9 ms·
Traffic Engineers’ Epic Fail
- mjevans 9y agoHow about actual civil engineering and commute design? DO NOT have public schools and other such facilities RIGHT NEXT to the high speed corridors. Those belong in the middle of residential areas. Design it for the safety of the pedestrians too. Some nice unclimbable walls that clearly show no other path across than the crosswalk (with as another reply stated, should be BRIGHT and VISIBLE). Yes, there should be safety space between the road and that wall; but it should deny reward for skipping the crosswalk.
- ebcode 9y agoCompelling article, but marred by the click-baity title. It would be more respectful of the bereaved to reserve "Epic Fail" for things less tragic than the loss of a child. "Tragic Failure" might be more appropriate.
- spraak 9y agoYeah, "Epic Fail" in my mind is most associated with humor from meme culture.
- adrianmonk 9y agoIt seems like it couldn't hurt (even if cars drove 20 mph) for the crosswalk to be about 10 times more visible as well. There's a small sign, but people don't always notice those, nor do they often think to look for them on a stretch of road not near an intersection. And in fact, based on Google Street View imagery, it appears they are in the process of doing exactly that: https://www.google.com/maps/@41.0919153,-112.0647278,3a,75y,20.28h,88.49t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1snEiLYiNnALhLbENgKyO3rg!2e0!7i13312!8i6656 https://www.google.com/maps/@41.0919153,-112.0647278,3a,75y,... My city has some crosswalks with big, obvious flashing lights similar to this, and they really catch your attention more. Some of them have button that immediately turns the flashing lights on so you don't really have to wait for lights to cycle like you do at a normal intersection, which probably makes them more effective.
- stevenwoo 9y agoThe four lane street (San Antonio south of El Camino) near where I live used to just have painted crosswalks but after two pedestrians were killed in a short span of time they added the flashing lights in the crosswalk to the ones close to El Camino and Foothill, no one has been killed crossing the street in the ten years since even though traffic anecdotally seems to have gone up a lot (knock on wood).
- dleslie 9y agoEvery time I travel to the USA on business I am aghast by how poorly the cities are designed for use by human beings, and how evident it is that the free mobility of automobiles is the primary consideration of urban design. Just look at those pictures. How can anyone live in that area and not think that they live in an environment and society that is openly hostile to pedestrians (school children)?
- closeparen 9y agoIn this kind of place, humans receive cars two years before they receive personhood (16 to drive vs. 18 to be the sole signer on a bank account). Thinking of drivers and people in general as separate categories is nonsensical. If a place isn't easy to drive to and park at, then it isn't designed for the human beings who live in American suburbia. Mainstream American culture holds that it is apartment buildings and street life which are the true menaces to children. From the Street View, this place would be considered ideal to raise a family, because there's plenty of room for huge houses and huge yards/open nature areas between them. That children can't transport themselves beyond the closed-world snow-globe of your immediate subdivision is considered a feature, as it limits the trouble they can get into. The most they should be doing without your accompaniment (in this mindset) is playing with other neighborhood kids in parks or in each other's houses.
- dionidium 9y agoYour first sentence here is most interesting to me. This is an aspect of car culture that's sometimes overlooked, but what it does is infantilize adolescents and provide an arbitrary blocker to normal human behavior (e.g. shopping, visiting cafes alone, etc) until the child is old enough to drive to those places. A kid in Manhattan is in society and has access to everything his parents do. A kid in the suburbs is outside society, in some very meaningful sense. His access to the broader culture is mediated through television, perhaps, but he's not actually there. He visits society when his parents feel like driving him there. [0] Who is surprised, then, that the car represents freedom to so many of these kids? Where I grew up, a car was needed for everything, which meant that I had almost no access to the normal world at age 15 and almost unlimited access on my 16th birthday. Like a fish who doesn't know what water is, most Americans don't even realize that car culture is all around them. And an appreciation for the status quo is baked in very early. The car is simply how you get places. How could it be any other way? [0] I think this is actually really important. A twelve-year-old should be able to pick up some groceries, mail a letter, grab a bite to eat at a lunch counter, and so on, but these basic acts of socialization are completely alien to suburban kids.
