6 ms·
World's steepest funicular railway opens in Switzerland
- bonniemuffin 9y agoApparently I had no idea how to interpret percent grade numbers, because I would've thought a 110% grade was impossible or meant going directly vertical or something. But actually the internet tells me it represents rise/run as a percent, so a 110% grade is slightly more than a 45 degree angle. The more you know!
- igitur 9y agoSo a 90° angle is... infinity%?
- myrion 9y agoIt would be, yes, basically.
- mikestew 9y agoIt’s related to a ratio. A ~6 degree slope would have you dropping one meter for every ten meters you move forward: 10%. 45 degrees means one meter for every meter forward: 100%. Keep plotting that out and it approaches infinity as you reach 90 degrees (or just ask, “for every meter forward, how many up/down?” if it is 90 degrees.)
- lisper 9y agoThe problem is that "forward" is ambiguous. You can measure it relative to your direction of travel, or perpendicular to the gravitational vector. For small gradients these are more or less the same, but the steeper the slope the more these two measures diverge.
- usrusr 9y agoFortunately, as 110% it's not ambiguous anymore.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gshubert17 9y agoWith slope in degrees and grade in percent, 100*tan(slope) = grade% slope = arctan(grade%/100) so 110% is about 47.7 degrees, and tan(90 degrees) is infinitely large.
- tmsldd 9y agoPrecisely. Math makes it clear to understand and settle down the discussion, thanks ;)
- jacobolus 9y agoIf you have a 90° angle that would be called a “wall” not a “slope”.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pablobaz 9y agoIn my experience percent grade is usually used as a measure when people want to make something sound really steep. E.g. "this ski slope has a gradient of 90%!!!"
- jessriedel 9y agoThat would, in fact, be an extremely steep slope. An 80% grade is steep enough that if you fall you do not stop until you reach the bottom. http://www.foxnews.com/travel/2017/01/30/5-most-dangerous-ski-runs-in-world.html http://www.foxnews.com/travel/2017/01/30/5-most-dangerous-sk...
- jessriedel 9y agoMore: > In general, beginner slopes (green circle) are between 6% and 25%. Intermediate slopes (blue square) are between 25% and 40%. Difficult slopes (black diamond) are 40% and up. ... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piste https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piste
- pablobaz 9y agoThat is very true. But my point still stands. People hear a percentage number and assume the max is 100. Also generally with ski slopes the quoted gradient is some tiny portion of the run. Top to bottom the actual gradient is much less.
- s0rce 9y agoThat is what an ice axe would be for, I presume.
- TylerE 9y agoThe nice thing about it from an engineering perspective is that it doesn't distort at the ends of a scale. A 10% grade over a horizontal distance of X will gain exactly twice as much height as a 5% grade over the same distance.
- hodgesrm 9y agoPercent grade is standard for road steepness at least in the US, e.g., 6% which requires effort for a loaded truck to climb.
- danbruc 9y agoIf you used the difference in height over the actual distance traveled instead of the horizontal distance, then 100 % would indeed be vertical. I.e. instead of using sin(a)/cos(a) you could just use sin(a) and for small angles the values are close but the later one approaches 1 while the former one diverges as you approach 90°. I would probably have picked the later one but the former one is probably somewhat easier to work with in practice, e.g. for construction work.
- Sharlin 9y ago> sin(a)/cos(a) Also called tan(a) ;)
- danbruc 9y agoThe other variant was actually meant to read sin(a)/1 to highlight the ratio in both cases but I abandoned that halfway through because I thought it makes the hypotenuse look special while it really is not in the sin(a)/cos(a) variant where the more natural description would be tan(a)/1 but that kind of ruins the simple association with the side lengths of a right triangle. I had another idea how to formulate it that would not favor one of the variants but as far as I can tell the necessary distinction between the two catheti that exists in German does not exist in English and so I left it as it is.
- Kenji 9y agoIt's simply slope. 1st derivative. Slope 100% = 1 which is equivalent to a 45° angle.
