3 ms·

The most important factors I'd say would be: (1) overall wealthy (compared to the rest of the world) (2) political stability, strong rule of law, low corrupti

The most important factors I'd say would be: (1) overall wealthy (compared to the rest of the world) (2) political stability, strong rule of law, low corruption (3) no extreme differences between rich and poor, with the majority being 'middle class' (neither rich, nor poor). (4) social redistribution and welfare system, reinforcing (3) by avoiding poverty traps (health issues, low education, debt spiral). (5) near mono-culture whose norms and values value conformity and avoiding social friction ("the needs of the many ...") (6) relative isolation to the rest of the world, very strict immigration laws, reinforcing (5) I can see the same properties (somewhat differently, of course) and results in Norway or Switzerland. All factors naturally reinforce each other. There's undoubtedly more, but I think those are the most important ones.

CryptoPunk 9y ago
>>social redistribution and welfare system, reinforcing (3) by avoiding poverty traps (health issues, low education, debt spiral). Japan has a Spartan welfare system: http://www.nytimes.com/1996/09/10/world/welfare-as-japan-knows-it-a-family-affair.html http://www.nytimes.com/1996/09/10/world/welfare-as-japan-kno...
- PhasmaFelis 9y ago
  I recall a ranking a few years back where Japan was the only country in the industrialized world whose welfare system ranked worse than America's.
- anvandare 9y ago
  I'm definitely far from knowledgeable on the Japanese welfare system (though that article is from 1996) but at least health care and education seem really cheap (and mandatory). As for the livelihood assistance part of welfare, it seems mostly old people make use of it (since unemployment is so low 2.8% in Japan) - which would link to what glandium said in another post: increase in theft by elders. https://www.japantimes.co.jp/opinion/2016/06/16/editorials/senior-citizens-welfare/ https://www.japantimes.co.jp/opinion/2016/06/16/editorials/s...
- jchb 9y ago
  Actually the welfare system is pretty extensive, but many people who need help are hesitant to use it. To quote of one of the guys in the article you linked: ''I could have used it, but I have too much pride,''. That quote sums up a good chunk of Japanese culture.
alphonsegaston 9y ago
Japan may have political “stability,” but it by no means has a low rate of corruption. Aside from the constant back room dealing where politicians hand out government contracts to their friends and supporters, Abe Shinzo’s party also has long standing ties to organized crime in Japan. And the “stability” itself is the result of American intelligence services intervention in their political system(dating back to the occupation) to undermine any leftist challenge to conservative rule. You can read about both circumstances in Tim Weiner’s book on the CIA, “Legacy of Ashes.”
LrnByTeach 9y ago
http://www.nytimes.com/1996/09/10/world/welfare-as-japan-knows-it-a-family-affair.html http://www.nytimes.com/1996/09/10/world/welfare-as-japan-kno... Scholars say that the system in Japan almost never breeds dependence, and they suggest that the Japanese approach has emphasized the work ethic and the importance of family ties. Caseworkers rigorously check applicants and drop by their homes regularly to make sure that they do not have banned luxuries like cars or air conditioners, and fraud seems extremely rare. Japan does have two elements of a social welfare program that far surpass anything in the United States: universal medical care and comprehensive day care. Everyone has access to doctors and hospitals at affordable prices, with the services free for the poor. And neighborhood nurseries throughout Japan provide excellent care for children from six months old to school age, if mothers work, for a modest fee that is waived for low-income families. Only 1% Japanese births are to unwed mothers. That compares with 30% of USA. ''The Japanese have a tendency to regard it as extremely shameful to receive welfare, and so they are hesitant,'' said Toshio Hata, a senior welfare official in Kawasaki. An applicant who owns a home is normally advised to sell it and use the proceeds until the money runs out -- and then to apply again. In May, a 96-year-old man was dropped from welfare because it came to light that he had $30,000 in savings. The caseworker told him to use that up and then reapply. A welfare worker has a caseload of about 60 in Japan, and there is time for regular, unscheduled visits to recipients' homes. The caseworkers have great discretion in handling cases, as well as considerable moral authority in advising recipients what to do.

CryptoPunk 9y ago

>>social redistribution and welfare system, reinforcing (3) by avoiding poverty traps (health issues, low education, debt spiral). Japan has a Spartan welfare system: http://www.nytimes.com/1996/09/10/world/welfare-as-japan-knows-it-a-family-affair.html http://www.nytimes.com/1996/09/10/world/welfare-as-japan-kno...

PhasmaFelis 9y ago
I recall a ranking a few years back where Japan was the only country in the industrialized world whose welfare system ranked worse than America's.
anvandare 9y ago
I'm definitely far from knowledgeable on the Japanese welfare system (though that article is from 1996) but at least health care and education seem really cheap (and mandatory). As for the livelihood assistance part of welfare, it seems mostly old people make use of it (since unemployment is so low 2.8% in Japan) - which would link to what glandium said in another post: increase in theft by elders. https://www.japantimes.co.jp/opinion/2016/06/16/editorials/senior-citizens-welfare/ https://www.japantimes.co.jp/opinion/2016/06/16/editorials/s...
jchb 9y ago
Actually the welfare system is pretty extensive, but many people who need help are hesitant to use it. To quote of one of the guys in the article you linked: ''I could have used it, but I have too much pride,''. That quote sums up a good chunk of Japanese culture.

alphonsegaston 9y ago

Japan may have political “stability,” but it by no means has a low rate of corruption. Aside from the constant back room dealing where politicians hand out government contracts to their friends and supporters, Abe Shinzo’s party also has long standing ties to organized crime in Japan. And the “stability” itself is the result of American intelligence services intervention in their political system(dating back to the occupation) to undermine any leftist challenge to conservative rule. You can read about both circumstances in Tim Weiner’s book on the CIA, “Legacy of Ashes.”

LrnByTeach 9y ago

http://www.nytimes.com/1996/09/10/world/welfare-as-japan-knows-it-a-family-affair.html http://www.nytimes.com/1996/09/10/world/welfare-as-japan-kno... Scholars say that the system in Japan almost never breeds dependence, and they suggest that the Japanese approach has emphasized the work ethic and the importance of family ties. Caseworkers rigorously check applicants and drop by their homes regularly to make sure that they do not have banned luxuries like cars or air conditioners, and fraud seems extremely rare. Japan does have two elements of a social welfare program that far surpass anything in the United States: universal medical care and comprehensive day care. Everyone has access to doctors and hospitals at affordable prices, with the services free for the poor. And neighborhood nurseries throughout Japan provide excellent care for children from six months old to school age, if mothers work, for a modest fee that is waived for low-income families. Only 1% Japanese births are to unwed mothers. That compares with 30% of USA. ''The Japanese have a tendency to regard it as extremely shameful to receive welfare, and so they are hesitant,'' said Toshio Hata, a senior welfare official in Kawasaki. An applicant who owns a home is normally advised to sell it and use the proceeds until the money runs out -- and then to apply again. In May, a 96-year-old man was dropped from welfare because it came to light that he had $30,000 in savings. The caseworker told him to use that up and then reapply. A welfare worker has a caseload of about 60 in Japan, and there is time for regular, unscheduled visits to recipients' homes. The caseworkers have great discretion in handling cases, as well as considerable moral authority in advising recipients what to do.