- bsder 9y agoUm, what isn't being pointed out is that there is a freakin' WalMart Supercenter right around the corner. That road is a thoroughfare--this isn't the "middle of nowhere" like the picture makes it look. I have lots of questions: Why isn't there a pedestrian bridge? Why are the schools on opposite sides of the road when there is obviously land on the same side? Why is there a major thoroughfare in front of a school? I know the answer: nobody is willing to sign off with money until the outcry is large enough. It seems like the traffic engineers know that there is a problem (15 accidents in the last 5 years and a traffic light plan already in flight), but you can tell from the article that all their solutions are cheap. That tells me everything I need to know.
- riffic 9y agoYou may not know this but in certain circles the word "accident" is not in vogue anymore -- the preferred description is crash or collision. https://www.google.com/search?q=crash+not+accident https://www.google.com/search?q=crash+not+accident
- zten 9y agoHere's my guesses... > Why isn't there a pedestrian bridge? Signals that you don't really care about people walking or people with disabilities and want them to drive. Ok, that was flippant, I realize, but the only time I've seen anyone use prefer overpasses and such is the Vegas strip and that's because it is outright hostile to walk next to or across. > Why is there a major thoroughfare in front of a school? Everybody is driven to school. Look at the land use around the school.
- Spivak 9y agoPedestrian bridges, or tunnels which would probably be more appropriate here, are perfectly accessible to the handicapped. They even go so far as to encourage walking because its now easier to cross the road. We have such a tunnel in my hometown for the local elementary school and it works pretty okay.
- philsnow 9y agoThere are tons of pedestrian bridges in Hong Kong, for instance [0]. This is over a complicated intersection with a large street that has a lot of bus traffic, so it makes more sense for people to go up and over to cross the street rather than for there to be ground-level crossings with confusing traffic patterns. Hong Kong is very pedestrian friendly. [0] http://static.panoramio.com/photos/large/45505811.jpg http://static.panoramio.com/photos/large/45505811.jpg
- maxsilver 9y agoTraffic engineers didn't decide to put two different school across from one another. Perhaps they could have built the elementary school and high school on the same side of the street? Like say, in the giant empty field right there next to the school (pictured in the article). Traffic engineers didn't decide to put the school on a busy arterial State-Designated Highway. Syracuse Utah has just 6 main arterial roads, and over 50+ small slow neighborhood streets. 90% of the roads in this town are already slow side streets safe for children (the exact ones StrongTowns advocates for), why did they build the schools exclusively on the 5% of roads designated to handle actual traffic needs? -- Ironically, we have a safer way to build streets like this. It's called a freeway, and it's great because it keeps nearly 100% grade-separation between people driving and people walking, while still handling massive transit requirements at high speeds. But we can't have those in cities, because StrongTowns hates them. They are too safe, promote affordable housing too much, and let people get to too many places too quickly. StrongTowns gets the luxury of claiming every street should be impossible to drive on, and can prattle on about how cheap it is to destroy a street (it costs nothing!). Because StrongTowns does not do any actual engineering or design, they are simply a political campaign against cars. Real traffic engineers have to actually handle transportation needs of real citizens everyday. Real traffic engineers don't get the luxury of just wishing away peoples lives, or jobs, or homes. So while I'm sure this will be an unpopular opinion, I don't see anything wrong with traffic engineers work here. I see a school system that decided building two schools on opposite sides of a "State Highway 108" was a great idea, and is now suffering terrible consequences because of it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utah_State_Route_108 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utah_State_Route_108
- revelation 9y agoYou haven't even established the timeline here. In any case, it doesn't matter, someone decided to put a crosswalk across a four-lane 40 mph road. There is no world where this is acceptable design backed by evidence. And in any case, if the tradeoff you are suggesting is dead kids versus "impossible to drive on, war on cars" I'm sure where an engineers opinion will fall. But traffic engineers aren't all that.
- 9y ago
- dingo_bat 9y agoThis is bullshit. A street designer has one job, to make the street good for driving. It is pedestrians responsibility to look and cross safely. It is driver's responsibility to not hit people who may have strayed onto the street. It is the car's responsibility to detect a human and apply the brakes automatically. It seems only the street designer did his job properly.
