5 ms·
Germany's Wolf Population on the Rise
- wirrbel 9y agoyay! With hunters who keep the woods overpopulated with deer etc. (because as they age they give better trophies) I can only hope that we will get even more packs in the future throughout the country. I have read an amazing report on how wolves changed the ecological system of yellowstone national park for the better (not quite sure which article specifically , believe it was https://www.yellowstonepark.com/things-to-do/wolf-reintroduction-changes-ecosystem https://www.yellowstonepark.com/things-to-do/wolf-reintroduc...) which makes me even more enthusiastic.
- diego_moita 9y agoI believe the report might be this one: http://www.nytimes.com/1997/12/30/science/in-2-years-wolves-reshaped-yellowstone.html http://www.nytimes.com/1997/12/30/science/in-2-years-wolves-... It is amazing because of the ripple implications: deer are scared of wolves therefore they don't eat on forests where they can be easily ambushed therefore trees have a better chance of growing therefore they make more shade on the river banks therefore trouts have better places to lay eggs. In the end: wolves bring more trouts. Who would have thought of that.
- swerner 9y agoThe "wolves fix Yellowstone" narrative may be oversimplyfying things. https://mobile.nytimes.com/2014/03/10/opinion/is-the-wolf-a-real-american-hero.html?_r=3&referer= https://mobile.nytimes.com/2014/03/10/opinion/is-the-wolf-a-...
- jimnotgym 9y ago> and found that elk rarely changed their feeding behavior in response to wolves. Perhaps a more useful study would have been to compare elkfeeding behavior pre-1995 to post wolf introduction. By 2007 maybe the Elk had just got the hang of living around wolves. Maybe their behavior had already changed?
- swerner 9y agoThose are the questions we'll never be able to answer for sure. All we can observe are correlations and cannot draw certain causations from it. Ecosystems are complex and its variables change constantly. The appearance of wolves was one notable change, but not the only one. Others have suggested drought as a possible factor for the change in elk population. Which one of the explanations is the truth, I can't possibly tell. Both sound plausible to a layman, and neither can be proven definitively.
- woodpanel 9y ago"yay!" is what only those people in Germany say, that don't have to live with the consequences that pack of wolves are their new neighbours.
- wirrbel 9y agoOh snap. forgot that I left my flock of sheep in the front yard... seriously, what are these terrible consequences?
- lindig 9y agoYou might want to look after your horses and their foals that you don't keep in the front yard.
- JTenerife 9y agoHow about your kids? In Germany there are a lot of small villages. Kids still playing in the forests and fields. It's plain stupid to forget that wolves are predators.
- wander_homer 9y agoNo worries, by the time my kids manage to run into a wolf they are already run over by cars multiple times on the way to the forest. Or stung to death by wasps, bees, ... bitten by the neighbors dog, attacked by a boar, drowned in some water, ...
- wirrbel 9y agoYou know what is a concrete danger for my kids (and all other kids, in both rural and cityareas)? - cars and if you worry about animals - dogs (which are wolves, bread for insanity and not fearing humans, and sometimes trained to attack people) - chicken (salmonella probably kills a few kids a year)
- zaarn 9y agoI fear boars much more than the wolves living in our woods. Wolves rarely attack humans and even if it is usually associated with rabies rather than an actual hunt. If you happen to walk into a wolf, it's probably gonna bite you and then leave you alone when you run away.
- toomanybeersies 9y agoI've never hunted in Germany, and New Zealand has very different hunting, but from all the Europeans that I've talked to, deer hunting is a managed system. It's not as simple as "keep the woods overpopulated". For starters, you tend to want to keep a good bloodline going. So hunters will cull off the deer of weaker bloodlines. You also don't want excessive competition, because you don't want malnourished deer. So there is incentive to keep the numbers at a manageable level. Lastly, there is actually a legal minimum number of deer that hunters need to shoot a year. They are required to harvest a certain number of animals.
- swerner 9y ago> Lastly, there is actually a legal minimum number of deer that hunters need to shoot a year. (excuse the German links please, I don't have any references in English for the following) Not only a minimum number, but an exact number: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abschussplan https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abschussplan In some jurisdictions, hunters are required by law to keep trophies as proof. Going over or under is a misdemeanour, and can result in severe fines in some cases: http://www.jagdrecht-bayern.de/jagd-4/abschussregelung/abschussplan/verstoss/ http://www.jagdrecht-bayern.de/jagd-4/abschussregelung/absch... http://www.jawina.de/abschussplan-nicht-erfuellt-19-000-euro-strafe/ http://www.jawina.de/abschussplan-nicht-erfuellt-19-000-euro...
- wirrbel 9y agoThere are several associations for hunters in Germany, and one, the ecological hunters association is questioning how deer is managed. Don't know how the google translate translation holds up for https://www.moz.de/artikel-ansicht/dg/0/1/1459507 https://www.moz.de/artikel-ansicht/dg/0/1/1459507 but maybe it is an interesting read. It really seems to me that a predator is a missing piece in the eco system at the moment. Hunting and quotas is a bit like introducing a quick hack you need to maintain over the years, that requires introducing more hacks over time to keep the system alive.
- krona 9y agoDespite what the article says, the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) doesn't consider the wolves that inhabit the Eurasian continent to be endangered [1]. [1] http://www.iucnredlist.org/details/3746/1 http://www.iucnredlist.org/details/3746/1
- rodionos 9y agoSome interesting notes in the summary: 1) wolves are one of beneficiaries of political instability (see the section on Balkan states). 2) in case of need, rescue from the Russian population is possible (section 7).
- mlvljr 9y agoWhat do you mean?? Can't we just have ur wolves (for dinner and supper)?
- singron 9y agoThey have individual ratings for different regions on that page, and they rate Germany/West Poland as Critically Endangered, so the article isn't just making it up. Maybe a more accurate wording would be "endangered species in Germany".
- pvaldes 9y agoIs not endangered as species, but locally can be different. In 2016 there were only 46 reproductive pairs in the entire Scandinavia for example; and Denmark has in 2017 their first and only reproductive pair in 200 years.
- Parcissons 9y agoOh, yes, the so called management. You report a damage by a protected creature (tractor crashes through ground into dug out beaver lodge- breaking axle)- some state official hippy appears, looks at the damage, gives you 100 € promising to bring a trap and evict the beavers (nothing happens), promises further compensation (nothing happens) - disappears, talks to the newspaper that he cant understand the outrage against geo-engineering animals in the neighbourhood of farms and living centers. After all they recived compensation. I know farmers who do not allow those lying hypocrites on theire grounds. If they trust wulfs fear instincts triumphing over hunger so much, would they do the test- and tie themselves with some warming blankets to a tree in a winterforrest for a night?
- JTenerife 9y agoWolves are preditors. There's a reason why our ancesters have evicted them.
- timgrossmann 9y agoTotally legit, let's just kill everything that is a predator but the humans themselves... What a thoughtful comment, thank you for that
- JTenerife 9y agoThat's not what I've said. And I'm not suggesting this. Your comment is a bit hostile.
- pvaldes 9y agoAnd also our ancester's best friend, saving people in distress, guarding our kids and houses and helping humans in a miriad of ways every single day. Their economic (positive) impact for humans is invaluable. Is a priceless species for us.