5 ms·
One night after the conference talks were over, a bunch of conference participants and I went for a swim in the ocean. While I was swimming around, S repeatedly
by nerdponx 9y ago
One night after the conference talks were over, a bunch of conference participants and I went for a swim in the ocean. While I was swimming around, S repeatedly grabbed me under the water, putting his hands on my torso, hips, and thighs. I tried to play it off and swim away. He picked me up and pulled me into his chest. He then started to carry me away from the rest of the group, presumably to have some sort of private moment with me that I had absolutely no interest in sharing with him. I struggled, gently at first and then more forcefully, and he let me go.
How is this not outright assault? Why are the police not involved and why is this guy not being charged with anything? Why is anyone concerned about protecting his privacy?
- ajross 9y agoChecking the author's twitter, it looks like the guy has been named at this point. And it's not assault because it's not. He was playing in the pool, she disengaged successfully. If you push someone in expectation of a bar fight and they walk away, the police likewise aren't going to pursue charges. That doesn't excuse it, of course. But there's a limit to the protection we can get from law enforcement. Obviously if it happens repeatedly, this can be harrassment, which is something that can be pursued via civil means.
- graeme 9y agoHave a look at the comment I wrote in reply. It is assault. There are reasons why assault isn't prosecuted, but we should be aware of the nature of the offense. (And, probably sexual assault, but that depends on how it's defined in the jurisdiction. In Canada this would be sexual assault)
- graeme 9y agoAjross, in case you're reading replies, your comment above has been flagged and is dead. I don't believe it deserved that. I do think what you wrote has a legal mistake, but there's no malice, and it's a fairly common mistake.
- ajross 9y agoI suspect it was the pointer to the naming on twitter that got the flag, FWIW. Not a big deal.
- pkd 9y agoWhen somebody punches you, it's physical assault, regardless if you punch back or not. Similarly when somebody tries to force you into a sexual situation without your consent, it's sexual assault, regardless of whether you end up escaping it.
- graeme 9y agoIt is assault (and in Canada at least, would be sexual assault). The trouble with both offenses is that 1. They are broad, 2. They are hard to prove criminally Broad isn't a problem per se. What I mean is that the system is set up to make the offense as wide as possible, but not to prosecute every case. This occurs with regular assault, not just sexual. For example, I'm sure most people reading this have had someone shove them at one point. I'm also sure that crime was not reported to the police. Even most cases of punching probably aren't reported. Next, the proof. The problem with both types of assault is that generally there is no evidence other than the words of the victim. Convictions can happen, but it makes it hard to do so in the less serious cases, which leave no mark. So apart from non-seriousness, that's why shoving isn't prosecuted. Whereas attacking someone and leaving cuts, bruises or broken bones provides definite evidence something happened. It both increases the gravity of the case and the provability. I've used examples from regular assault to show that low rates of prosecution/conviction aren't merely an issue of sexism. Assault/sexual assault are fundamentally hard offenses. However, this absolutely has a disproportionate effect on women. Generally speaking, people don't go around assaulting people, and so low rates of prosecution for assault is not really a problem in most cases. (What I mean here is that not enough people commit unprovoked common assault for it to be a common experience on the receiving end. Domestic abuse is likely the biggest place our system has a gap in this regard.) But, enough people sexually assault women that it is a common experience, especially for offenses which fit the category of: 1. Leaves no mark or lasting physical harm, 2. Has no outside evidence, 3. Is nonetheless psychologically traumatic. I don't know what to do about this. I think the solution probably starts by recognizing the nature of the situation, which is why I've spelled it out.
- Sir_Substance 9y ago>What I mean is that the system is set up to make the offense as wide as possible, but not to prosecute every case. Which is terrifying, because it undermines the notion of a jury trial.
- graeme 9y agoHow? This has been an intrinsic feature of common assault since time immemorial. I imagine most cases of assault in the middle ages were not brought to trial either. But, if something does go to trial, it's still up to the jury to decide.