- sitharus 9y agoI’d love to agree with you, but unfortunately as humans we are not infallible. We cannot rely on people to look in every direction and see every hazard constantly. The driver may have been distracted, for example by sun strike, and the pedestrian may have not seen the car due to its colour. Roads need to be designed for their purpose, and their purpose also includes allowing pedestrians to cross safely even if the pedestrian and the driver suffer from a momentary distraction.
- PhasmaFelis 9y ago> This is bullshit. A street designer has one job, to make the street good for driving. The field you're referring to is called "highway engineering" or "traffic engineering", depending on specifics, and safety is absolutely a critical component either way.
- gregatragenet3 9y agoA side note but something that this article relates to. Here in Pacific Beach California, the traffic engineers have created a perfect storm of pedestrian danger. See, they've installed these lighted flashing crosswalk signs activated by a button on a pole. Awesome idea, as a pedestrian I can hit a button and think that drivers are alerted to my crossing.. as a driver I no longer have to search the shadows on sidewalks for pedestrians because of the lights. Now as a pedestrian and a driver I'm conditioned to depend on the lights.. but now that they've been in place for months the lights are failing and public works doesn't replace them regularly. We now depend on the lights to keep peds safe, and their unreliability is an accedent waiting to happen.
- eru 9y agoLondon is the opposite: red lights are merely advisory for pedestrians. People just cross the streets. That has trained drivers to be very attentive. Add in that usual London traffic moves at about bicycle speed, and the central part of town is a very human friendly place.
- rahimnathwani 9y agoBeijing is the opposite: red lights are merely advisory for drivers. Cars just cross the pedestrian crossings. That has trained pedestrians to be very attentive.
- d4rti 9y agoIt's pretty great, and the bike lanes just keep getting better.
- eru 9y agoYes. It's gotten so good that I feel the main impediment to cycling has become air quality rather than cars.
- jessaustin 9y agoThose factors seem to be related, don't they? b^)
- GalacticDomin8r 9y agoWhy is the math wrong if this is a "traffic engineer"? > A quick physics lesson: The force of impact from a car increases quadratically with speed. This means that doubling the speed quadruples the force of the impact. That is absolutely not what quadratically means.
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoIt's not? I'm not a mathematician, but Wikipedia says "In mathematics, a function or sequence is said to exhibit quadratic growth when its values are proportional to the square of the function argument or sequence position."
- GalacticDomin8r 9y agoThat's my point. The wiki definition you have cited is correct, but it doesn't compute with the article.
- DannyBee 9y agoI'll save everyone else the trouble. The original data is from https://www.aaafoundation.org/sites/default/files/2011PedestrianRiskVsSpeed.pdf https://www.aaafoundation.org/sites/default/files/2011Pedest... If you look, on page 9, you can see the plots of impact speed vs risk of death. They are clearly non-linear, and they you can also read that they tried various fitting methods for missing data (and quadratic best fit things). I'm just guessing that you are confused because it does not appear the constant for the x^2 term is >1.
- GalacticDomin8r 9y agoI'll make it even easier: http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/impcal.html#c1 http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/impcal.html#c1
- scotty79 9y agoQuadratic relationship is between the speed and force of impact. If you want to accelerate pedestrian to certain speed you have to pump kinetic energy into him. You do that by applying a force over some distance (distance is how much pedestrian will squish during impact before it starts moving with the car) so to acellerate to double speed, you need to pump in quadruple energy, you need to quadruple the force since squishing distance is the same (until you reach speeds that pulverize pedestrian bones).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jessaustin 9y agoSometimes car drivers have to slow down. Maybe on a big, straight street. Maybe on a state highway. Maybe on the main street in town. Even in those situations, if there is a crosswalk in regular use for most of the day, they've got to slow down. If they don't, the street must be changed until they do. That is the most important task a traffic engineer in small-town Utah has. It shouldn't take 15 crashes in 5 years to prompt that action. It shouldn't take an additional fatal crash with a child victim to prompt it. Anyone who doesn't understand any part of this should never drive on public roads.
