3 ms·
It's not: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/millionaire-ehsan-abdulaziz-who-said-he-accidentally-tripped-and-penetrated-teen-is-cleared-of-rape-a677494
by joshuamorton 9y ago
It's not: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/millionaire-ehsan-abdulaziz-who-said-he-accidentally-tripped-and-penetrated-teen-is-cleared-of-rape-a6774946.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/millionaire-ehsan...
And that's just the one I happen to remember because of the ridiculous excuse. I'm sure cursory research would dig up more.
None of the claims made in that post are plausible.
- naasking 9y agoYour response smacks of the typical over confidence of jury trials with surprising outcomes, like how people think the McDonald's coffee verdict was ridiculous until they actually learn all of the facts. The jury deliberated on this rape case for 30 minutes on all of the evidence and apparently easily reached a not guilty verdict, but this is apparently evidence of a grand conpsiracy rather than the more reasonable conclusion that the facts reported in this article do not convey the whole story.
- joshuamorton 9y agoI think that comparing that case and the McDonald's coffee case is ridiculous. You're correct, we weren't in the courtroom, but that doesn't make juries infallible.
- naasking 9y agoI'm not comparing them, I'm comparing your arguments against this case to the same arguments made about the McDonald's case. It's not about the cases themselves, but our ignorance of them.
- joshuamorton 9y agoExcept that I'm not equally ignorant, given that we know the defenses argument, and it's ridiculous.
- naasking 9y agoYou've presented a single vague summary of the defense argument (and given the non-guilty verdict and the article's presentation, is probably biased as well, but I reserve judgment). So it seems you really know very little given the evidence I've seen so far, and your insistence that you know enough is frankly disturbing.
- joshuamorton 9y ago>and your insistence that you know enough is frankly disturbing. I'd appreciate that you not make accusations like this, and I think this violates HN conduct guidelines. In any case. I've presented evidence that includes quotes from the testimony. You're argument rests on the jury having deliberated for 30 minutes. Juries are incredibly stupid. They can be misled, they can and do get things wrong, all the time. My argument can be summed up as "the jury is wrong, here's why". Your counterargument is "the jury disagrees with you". And to that I'd say "duh, that's why I said they're wrong". Using the Jury's conclusion as a counterargument to the statement "The jury is incorrect" is not an argument.
- naasking 9y agoNo, your argument can be summed up as, "based on these paltry and selectively quoted statements, I know better than a group of my peers who actually have all of the facts at their disposal." Your argument is frankly absurd, and not only will I double down on calling this argument disturbing, it's also arrogant. You are ignorant of all the facts and literally saying you don't need them to decide that this group of people is stupider than you, and that you can discern the truth based on a single, brief article about this trial. Finally, I made no accusation, I pointed out simple, obvious flaws in your argument. I made no claim about the defendant's innocence or guilt, but questioned your apparently unjustified certainty about the outcome. Calling juries stupid is not brave or insightful. Everyone is stupid. I'm stupid, and you're stupid. The fact that you think you're less stupid and don't need all the facts to ascertain the truth is also stupid. Go ahead and report me if you think I violated posting guidelines. Let someone else decide who is being more impartial.