6 ms·
>... he touched me on the leg and told me that my dress was “way too sexy for a poster session.” This seems to have been their first interaction. Touching her
by mirimir 9y ago
>... he touched me on the leg and told me that my dress was “way too sexy for a poster session.”
This seems to have been their first interaction. Touching her was plainly a dumb-ass move. Plus his consistent deafness to her repeated "I'm not interested" feedback.
But his comment about professional dress could have been made far more constructively. When I encounter provocatively-dressed women in professional contexts, I'm immediately suspicious. Are they stylishly clueless? Are they trying to manipulate others? Are they making a point about women being free to dress as they like?
I mean, I invite you to log about outfits worn by your male and female professional colleagues. Assess overall tightness, especially legs, butt and breasts. Estimate percentage of bare skin, especially cleavage.
For example, you may see women in tight sleavless tshirts aka wifebeaters, plus short skirts. How many men will be wearing tight wifebeaters with short pants and sandals? Not many, I bet.
- helpComputer 9y ago> But his comment about professional dress could have been made far more constructively. When I encounter provocatively-dressed women... It's not at all clear from her blog post that she was dressed provocatively, or that he was sincerely commenting on the appropriateness of her appearance. This could just as easily have been a scenario where a man thinks a woman looks good and lets her know that he thinks so, while simultaneously criticizing her for his advantage, ie, negging. But with the information we have, we just don't know. It's like an ambiguous personal email that one can project attitudes onto; if you're feeling defensive or threatened, then it's easy to read a perfectly neutral message as being hostile or even sarcastic.
- daveFNbuck 9y agoWhen I was a grad student, shorts and sandals is absolutely what I would wear to a poster session. I never had anyone comment on what I was wearing. If I did somehow manage to cross a line, I would expect to hear about it from my friends or my advisor, not from a stranger. Most of your complaints seem to be that men and women have different standards for work-appropriate clothing. If bare arms are too provocative for you, that is a personal problem that you need to work on.
- mirimir 9y agoIt's not at all a problem for me. However, maybe it's a problem for them. Prudent men won't comment or act out. But many men (and women) will judge. Like it or not, it's what's so.
- daveFNbuck 9y agoThere isn't any outfit a woman won't be judged negatively for wearing. You could do a lot more good by speaking up when people are judging.
- mirimir 9y agoSure. But conservatively stylish presentation is arguably the best strategy for career advancement. At least, in academica.
- daveFNbuck 9y agoAre you saying that it's appropriate to give arguably good unsolicited advice to strangers about their appearance?
- mirimir 9y agoNo. I thought that I made that clear. Such advice is appropriate from family, close friends, mentors and managers. Everyone else should keep it to themselves. But the problem is that people gossip. And they judge. Covertly. As in "I don't trust this woman. Why does she dress like that? She'd be disruptive. I'd better not hire her."
- daveFNbuck 9y agoHow do you respond when people covertly tell you that?
- zbentley 9y ago> For example, you may see women in tight sleavless tshirts aka wifebeaters, plus short skirts. How many men will be wearing tight wifebeaters with short pants and sandals? Not many, I bet. So . . . burqas for everyone, then? Seriously, if you can't recognize that fashion norms for women and men are different, and can't tell the connotative difference between a sleeveless shirt on a woman and a tank top on a man, I cannot help you.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mirimir 9y agoYes, "fashion norms for women and men are different" in modern American culture. Of course. That's rather my point. But what's up with that? Please say more about "the connotative difference between a sleeveless shirt on a woman and a tank top on a man". I don't see much substantive difference. They're both an assertion of physical power. I actually do think that "burqas for everyone" might be a good fashion trend. For privacy, given that there are cameras everywhere. But in professional American culture, it's actually men who are more constrained to dress modestly.
- rockinghigh 9y agoAre you really blaming her? Attractive women who wear dresses tend to attract predators. We should condemn the predators, not the women.
- mirimir 9y agoNo, I'm not blaming her. But I am wondering about her motivation, and level of self-awareness.
- pron 9y agoI've taken the time to compile the comprehensive list of people who may (but perhaps shouldn't) give you unsolicited constructive criticism on how you dress: 1. Close friends/family. 2. Professional designers/fashion experts. As to his dumb-ass move, I wonder what would be your reaction if he'd done that to you, because that's what she felt. I think it would be a bit different from, "that's a dumb-ass move".
- mirimir 9y agoI totally agree. Also whoever she reported to. Because her presentation reflects on them. If someone had done that to me, I would have gracefully fended them off, verbally and physically.