- jsmthrowaway 9y agoThat's right. It's simple to remember once you get the hang of it. 100% grade: every foot forward is one foot of climb, or every meter forward is one meter of rise. 10% grade: ten feet forward, one foot up, or ten meters forward, one meter up. 110% grade: one foot forward, 1.1 feet up, or one meter forward, 1.1 meters up. 6% grades are steep enough to earn warning signs, if you pay attention to signage in the mountains. Sonora Pass, for example, has sections of 26% grade. That sounds immensely steep (and is, for driving), but it sounds more reasonable when you say "every 50 feet forward, you've climbed 13 feet." Solve the triangle, and that's 14.574°. If you've been over the Sonora Pass, you know that it feels like you're in a rocket climbing vertically at a couple points, and you might be surprised to learn that's only 14.6° of grade. 22nd Street in SF is over 31%, IIRC, and is one of the steepest streets I can think of.
- frede 9y agoIf you plotted the altitude with a function f(x), it's just the derivative f'(x) expressed in percent.
- bmc7505 9y agoAt what point does a funicular become an elevator?
- discohead 9y agoAt precisely 90 degrees.
- mikeash 9y agoApparently not! https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incline_elevator https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incline_elevator It seems the distinction is that funiculars operate in balanced pairs, while elevators are independent units.
- mason55 9y agoFunnily enough that page has a funicular listed under the incline elevator examples
- mordechai9000 9y agoI went to Germany this year and I made a point of planning a visit to a funicular. To my great disappointment, the funicular we found in Freiburg am Breisgau used a counterweight instead of another car. Now I wonder if it was really a funicular at all.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- looiid 9y agoDefine precise.
- blattimwind 9y agoNope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Town_Hall_(Hanover)#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Town_Hall_(Hanover)#Histor...
- nmcfarl 9y agoThere are a few videos of the built thing running on YouTube, and http://stoos-muotatal.ch http://stoos-muotatal.ch none of which are perfect but this is my fav: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=C5YoI5F3xEw https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=C5YoI5F3xEw
- EwanG 9y agoOne more for consideration - does a nice job of showing how the cars work: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Se4KrC0nfGE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Se4KrC0nfGE
- DonHopkins 9y agoIs "funicular" the name of some new neural network hill climbing technique?
- sndean 9y agoLooking at an image in a Guardian article about it (https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/dec/15/world-steepest-funicular-rail-line-open-switzerland https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/dec/15/world-steepest...) what is the purpose of those panels further up the mountain on either side of the tracks? Is that to try to catch the train if it falls off the tracks?
- _nalply 9y agoTo catch snow or rocks falling down.
- red_admiral 9y agoTo prevent a large snow sheet building up that could trigger an avalanche.
- pierrebeaucamp 9y agoThose are avalanche protection fences Edit: s/avalanche protection/snow/g > https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snow_fence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snow_fence
- sndean 9y agoThanks, that "Snow fence" name helps. With zero mountains/trains/snow knowledge, it's hard to google for.
- Bluestrike2 9y agoSpecifically, they're called snow sheds[0] as they're angled to capture and hold snow deposits, serving as a physical obstacle to accumulated snow that could then later slide. The big risk there would be a slab avalanche,[1] possibly triggered by the funicular's own vibrations. Because the snow sheds are directly supporting any heavy deposits of snow, they isolate the slab from a weaker snowpack that'd otherwise be underneath it. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snow_shed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snow_shed [1] https://www.meted.ucar.edu/afwa/avalanche/navmenu.php?tab=1&page=2.3.0 https://www.meted.ucar.edu/afwa/avalanche/navmenu.php?tab=1&...
- deleted 9y ago
- _nalply 9y agoI went with my family before they shuttered the old funicular. The old funicular was expensive to maintain and prone to interruption by falling rocks. So they decided to scrap the old funicular and build a new one. However not everything worked out to plan. After all there was a two-year delay. They underestimated the difficulties the steep grades created. For example they had to tether all workers to ropes. Tools falling down turned into dangerous projectiles. Tunnel boring machines had to use a climbing contraption to bore literally upwards. An so on. By the way would have Elon Musk helped by combining his Boring Company and SpaceX to bore upwards?
- chris_st 9y agoI rode the cog railway up Pike's Peak a few years ago. If you EVER get a chance to ride the train documented here, or any other such train, BY ALL MEANS take it. The views are just spectacular. And, on a train, you're not distracted by driving, so you can watch the view the whole time.
