3 ms·
I'm copying an observation I made on a similar thread about Mill a few weeks ago: --- [...] Mill should be taken holistically -- he's a Utilitarian[1], and is
by woodruffw 9y ago
I'm copying an observation I made on a similar thread about Mill a few weeks ago:
---
[...] Mill should be taken holistically -- he's a Utilitarian[1], and is firmly committed to his version of the principle of utility (the "Greatest Happiness Principle"). Reading a practical prescription of free speech as a moral (or even lesser, legal) prescription would lead to a contradiction in any circumstance where the GHP says that restricting speech would promote happiness (e.g., where incitement leads to murder).
[1]: Specifically, on my interpretation, he's an act utilitarian. I've seen him read as an rule utilitarian (and parts 4 and on of his Utilitarianism can support that reading), but his first formulation of the GHP is pretty unambiguous:
> [...] actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness, wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness [...]
---
This is a tension that is frequently pointed out in academic philosophy in Mill's works -- he switches between principles and actions frequently, and contradicts himself by valuing free speech qua principle rather than means.