5 ms·
So what would you do instead? Alice and Bob work together and Alice accuses Bob of rape (or really any personal crime like assault or theft). The police investi
by Spivak 9y ago
So what would you do instead? Alice and Bob work together and Alice accuses Bob of rape (or really any personal crime like assault or theft). The police investigate and either decide not to press charges or Bob is found not-guilty in court.
After the fact it's clear that Alice and Bob working together isn't good for either of them. And to the best of your knowledge Bob isn't guilty of anything -- unless you claim to know better than the police and the courts.
If you were the manager of Alice and Bob what action would you take that you belive is fair?
- Retric 9y agoThe courts are not designed to find the truth they are a complex compromise that evolved over time to protect both people and society. Having a different burden of proof for firing someone and sending them to prison is completely reasonable.
- Spivak 9y agoI don't necessarily disagree but then what should that burden be? "More likely than not?" I wouldn't even feel comfortable sending a child to time out if there was a 49% they didn't do it. Reasonable doubt is, at least to me, pretty much the gold standard for all forms of punitive action. Also, if you aren't going to follow the justice system's outcome then what system are you going to use to evaluate the evidence under the new burden? The court of office opinion sounds terrifying.
- rayiner 9y agoHere are the two failure modes. Say you believe Alice, but she’s lying. Then Bob gets fired or moved despite being innocent. Or, you believe Bob but he’s lying. So Alice has to either leave (the exact same result as Bob), or continue to work with her rapist (arguably a worse result). The two failure modes are equally bad. From the point of view of minimizing social harm, you want to minimize the sum of the two failure cases. Now, let’s look at the statistics. Rape is much more common than false accusations of rape. Now, you run a simulation using these statistics. What happens? The rule of believing Alice results in vastly more cases where you make the right decision than the rule where you believe Bob. And it results in vastly less social harm overall. So what’s fair? I’d assume that you’d say it’s to believe Bob, since you have no “hard evidence” to the contrary. (To nitpick: a sworn statement by a witness, Alice, is evidence admissible in court.) But that means that 10-20 women are forced to leave their jobs or work with their rapists for every one man who is spared from wrongly being fired due to a false accusation. From the point of view of minimizing social harm, you’ve failed. Of course, in reality, you’re usually going to have some other evidence to go on. Bob might say, “Alice is lying I was at the bar with my friends when the alleged rape happened.” If so then you should believe Bob, of course. The idea of shifting the burden of proof might not work in a criminal case, but for the reasons explained above, the considerations in a work place scenario are very different: false negatives are just as bad as false positives.
- abiox 9y ago> Rape is much more common than false accusations of rape. i'd wager that's true of every crime, from thievery to murder. what you're suggesting is to treat every accusation as true.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoI think they're saying that a massive percentage, about 98% of rape accusations will be true. And even when rape accusations are false, they're primarily not what the fertile imaginations of HN imagine, which seems to be women who've taken a dislike to some nerdy colleague for no reason, or the willing partner who decides later that it was actually rape. In reality, the majority of them are very young girls, or cheating wives, who need to come up with some alibi for their parents or husband and so invent a classic stranger with a knife rape scenario rather than point the finger at some innocent person. Often they don't even intend to go to the police but the parent who they lied to files on their behalf. https://qz.com/980766/the-truth-about-false-rape-accusations/ https://qz.com/980766/the-truth-about-false-rape-accusations... 10% of false rape reports may be made by people in the hope of recieving medical care they need for other reasons, which is a tragic statistic in itself.
- abiox 9y agoyour link states: "To classify a case as a false allegation, a thorough investigation must yield evidence that a crime did not occur." 2-10% provably false allegations does not mean 90-98% are true. i have little doubt that most allegations speak to truth, but it also seems to me that trying to manipulate numbers in this way isn't beneficial.
- tfha 9y agoAlso, if we construct our society such that making false accusations is a way to get what you want, certainly the number of false accusations will rise.
- ZeroGravitas 9y ago
- tfha 9y agoAs a practical manager, I would require that either Alice or Bob switch teams, far enough that they no longer need to interact, and also give either the option to amicably leave the company. There's not much more you can do. You address the tension, you don't assign blame, and you make sure both people have enough room to live healthy lives. Now, if this is the second or third time Bob has been put in this situation, he's gone. And if this is the second or third time that Alice has been put in this position, she's gone.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoSo what would you do instead? When Cheryl Yeoh posted her story, I wrote a few blog posts positing that we ought to focus on prevention. You and most people here are kind of assuming that the only point at which Microsoft had power to intercede was after the woman was sexually assaulted and now has this horrible dilemma of whether or not to work with her rapist. But the incident occurred because she went out for drinks with colleagues, got too drunk to drive home and crashed at the home of a colleague. Microsoft could have had policies about how to handle work related functions that discouraged drunkenness, discouraged a woman crashing at a male colleague's house instead of being put up in a hotel if she couldn't make it home, etc. No one ever brings up that angle but me and when I do, I get accused of blaming the victim.
- makesthingspos 9y ago> discouraged drunkenness, discouraged a woman crashing at a male colleague's house instead of being put up in a hotel Doesn't it seem ridiculous that companies need to have these kind policies or risk lawsuits and being smeared as cultivating a culture of rape? It seems to me that employers shouldn't have to babysit their adult employees or be their parents. Maybe instead of having employers be parents, society could reinforce the idea that parents/family/individuals be responsible. For example, not getting hammered, calling a cab if one can't drive, not going out alone (or as the only female in a group), not staying the night at the home of someone of the opposite sex, not having sex before marriage, courtship is chaperoned, etc. Oh no, how patriarchal! Instead, it's seen as reasonable for one's employer/university/etc to decide if one's sex life is consensual and make sure one has a safe bed to sleep in when one goes out partying! > discouraged drunkenness I'm sure this isn't what you meant, but imagine if Microsoft had a policy that punished an employee if they were found to have gotten exceptionally drunk outside work like in this scenario. First, it could only be applied to the accused, never the accuser. Imagine if this purported rape victim were punished because she admits she got very drunk before the rape happened. People would go crazy at that. They'd blame Microsoft for punishing the victim. They'd demand all rape accusers be given immunity from any punishment for misdeeds they did before the purported rape took place, lest the punishment for what they did discourage them from reporting the rape. Btw, very much enjoyed your thoughtful well-reasoned comments in this thread!