9 ms·
What NN has to do with "freedom of speech, equality and diversity"? The whole article sounds like a bunch of duckspeak, repeating slogans without almost any act
by smsm42 9y ago
What NN has to do with "freedom of speech, equality and diversity"? The whole article sounds like a bunch of duckspeak, repeating slogans without almost any actual informational content.
Wait, no, I'm wrong, there's one: Canadian NAFTA negotiators have indicated that they support inclusion of a net neutrality provision within the agreement’s new digital trade chapter.
What this means? That Canada would require US to create certain regulations as a condition for signing NAFTA? Wouldn't it be kinda presuming - telling US which laws they have? I mean, Canada can have any regulations they want, NN or not, that's their business, but what this has to do with US and NAFTA?
- nekopa 9y agoI think the US is probably the most likely to require negotiating parties to change laws to benefit them, and because the US negotiates from a position of strength most countries have to bow down to it.
- Consultant32452 9y agoThe argument is that your carrier can now block you from getting information relevant to your rights. So you may no longer be able to search for an abortion clinic, or newspapers that have negative articles about the government could be blocked, internet services in poor black neighborhoods may have their access to educational materials limited, etc. While I think that's an unlikely outcome, it would be devastating to free speech, equality, and diversity.
- notdonspaulding 9y ago> The argument is that your carrier can now block you from getting information relevant to your rights That's not an argument. > So you may no longer be able to search for an abortion clinic, or newspapers that have negative articles about the government could be blocked, internet services in poor black neighborhoods may have their access to educational materials limited, etc. None of these hypotheticals are being seriously contemplated as potential outcomes of the FCC relinquishing its Title II authority over ISPs. Let's focus on the likely outcomes, not the unlikely ones.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> None of these hypotheticals are being seriously contemplated as potential outcomes of the FCC relinquishing its Title II authority over ISPs. Yes, an internet version of Verizon’s “controversial and unsavory” text message policy it's blocking of NARAL is definitely a serious concern.
- smsm42 9y agoFacebook, Twitter, Google, etc. are blocking controversial content all the time. Any major content hoster and social network does it. Cloudflare does it. Hosting providers do it. If it were serious concern now, which it hasn't been serious concern in 2016? Or 2014?
- todayiamme 9y agoThat's a flawed argument as the level of abstraction matters. We can route around FB and Google. Direct message each other through Signal, Telegram, or just setup our own email servers. We can't do that if the ISP inspects our packets and refuses to send them no matter how we send them. What are you going to do when Comcast decides that hey let's charge $50 more for VPNs and another $4.99 for messaging apps (pre-approved of course)? What will you do when Signal or Telegram aren't on that list due to "security" concerns? What will you do if an ISP decides that all encrypted traffic is bad and decides to create whitelisted exceptions? Where will you go then?
- smsm42 9y ago> We can't do that if the ISP inspects our packets and refuses to send them no matter how we send them. VPN > What are you going to do when Comcast decides that hey let's charge $50 more for VPNs You can't charge "for VPNs" - VPN traffic is just encrypted traffic. Comcast can charge more for encrypted traffic, but that would be completely insane, ruinous for business and Comcast won't ever do it because that would be insane. And of course, it didn't do it until 2015, because it'd be insane. And if they were insane enough to do this, I'd just use AT&T or Verizon or T-Mobile or whatever there would be around. Of course, I won't actually have to do any of that because Comcast is not going to do this insane thing. > and another $4.99 for messaging apps (pre-approved of course) Comcast doesn't approve apps, in fact Comcast has no idea what am I running and whether there are such thing as "apps" on the OS that I am running. But many mobile providers do provide free traffic for certain messaging apps. I've used it when traveling overseas, very useful to send my wife a message "I've landed, everything's fine" without having to pay for a whole daily internet package that I am not going to use. Of course, from NN point of view it is an outrage that must be banned. I fail to see why. And of course, 2015 regulations didn't prevent that from happening either. > What will you do if an ISP decides that all encrypted traffic is bad Wake up? Why invent scenarios that everybody knows would never happen? ISPs had 30 years until 2015 to do it, and we were fine. But now of course suddenly they all go crazy and start destroying their own business because they want $4.99 from you.
