4 ms·
That's largely how VAT (value added tax) works in theory: A company collects VAT on what they sell, and counter that with VAT on what they buy, so that they eff
by vidarh 9y ago
That's largely how VAT (value added tax) works in theory: A company collects VAT on what they sell, and counter that with VAT on what they buy, so that they effectively pay a tax on the "value added".
The problem with all of these things is that when you can pick and choose jurisdictions, then playing them up against each other becomes easy: Sell said phone for 690 from a low tax jurisdiction to the Italian company, and the "value added" on that 700 sale is 10.
This is one of the tricks they also use to avoid income taxes: Shift the revenue to a low tax country by applying trickery in terms of how subsidiaries shift products and revenue between themselves.
But this example also shows why you can't just tax people on the total value rather than the added value unless the tax is set very low:
For the majority of companies that don't control the whole value chain, the margin between the import price and the price the product is sold on to retailers at might very well genuinely be <10%. Any such tax on the total retail value that makes a dent in the Apple's of the world is likely to bankrupt large numbers of local companies.
If you were to apply such a tax at every step in the value chain, it'd very quickly become a big problem.
And while it might seem "easy" to instead e.g. put such a tax only on final products sold to end users in some product categories, it'd lead to a massive complexity in trying to create rules that are not trivially easy to evade with small changes to the way the products are sold.
In other words: The idea is good, but creating rules that are possible to enforce and not full of loopholes is where these thins tends to fall apart.
- kgwgk 9y ago> Sell said phone for 690 from a low tax jurisdiction to the Italian company, and the "value added" on that 700 sale is 10. You're still paying the VAT on the 690 on the "low tax" country (and the lowest standard VAT rate in the EU is 17%).
- vidarh 9y agoYes, but the retailer is not, as the retailer will get any VAT paid on the 690 refunded (or in most jurisdictions will simply pay the difference).
- kgwgk 9y agoI really don’t know what is the problem that this example is supposed to illustrate. This is VAT working as expected, each participant in the chain pays for the difference between the revenue they get from their customers and the cost of goods they pay to their providers.
- vidarh 9y agoIt wasn't illustrating a problem. On the contrary.
- kgwgk 9y agoOk. I was confused because the complete sentence read: > The problem with all of these things is that when you can pick and choose jurisdictions, then playing them up against each other becomes easy: Sell said phone for 690 from a low tax jurisdiction to the Italian company, and the "value added" on that 700 sale is 10.