7 ms·
Face ID flop: Chinese colleagues can both authenticate iPhone X
- bloudermilk 9y agoFlagged. Site redirects to phishing site on iOS
- 627467 9y agoQueue in racism accusations...
- rainbowmverse 9y agoIt depends on how you define racism. The meaning people use when calling stuff like this racist is not meant as an insult, and it's not even a comment on the character of the people doing it. Good people can do racist things by this definition since it's focused on systems instead of individuals. Unfortunately, people rarely define their terms when talking about sensitive subjects. It'd save a lot of people a lot of stress.
- Banthum 9y agoLots of people don't agree on exactly what racism means, but one thing that is always true is that it's evil. That's the core, most powerful, most enduring meaning of the word. You're just making the motte of the motte-any-bailey argument: Oh, racism isn't an insult, just a neutral description of something. The goal here is to make the word as widely applicable as possible. The bailey is, of course, that the company is racist! And that's evil! So it needs to shift resources towards whatever the accuser wants them to do.
- rainbowmverse 9y agoI can't tell whether you misread or are intentionally misrepresenting my words.
- tgb 9y agoThis is what one in a million looks like. https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/larryosterman/2004/03/30/one-in-a-million-is-next-tuesday/ https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/larryosterman/2004/03/30/on...
- BillinghamJ 9y agoFor computers, not humans...
- mikeash 9y agoThere are millions of iPhones X and billions of humans. It definitely applies to humans if you look at a worldwide scale.
- JimDabell 9y agoSome estimates put iPhone X sales this quarter at 30m. And don't forget that people are generally poor at estimating probabilities like this, consider the birthday problem as an example. It takes a group of ~1,200 people for a one in a million collision to be more likely than not to occur. It's very unlikely for it to happen to you, but it's very likely to happen to somebody.
- twhb 9y agoYet you didn't hear about this with the "1 in 50,000" Touch ID. It's not about brute force, but filtering (you know who has a similar face, you don't know who has a similar fingerprint) and input distribution (similar faces are more likely to be nearby than similar fingerprints).
- fromfuture 9y ago.. and is the reason I'm so skeptical about Self-Driving Cars. I even think that AI investments are going to be a major cause of the next stock market crash.
- kevinsimper 9y agoIt is pretty bad that a colleague can unlock your phone, but they would also be able to see and remember your 4-6 number pincode to unlock your phone as well, even touchId can be fooled by a person who happens to have a very similar fingerprint. I feel Apple should let your train the FaceID a bit more so that it is more correct, or maybe a setting on how precise the match should be, as this is a clear example of where the Face detection is too loose to ease the user compared to the lower security.
- mikeash 9y agoAccording to Apple, Touch ID is far more likely to fail in this way. They say the false positive rate is 1 in 50,000 per fingerprint, and you can enroll up to five fingerprints, so the chances could be as high as 1 in 10,000. Face ID is supposedly 1 in a million. That’s still high enough that we’d expect to see stories like this from time to time.
- RodgerTheGreat 9y agoNo one can tell at a glance how similar two people's fingerprints might be, so finding a collision by accident is very hard. Finding similar-looking faces from a pool of candidates is, in contrast, very easy for humans. It would probably be even easier to find matches if we knew the precise heuristics Apple employs for ignoring glasses, headwear, facial hair, and so on; to be at all practical the feature must have generous degrees of freedom, which in turn reduce discrimination. Finally, as many have observed, there are plenty of situations where humans will be in close physical and social proximity to others with similar faces: twins, siblings, etc. Even if collisions are as infrequent as Apple claims (which I find dubious), face identification is fundamentally a lock that is easier to "pick" than fingerprints. I am forced to conclude that depending on facial recognition is a poor engineering decision motivated by user convenience whose limitations are deliberately mischaracterized by marketing materials.
