4 ms·
This makes the article much less potent. Without knowing the analysts and being able to confirm it, it’s just a case of he said, she said. HHS has a statement t
by prepend 9y ago
This makes the article much less potent. Without knowing the analysts and being able to confirm it, it’s just a case of he said, she said. HHS has a statement that says this didn’t happen.
It seems like the journalist should have worked to get a recording or at least multiple sources.
- jacquesm 9y agoAs a rule journalists do not make stuff up. And the few exceptions to that rule, if and when found out are dealt with rather harshly. Wish that we would hold politicians to the same standards.
- mcculley 9y agoI'm not suggesting that journalists made something up. I would like to see a list of banned words presented to CDC staff. It's not clear to me how serious this is. Is it an exaggeration? A miscommunication? We are not talking about Watergate or the Pentagon Papers. It's hard to tell if this is gossip. Anybody taking ownership of the claim could clear that up.
- SimbaOnSteroids 9y agoExfiltrating a hard copy/digital copy proves to be a very traceable source for a leak.
- prepend 9y agoThis is a good point, but it’s what makes journalism hard. Fortunately, there are many ways to get hard copy / digital copy without traceability (eg, Wikileaks but not Reality Winner).
- mcculley 9y agoSo? If I were a CDC employee and I were fired for publishing policy, I would be proud of that. I'm sure many lawyers would love to represent such a person.
- prepend 9y agoThat’s a good point and I don’t think the journalist is making it up, although there have been quite a few cases of journalists being wrong or outright lying (eg, Dan Rather). I think the bigger risk is that the source is wrong. Being able to confirm with multiple sources isn’t just about proving yourself as a journalist, but about verifying the story. I look forward to the follow up stories to confirm or deny what this is about. Like I said, HHS already has statements saying “that didn’t happen like that” so it’s an issue of HHS credibility vs. New York Times. Having better sources would remove this question.
- mwilliaams 9y agoThat really only applies if you have a narrow view of which writers are journalists. Lots of people make stuff up.