- wavefunction 9y agoThere used to be a funicular nearly adjacent to the starting point of the Cog Railway that would have given the Swiss one a run for its money, as the Manitou Incline hit 68° in some points. The Manitou Incline shuttered in the 90s after a rockfall damaged the tracks. It's a popular endurance trail now, with people 'running' up the old incline track to the top of Mount Manitou. I'd like to second your post though. I took the Cog Railway up to the summit of Pikes Peak right before Christmas a few years ago and we were blessed with having to stop as a herd of Rocky Mountain big-horn sheep moved across the path. There is a protected lambing area on the backside of the mountain which of course I've never visited but to see these animals up close at 11,000 feet was spectacular. Plus you can buy fresh donuts and coffee up at the summit. A nice way to visit 14,000 feet if you're not inclined to the wonderful but strenuous Barr Trail.
- quotemstr 9y agoA vertical railway is just an elevator, isn't it?
- PuffinBlue 9y agoI went on this one once, it's actually the worlds oldest I think. Short, but incredibly steep! https://www.salzburg.info/en/travel-info/arrival-traffic/cable_railway https://www.salzburg.info/en/travel-info/arrival-traffic/cab... <del>I can't find any info on an exact percentage but I'm surprised another railway beat it as it really is very steep</del> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1m507EEHp34 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1m507EEHp34 EDIT: 62% according to wikipedia (once I found the right name for this railway). That's less than half the one linked in this post. Impressive!
- svarrall 9y agoThe Scenic Railway in the Blue Mountains, NSW is listed at 52deg so I believe it’s still steeper? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Katoomba_Scenic_World#Railway https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Katoomba_Scenic_World#Railwa...
- thomasahle 9y agoUnless they've used 400deg degrees to make it sound steeper. In that case, the Scenic Railway would be slightly less steep.
- zyztem 9y agoSeems strangely inexpensive to me. Serious engineering, special train, 1.3 km construction on difficult terrain and only 45 mln. Euro? In comparision, new Dublin tram line - COTS cars, 6 km line for 368 mln Euro. Or Detroit Qline, $180 mln. for 5.3 km line.
- willyt 9y agoTrams are expensive because of all the pipes and cables under the street that have to be moved. Also a funicular train is driverless and unpowered, more like big elevator car than a train.
- jandrese 9y agoThere surprising little to a typical funicular train. Just two cars, a long cable, some track, and a big electric motor.
- roryisok 9y agoYou also have to account for dealing with traffic and pedestrian crossings, lights, planning etc. The Dublin tram was a new line across existing streets. This funicular probably doesn't cross any roads. Also things take longer and cost more in Ireland. Case in point, near my house the local council had to dig up a road and lay some pipe to channel a stream underneath. This took two months. In the UK they put a train tunnel under a motorway in 72 hours
- Animats 9y agoIntamin offers comparable systems.[1] Intamin is primarily a roller coaster manufacturer. As a sideline they offer the "Mountain People Mover", which uses roller coaster track and wheel systems. It's electric drive, not cable drive, so it's a people mover, not a funicular. The track can be much more curved, in all axes, than with a cable driven system. Intamin offers the tilting cabin option, but their existing installations don't use it. At some inclination, cable-driven systems are considered elevators. The George Washington Masonic Temple has cable-hauled elevators which are 82.5 degrees from horizontal. This is a 759% slope. They're tilted in two axes, because the building is a narrowing tower with big meeting rooms on several floors, and the elevators don't break up the space. [1] http://www.intamintransportation.com/transportation/MountainPeopleMover/tabid/119/language/de-DE/Default.aspx http://www.intamintransportation.com/transportation/Mountain...
- s0rce 9y agoFor the California/bay area folks there is a tram from Silver Lake to Lake Agnew over in the Eastern Sierra (near june lake) that has a max of about a 105% grade. Sadly, you can't ride it but you can hike up parts and around the station at the top. Even trying to climb up is quite a challenge. Its quite amazing. Built in 1915 to support construction/operation of the Lake Agnew and Gem Lake dams. I suggest going up in the fall when the aspen are changing color.