- mikeash 9y agoThe main use case for a phone passcode is keeping your stuff secure in the event that it’s lost or stolen randomly. Both technologies are fairly secure against run-of-the-mill thieves. They’re good enough that the market for stolen phones is probably reduced to breaking them down and selling them for spare parts. If you happen to fall victim to a more sophisticated criminal, Touch ID is going to be way worse. Your phone is covered with the fingerprints needed to unlock it. It will take some sophistication to turn a print into something that can unlock the phone, but it’s doable. There’s no equivalent for Face ID. Most likely the criminal doesn’t know what you look like at all, so they could try five random people and then get locked out with a probability of success of roughly 1 in 200,000. If they know who you are they could try to look you up and find similar looking people, but that’s going to take time and effort and you have to get it done within 48 hours, and the odds of success are still not great. (If it was easy to reliably unlock the phone with a similar-looking person, we would have heard a hundred stories like this by now.) It’s far from perfect but I have no qualms trusting my security to it. It’s better than Touch ID and far better than the 0000 passcode I used before that.
- neom 9y agoWe got a friends phone to unlock with her sisters face, but it required the phone to fail, enter correct passcode, fail, enter correct passcode. After two failed attempts (consistently, and after retraining) the iPhone had added enough of her sisters face that her sister could unlock it. I wish these unlock articles would state if the phone was "trained" to learn the new face.
- Someone1234 9y agoI get a little annoyed with this defense. Automatic re-train is a "feature" you cannot turn off, cannot turn on, have no visual feedback that it occurs, and ultimately weakens the security of your device. If this is what is causing Face Unlock to fail then that's still just as much Apple's responsibility than any other methodology. You also have no way to knowing how much re-train has occurred since Apple doesn't provide that information.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoLooks like you can disable FaceID pretty easily: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208108 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208108 To disable Face ID, open Settings > Face ID & Passcode, and tap Reset Face ID. Doing so will delete Face ID data, including mathematical representations of your face, from your device. If you choose to erase or reset your device using Find My iPhone or erasing all content and settings, all Face ID data will be deleted.
- nerdponx 9y agoThere's a really, really easy solution here: don't buy an iPhone X. If the technology is bad and dangerous, stop buying it. Publicly and loudly discourage people from buying it. Go to the media, drum up hysteria about the dangers of FaceID. Bury the technology under public skepticism. Convince people that biometrics are dangerous and put them at much greater risk than before, and send a clear message to the industry when biometric sales tank. Anything else is hypocrisy.
- wklauss 9y ago> There's a really, really easy solution here: don't buy an iPhone X. Or buy one if you want one and use an alphanumeric passcode if you don't like biometrics.
- wtetzner 9y agoThat works until they stop offering the ability to use a passcode.
- wklauss 9y agoHave they suggested they'll do such a thing? I'm pretty sure that will never be the case. And if for some reason they do, change platforms then.
- userbinator 9y agoDid Apple suggest they would remove the headphone jack when they introduced their first iPhone with BlueTooth? Long ago, no one thought mobiles and laptops would not have removable batteries either.
- valuearb 9y agoApple never removed the headphone jack from my 6s, but i shouldn’t have bought one cause they removed it from done other device? The idea Apple would remove passcodes is a paranoid fantasy on par with them removing the touch screen to force you to use Siri.
- Friedduck 9y agoDownvote. Pocketnow redirects to a scam site. Face ID is an answer to a question no one asked. I’m sure I’d acclimate but the fingerprint reader works brilliantly.
- jamesrcole 9y ago> fingerprint reader works brilliantly I'm not making any comment on Face ID, but the fingerprint reader does not work brilliantly. I think it's pretty good, but it has some major shortcomings. It works really poorly if you have moisture on your fingers (which is not uncommon for me). And on a number of occasions I've accidentally (and unknowingly) unlocked my phone while it's been in my pocket and subsequently a bunch of crazy stuff has happened (web-pages being opened, clicked through to weird places, accidental reply to an SMS etc).
- jihadjihad 9y agoI'm going to stick with TouchID. Even if my twin brother chose the same passcode as me and was able to unlock my phone with FaceID, he couldn't get past the fingerprint scanner.
- pilif 9y agoWell. If he knows your passcode, TouchID won’t be of any help anyways. Neither will FaceID of course
- stmfreak 9y agoWe should not use biometrics to unlock anyway. I keep waiting for apple to combine biometrics with passcode, but they don't and seem unwilling do offer that as an option... why is that? To be clear: face ID should authenticate you are the valid user, then prompt you for your passcode. Wrong face? No passcode challenge.
- zimpenfish 9y agoIs there a decent verified source for this with evidence? Every report of this I've seen has been sourced from the single same place.