3 ms·
"Given the similarities of the populations and the actual overlap of membership, in recent months I have been forced to conclude that the difference in culture
by pmoriarty 9y ago
"Given the similarities of the populations and the actual overlap of membership, in recent months I have been forced to conclude that the difference in culture is due to a difference in moderation. So, you do good work and should be proud of that."
Although the moderators certainly deserve credit for contributing to a civil atmosphere on HN, the users have a lot to do with it too. There's a lot of self-policing, as it were, going on here, with users who already buy in to HN's constructive comment ethic downvoting and calling out posts that go against that. That takes more than mere intelligence or education, but a willingness to adhere to commonly-shared norms of what's good for the site -- in HN's case it's constructive, helpful comments.
- dang 9y agoCouldn't agree more.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThere's a lot of self-policing The crux of my point is that I was really puzzled for a long time as to how on earth I could interact in two forums with some of the same members and people who are openly, persistently and consistently ugly to me in one successfully self police in the other and refrain from harassing me. That blew my mind for the longest time. It made no sense at all. I eventually concluded that a difference in moderation must be the difference that makes a difference. Perhaps that should have been said privately. I am not prone to flattery. That isn't the point of saying it here. The point is that it is a clear example that demonstrates the power of moderation. As someone who has done some moderating myself, it is an intriguing contrast.