4 ms·
"Rape cases are hard to prove" Why are rape cases like this hard to prove? She was pass-out drunk, and the accused had sex with her. That's all the prosecu
by bryanlarsen 9y ago
"Rape cases are hard to prove"
Why are rape cases like this hard to prove? She was pass-out drunk, and the accused had sex with her. That's all the prosecutor should have to prove, there should be no she-said, he-said over consent.
Courts regularly rule that people don't have the capacity to sign a contract while drunk, yet somehow they do have the capacity to consent to sex? Come on.
Even if she did say yes, it's still rape in my opinion.
I know that drunken sex is the traditional way to consummate a relationship in modern Western culture, so this would be quite a difficult cultural change.
But IMO such a change would do more to strengthen the drunk college party tradition than it would to weaken it. Girls would be even more likely to party wildly if they weren't scared of being assaulted while doing so...
- volgo 9y agoYou also need to prove they had sex. Many victims are highly vulnerable after the attack and many don't seek to do a rape kit. It's a highly complicated problem with no clear black and white solution
- DoreenMichele 9y agoDo we have video of the event? Do we have eye witnesses who saw the sexual encounter? Do we know for sure what happened between two people when most likely no one else was around? Most cases of rape absolutely are a case of he said, she said because in most cases they are the only two people present when the encounter occurred. You can come up with physical evidence showing that intercourse happened and that she had high levels of alcohol in her system. You can come up with witnesses that the man and woman in question attended an event together and she went and crashed at his place. All of that is called circumstantial evidence. So unless you have something like videotape of the assault, it very often comes down to the testimony of two people -- him and her -- and which one you believe the most. Because the definition of rape hinges on the detail of consent. That is almost always the case. Sex typically occurs privately. There are usually no other witnesses to sexual intercourse aside from the two people who had intercourse. This is generally true whether the incident was consenting or not.
- bryanlarsen 9y ago"You can come up with physical evidence showing that intercourse happened and that she had high levels of alcohol in her system" And I'm saying that's all that necessary. With high levels of alcohol I claim that she could say "Yes, please" and it would still be rape: she didn't have the capacity for consent.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoIf he was also drunk, could we equally charge her with rape (or sexual assault) if we have physical evidence that a) sex occurred and b) both were legally intoxicated? Most incidents of first time sex -- ie the first sexual encounter for this specific couple -- involve alcohol.* Are we going to start willy nilly charging both parties with rape for all such incidents? * at least in the US they seem to.
- skj 9y agoYes, but social pressures make it hard for a man to make that accusation. Comments like the one you made, for instance.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoWhat did I say that you feel constitutes social pressure that makes it hard for a man to accuse a woman of rape? Because I am quite confused by your comment.
- skj 9y agoYour question, as posed, presumed the answer would be different for men than for women. Why else pose it?
- DoreenMichele 9y agoNo, my question, as posed, presumes that the person I am addressing has not thought this through and they are assuming that only women can be raped. They are ready to hang a man high for having sex with an intoxicated woman with no additional evidence beyond "Sex happened and she was intoxicated." I asked it to rebut their unstated but obvious (and erroneous) assumption that only men are rapists and only women are victims of sexual assault.
- arcticfox 9y ago> But IMO such a change would do more to strengthen the drunk college party tradition than it would to weaken it. Girls would be even more likely to party wildly if they weren't scared of being assaulted while doing so... I don't think you thought that one all the way through. They also wouldn't be allowed to have sex afterwards under any circumstances, which for a lot of women I know would be a problem. As far as I know this is already the law essentially, but not in practice.