5 ms·
> The core idea (deploy an easter egg via an add-on) seems pretty reasonable Erm no. I don't use a browser to have fun. I certainly don't want any surprises, a
by ekianjo 9y ago
> The core idea (deploy an easter egg via an add-on) seems pretty reasonable
Erm no. I don't use a browser to have fun. I certainly don't want any surprises, and coming from Firefox/Mozilla this is very, very disappointing. How can we trust you guys to do the right thing from now on?
- khedoros1 9y agoThat's why you'd want it as an add-on, as opposed to core browser code. It's reasonable for all the silly crap that no one wants to be in the add-on directory. It's not reasonable for them to push the add-on to people that didn't choose to install it. That's the part I'm upset about.
- jasonlotito 9y agoTo be fair, Mozilla had a long history of easter eggs. So do other things that you'd want to take seriously (Tesla and Google for example). Easter eggs are a part of software culture whether you like it or not. > How can we trust you guys to do the right thing from now on? The same way you can continue to trust the GNU/Linux system which contains easter eggs.
- theclaw 9y agoThis is an advertisement in the form of an easter egg, that’s not common and not OK
- jodrellblank 9y agoOh the same way I can trust Canonical to include advertisements in Ubuntu? ( https://www.theinquirer.net/inquirer/news/2221490/eff-urges-canonical-to-make-ubuntu-1210-amazon-ads-optional https://www.theinquirer.net/inquirer/news/2221490/eff-urges-... ) Easter-eggs, to me, means something like "press a key combination, get a list of developers" or "go through the levels in a fast time, unlock a secret level" or "on march 14th there's a message about Pi day". It doesn't mean "if you change xyz settings, we'll sell some control to your system to a third party for our profit".
- Endy 9y ago> The same way you can continue to trust the GNU/Linux system which contains easter eggs. By which you mean, not at all, I assume.
- syshum 9y ago>>To be fair, Mozilla had a long history of easter eggs. This is not an easter Egg, I wish people would stop calling it that. This is a Paid Advertisement, injected with out my permission into my software. AKA Malware or Adware. Companies pay thousands of dollars a year to prevent that type of software from being loaded on their system. Firefox DOES NOT have a long history of being a distributor or malware or adware... Easter Eggs are funny things that Dev put into code that make people chuckle but have no impact on the actual software To call this a "Easter egg" is naive and ignorant. This is a Paid Promotional Advertisement of a Large Commercial project not an Easter egg
- jodrellblank 9y agoI do use a browser to have fun. I still don't want the browser having fun at my expense, and certainly not for advertising. (the upsidedownternet is over 10 years old at this point - http://www.ex-parrot.com/pete/upside-down-ternet.html http://www.ex-parrot.com/pete/upside-down-ternet.html is from at least 2006 - awkward out of touch big company advertising isn't fun)
- krzyk 9y agoDid you read pass the first sentence? He explains that including that addon for everyone by default is NOT OK. What he means by the first sentence is that using addon for easters eggs is OK (but users need to install it themselfs).