3 ms·
Eh, what's dehumanising about remembering the power structure in a typical work environment? For instance- it's very good sense to remember that the people who
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
Eh, what's dehumanising about remembering the power structure in a typical work environment?
For instance- it's very good sense to remember that the people who are under your management are employed to do as you say and don't just freely decide to grant you their time and attention. When the social context is of communication between work colleagues, you are very likely to make a mistake if you interpret it in the same way as communication between friends.
Consider for instance the situation where The Boss Made a Joke. A sensible boss will recognise that people aren't necessarily laughing at their jokes because they consider them funny- but because it is polite to laugh at colleagues' jokes, and you are expected to be polite to your boss. So a manager who keeps on cracking jokes, thinking that everyone finds them so funny, is not acting sensibly and is making a social mistake. A boss who keeps the jokes to a minimum required to keep morale high, is actually keeping morale high.
At the end of the day, what everyone must realise, managers and reports alike, is that your colleagues are not your friends. To the extent that you don't make the decision who to work with (because someone else hires them, or they hire you) you are also not choosing to socialise with them. You are obliged to socialise with them in the context of work.
Btw, I recognise that the OP is actually totally treating his (?) employees as friends- but there you have it. I think that's inappropriate and can only lead to tears.
- noobermin 9y agoAlright, here's my thoughts: You can be friends with your workers if they are friendly. If not, just be professional. There should be no reason to either have to a) force employees to be friends or b) force employees to be robots. For fuck's sake, the issue here is sexual assault and harrassment, it's a far cry from misinterpretation of comments or intent, which for some reason, people think is a bigger deal than the abuse women and men have faced in the workplace. How about you respect people as people? That seems like a better prescription than forcing people to be cold to each other. I do agree some of the rules are different with bosses, as the maxim goes, with great power comes great responsibility. But your conclusion that colleagues are not your friends seems ridiculous to me. It ignores the organizations where people are friends and there are no issues. So I am being a little combative, but please tell me how this opinion is still problematic. I am genuinely open minded and want to discuss this.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoI don't mind if you're being combative, but I think, if you're being combative, then it's about something I never said- the bit about "forcing people to be cold to each other". Are you reading more than I wrote, in my comment? For what it's worth, I consider "being friendly" and "being friends" two distinct categories. You can be friendly to people (or polite, corteous, respectful etc etc) without actually being buddy-buddies with them. On a personal note, I have been lucky to have had some strong working relationships with (male) colleagues who offered me valuable mentorship. They were great teachers to me and helped make me the professional I am today. Still- we were not friends, in the sense of slapping-the-back, rude-joking, buddy-buddies. I'm not saying that sort of relation (a colleague who's your mate) can never work. All rules are made to be broken etc etc. But I do believe that unless you carefully compartmentalise your professional relationships from other kinds of relationships, you run a very significant risk of making a mess of all your relationships. Edit: as to ignoring organisations were people are friends and the sky doesn't fall- that's just the survivorship fallacy, innit. Just because you can swim with sharks without being eaten doesn't mean swimming with sharks isn't dangerous, in general.