3 ms·
> it's about it expressing a real fault in the legal system and its attitude, despite doing it using a non-factual case. If you want to point out an actual fla
by naasking 9y ago
> it's about it expressing a real fault in the legal system and its attitude, despite doing it using a non-factual case.
If you want to point out an actual flaw instead of a non-factual/non-existent flaw, then use facts not fables.
> In other words, the US legal system might not have THAT law, but the story remains true in a deeper level, in the sense that it is indeed the kind of system were such a law could be conceived or be remotely possible
Except you would need a factual argument to demonstrate this possibility. Your arguments so far do not qualify. The fact that you can imagine this possibility entails facts about you and your understanding of law, and does not entail anything about the law itself.
- coldtea 9y ago>If you want to point out an actual flaw instead of a non-factual/non-existent flaw, then use facts not fables. If I want it, then yes, I'll take that advice in mind. My concern is not what I want though, but what happens in real life, how some things can be more complicated than the naive first order view (factually false = useless), and how some narratives (both good and bad) are transmitted in society through such methods.
- naasking 9y ago> but what happens in real life Facts are pertinent to real life. Fiction is not. > how some things can be more complicated than the naive first order view (factually false = useless) 1. Facts are not first order, but applicable at arbitrarily higher orders as well. 2. Factually false claims aren't useless, they quite clearly identify the biases of the people who perpetuate them.