials at this point, and once elected, all the attention goes to the rich people that financed the campaign in order to "pay them back".
- Asooka 9y agoYou should keep voting, so you keep the hope for a good candidate to come along, so you don't get out of the habit of keeping up with politics, and so you send a clear signal that you still believe in the democratic process for whenever it becomes relevant again.
- ianai 9y agoThe small participation rate in voting empowers the actual voters. If only 50% show up then each of those voters effectively voices preferences for 2 people (his/herself and another person who didn’t vote). It’s all about perception. Votes are also more valued (by a lot) in swing states.
- jsoc815 9y agoSerious question here: Have you ever worked in any form of US gov't? If not, I'd suggest that you block out some time to do so. You might find the experience to be illuminating. Whether it be local, state, or federal government, it all works pretty much the same way. And none of it, despite peoples' cries, is functioning outside of how it was designed to.
- ianai 9y agoI’ve volunteered for a campaign and worked for a large federal project. I do agree that they’re functioning within acceptable parameters. But the voting system itself is why we only have 2 viable parties that essentially define one another.
- jsoc815 9y agoThanks for replying. Though I've never worked on a campaign, I imagine that it's a slightly different animal. And without knowing which project you worked on I'd guess similarly. That said, experience in either would probably expose you to the pervasive paternalism and disdain for the "general public" permeating through (most forms of) American gov't. Ironically, my observation is that gov't employment is often less about knowledge/expertise and more about friendsies, patronage/quotas and malleability/docility. @ this point, I'm not convinced that the current state of affairs doesn't reflect the complicity of "the people" (who are constantly reminded to aim for "middle-class" (mediocrity)). Since we'd be working with the same public, changing the # of parties would still likely yield the same result. And I say that as someone who regularly votes on positions not parties or candidates (and is often criticized for doing so).