5 ms·
It's easy for companies to fire people at the lower levels or even top management who are for the most part replaceable. The question will become more difficul
by mc32 9y ago
It's easy for companies to fire people at the lower levels or even top management who are for the most part replaceable.
The question will become more difficult when people who are essential to the success of a company or product become entangled in allegations (and perhaps eventual convictions). But let's forget the high bar of convictions, for a moment.
If we soon begin to embroil anyone and everyone who may have said something inappropriate or who had someone interpret something as inappropriate, we'll end up including people who are _essential_ to a company or companies.
When that time comes, I think companies and society will have to reach a consensus on how to deal with borderline cases (things uncouth but not illegal). Will society ostracize and black ball all cases, or pursue ways to rehabilitate people --like they rehabilitate drunk drivers, etc.
Else, a less discerning competitor could scoop up problematic talent.
- HarryHirsch 9y agoPolicy has a way of shaping character. When people get away with a lot, they think it's OK, because experience shows that it is.
- gozur88 9y agoThere's a limit to the extent to which HR can control basic human urges. This kind of stuff is going to happen no matter what the rules are.
- deeponey 9y agoLook at the diversity, globally, of behaviors supported by an equally diverse set of culturally formed ethos. It's about dropping orders of magnitude off the frequency of these situations.
- gozur88 9y agoThere's a lot of assumptions baked into that cake. The most obvious being what's considered acceptable behavior in a man by his female colleagues. There are a lot of countries where this kind of thing is considered part of the job by women.
- SolaceQuantum 9y agoIt should not be a basic human urge to touch peoples thighs and buttocks without their consent. It has never occurred to me to touch someone sexually without their consent and I’m pretty sure I’m normal in that respect.
- Bertio 9y agoIf your reputation is that important to your career, you will find a way to control your urges. Either that or men don't belong in leadership because they can't control themselves?
- aaron-lebo 9y agoThe question will become more difficult when people who are essential to the success of a company or product become entangled in allegations (and perhaps eventual convictions). But let's forget the high bar of convictions, for a moment. You mean like Weinstein, Spacey, and Singer? When that time comes, I think companies and society will have to reach a consensus on how to deal with borderline cases (things uncouth but not illegal). Will society ostracize and black ball all cases, or pursue ways to rehabilitate people --like they rehabilitate drunk drivers, etc. I haven't seen people get fired for just saying the wrong thing. These cases are mostly way beyond that. Some people have gotten accused (Affleck) but they have been brushed off as either not having evidence or not being serious. This isn't "oops I made a mistake" behavior, it's predatory behavior and predators are hard to rehabilitate.
- alexasmyths 9y ago" it's predatory behavior " Most people call it flirting (I mean the touching of a thigh). Let's not make guys stupid romantic attempts out to be like rape. If in a professional context, it's definitely inappropriate and must be called out.
- Eridrus 9y agoTouching someone's thigh when they're presenting their poster at an academic conference is completely out of line. They have to be there to present their work to people, not get sexually harassed, and that's even ignoring his other behaviour. You probably shouldn't be flirting with people at a poster session anyway.
- alexasmyths 9y agoI was disagreeing with the use of the term 'predatory', I didn't suggest that what he did wasn't wrong. Folks: someone touched someone on the thigh at a conference (inappropriately), and it's making international news? This is ridiculous.
- 9y ago
- pcurve 9y ago"The question will become more difficult when people who are essential to the success of a company or product become entangled in allegations" There's already a big precedent. It's Mark Hurd at HP. He was basically asked to resign for less severe incident than what these guys are facing, even though he did spectacular thing to HP stock price after years of Fiorina mismanagement.
- mc32 9y agoYes, but he's still replaceable. Imagine you have a biotech. The main or _the_ sr scientist there which the whole company's future depends on, gets embroiled in something like this. So they kiss the company good bye, or do they seek to rehabilitate?
- HarryHirsch 9y agoUmberto Eco discusses that very issue in his book "How to Write A Thesis". Question: "My advisor is an arsehole." Answer: "Dude, you knew that before."
- coliveira 9y agoIn its essence, the problem will always exist. What if he/she kills someone? What if he/she has a heart attack? If your problem is depending on a single person for the company to work, then you should count on the fact that you are probably screwed.
- mc32 9y agoTrue but deaths and incarcerations are not something a company can control (perh some places you can bribe against incarceration) but a company can control when and how they fire or not fire someone for misconduct.
- coliveira 9y agoAs current events show, companies can't control that either. It is just a matter of realizing the obvious.
- Eridrus 9y agoDespite people's egos, I think everyone is more replaceable than they think they are, and often a person's effectiveness is so tied to a single organization that they would be nowhere near as effective elsewhere.
- mc32 9y agoI think in most cases I agree. Most people are replaceable. But we have exceptions like Musk, Von Braun, Bezos, Hastings,(among many others).
- Drdrdrq 9y agoLet's not forget Steve Jobs.
- suyash 9y agoforever irreplaceable :)
- kthejoker2 9y agoMeh, all replaceable too. Pure survivorship bias.
- coliveira 9y ago> people who are essential to the success of a company That's a myth. People leave companies all the time and they continue to exist. Executives are not paid high salaries because they contribute anything special other than what any other person would do. It is just that they, as a group, have the power to give themselves high compensation. If I were part of a group of people who decided their own salary levels I would also increase it!
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoIndeed. Amit Singhal was allegedly fired for sexual harassment after 18 years at Google. I don't believe someone starts harassing women after almost two decades. But as the head of Search, and a guy who rewrote Google's search engine from scratch back in the day... he was almost certainly protected a long time. And even when he was fired, he got to "retire". I presume he was too mission critical to get rid of as long as they could keep it quiet.
- srean 9y agoCould you tell/substantiate more on this, because this is the first time I heard anything like that.
- emj 9y agoWell he was fired from Uber because of sexual harrasments that happend while working at Goole. More than that I don't know.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoSource: https://www.recode.net/2017/2/27/14745360/amit-singhal-google-uber https://www.recode.net/2017/2/27/14745360/amit-singhal-googl...