- justinph 9y agoYou can put all the speed limit signs you want on that street, but it doesn't change the fact that the road is too wide and straight and people will go the speed they feel comfortable at, regardless of the signs. That street needs to be narrowed, have parked cars on the side, have speed tables, a boulevard, dynamic feedback signs, or other traffic calming measures. Physical objects and changes to the environment are what cause drivers to slow down in urban environments, not flimsy metal signs. There have been numerous studies and research projects on this. Here's one by the Federal Highway Administration showing the effects of various traffic calming techniques in situations just like this one: https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/publications/research/safety/08067/ https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/publications/research/safety/08067/
- jessaustin 9y agoYou're preaching to the choir. All of that stuff is what I meant when I said "If they don't [slow down], the street must be changed until they do." I assumed there were already signs in place.
- bmsleight_ 9y agoMy condolences to the family. I hope this can learn to valuable learning from this loss of life. Really interested in what data analysis is done in the states regarding (KSI - Killed and Serious Injured). In the UK we hold good data and can related designs and design improvement to the KSI. I strongly agree with the article, we should aim for zero-killed. The balance can be vehicle congestion vs. space vs. cost vs. time. Because our modelling is very good we can tell the impact of a new school and the behaviour of the pedestrians. I could talk about the hierarchy of roads, but Traffic Engineers need to start influencing the politicians that make some of the decisions. How ? - By clear data and model that show with this design you will have this KSIs.
- Zak 9y ago> The street separating these two schools in Syracuse was designed for speed, which means it was designed to kill. This is hyperbole. The street is designed to efficiently move car traffic. The design error here is in creating a situation where a large number of children will walk across it. The author's goal appears to be to design streets so that they make getting hit by a car less deadly, which strikes me as perverse. It's certainly possible to make the street better for walking across by making it worse at efficiently moving car traffic, but it's also possible to replace the crosswalk with a pedestrian overpass and eliminate the conflict entirely.
- Empact 9y agoAny street that doesn't seriously consider the safety of people needing to cross it is functionally a wall or a hazard, whatever the uses surrounding it. If you create a conflict and don't try to make it less deadly, how do you describe that? Pedestrian overpasses require those who cross to physically climb over traffic. Better than a wall, but let's acknowledge the cost of that. They're also enormous and expensive, whether you design them terribly or well.[1] The calming proposals include: narrower lanes, a raised median, and a traffic light to explicitly priortize and protect pedestrians when crossing. What about those makes them an imposition? [1] https://candysdirt.com/2016/04/28/fugly-pedestrian-bridge-harry-hines-walnut-hill-cost-us-4-6-million/ https://candysdirt.com/2016/04/28/fugly-pedestrian-bridge-ha... http://m.sfgate.com/bayarea/place/article/Footbridge-an-elegant-new-icon-in-East-Bay-3171157.php http://m.sfgate.com/bayarea/place/article/Footbridge-an-eleg...
- Zak 9y agoRequiring people to climb over traffic doesn't seem like an unreasonable imposition in most cases. That sort of physical activity is even a health benefit for most people. I'm sure there are exceptions. All of the calming proposals create an imposition. The whole point of traffic calming is to impede the flow of traffic so as to reduce its speed. Without effective alternatives, reducing the speed of this road reduces its capacity to get people from one part of town to another, and it appears that state road 108 is, in fact a major road. It provides access to a number of businesses including a Walmart supercenter, churches, four public schools and city hall. The obvious alternative to driving is a public bus service, which also uses the road. It stops near the two schools hourly most times of day. So to make the interaction of the road and the schools safer, the city could redesign the road and make traffic worse, more substantially redesign the whole transportation infrastructure, or add a pedestrian overpass. The latter is not an insignificant project, but it usually costs less than the examples you linked.
- glogla 9y ago"Traffic Engineers’ Epic Fail" "Let's Turn this Dangerous, Expensive Road Back into a Safe Neighborhood Street" "Dying to Widen Highways - Oregon’s DOT seems to be more concerned with making cars go faster than saving lives." The site seems to have a rather ... specific focus.
- ebiester 9y agoIt’s a blog about city planning that is espousing a contrarian view. It isn’t limited to cars, but it does take a strong point that designing cities around cars has significant consequences.
- justinph 9y agoStrong Towns has far from a contrarian view. Perhaps to civil & traffic engineers, but to urban planners, it is well known the detrimental effects streets can have on cities.