- smsm42 9y ago> The argument is that your carrier can now block you from getting information relevant to your rights. I have never heard of anything like that happening in the US before 2015. Could you give me some examples of this happening? I've heard about Google and Facebook and Twitter blocking sites and content that they consider inacceptable, such as Russian media outlets associated with Russian government. I have also heard about some Nazi sites recently being essentially booted from the Internet by companies no longer wishing to be associated with such sites. All this happened while 2015 regulations were still in place, so apparently NN, at least as far as 2015 regulations go, is no barrier to this. However, I have never heard about ISP blocking access to an abortion clinic (excepting parental control, etc. setups of course, which are usually done in more localized manner). > internet services in poor black neighborhoods may have their access to educational materials limited How? Any why anybody, at a time where one can lose his job just for questioning HR diversity policies, and be booted from air for having the same name as a Confederate general, would be crazy enough to do such an outrageously racist thing, even if this were possible (which it almost certainly won't be)? > While I think that's an unlikely outcome, it would be devastating to free speech, equality, and diversity. If it's unlikely outcome, why Canadian politicians talk about it so much and do not talk about more likely things? Rhetorical questions, of course, I know they are just blowing hot air and duckspeaking.
- todayiamme 9y ago> I have never heard of anything like that happening in the US before 2015. Could you give me some examples of this happening? Okay. Here's a quick timeline of related incidents where the ISP has modified someone's access to information - it includes an ISP blocking information about a labor strike against the company; """ TELUS: In 2005, Canada’s second-largest telecommunications company, Telus, began blocking access to a server that hosted a website supporting a labor strike against the company. Researchers at Harvard and the University of Toronto found that this action resulted in Telus blocking an additional 766 unrelated sites. http://thetyee.ca/News/2005/08/04/TelusCensor/ http://thetyee.ca/News/2005/08/04/TelusCensor/ WINDSTREAM: In 2010, Windstream Communications, a DSL provider with more than 1 million customers at the time, copped to hijacking user-search queries made using the Google toolbar within Firefox. Users who believed they had set the browser to the search engine of their choice were redirected to Windstream’s own search portal and results. http://www.savetheinternet.com/blog/10/04/05/phone-company-helps-make-case-net-neutrality http://www.savetheinternet.com/blog/10/04/05/phone-company-h... PAXFIRE: In 2011, the Electronic Frontier Foundation found that several small ISPs were redirecting search queries via the vendor Paxfire. The ISPs identified in the initial Electronic Frontier Foundation report included Cavalier, Cogent, Frontier, Fuse, DirecPC, RCN and Wide Open West. Paxfire would intercept a person’s search request at Bing and Yahoo and redirect it to another page. By skipping over the search service’s results, the participating ISPs would collect referral fees for delivering users to select websites. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2011/08/update-paxfire-and-search-redirection https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2011/08/update-paxfire-and-sea... - https://www.freepress.net/blog/2017/04/25/net-neutrality-violations-brief-history https://www.freepress.net/blog/2017/04/25/net-neutrality-vio... """ I feel that these incidents establish a strong precedent and behavioral pattern that makes the expectation of a hands-off approach by ISPs irrational.
- mc32 9y agoAren't they walking right into Trump's rhetoric is they want to subvert sovereignty? But then again, I'm sure we could comeback with something, something about Alberta sands being more carbon intensive or ecologically impactful than other sources of petroleum... Something about them wanting the KeystoneXL something something...
- Spooky23 9y agoInternet communications are a critical component of trade. Why should Canadian companies fall victim to arbitrary barriers put up by US ISPs? Treaties are powerful instruments, and require Senate confirmation. If approved, the US would be obliged to meet its treaty obligations.
- SAI_Peregrinus 9y agoFree trade is impeded if the ISPs are putting tariffs (paid prioritization) on Canadian services.
- smsm42 9y agoHow is it impeded? It's like saying "free trade is impeded by Canadian trucks forced to pay for gas in US". No, it's not impeded - expecting to pay for services is not "impediment", nobody owes anybody to serve them for free, even to Canadians.
- freeone3000 9y agoPaying for gas is a required, due to physical constraints. Prioritization of local services over international services is a de facto tariff, and could easily fall under free trade. WTO has handled internet cases before.
- Can_Not 9y agoIt is impeded if they have to pay for the US gas stations for the same gas they already paid for in Canada.
- SAI_Peregrinus 9y agoBecause they already paid for access, to their own ISPs. Their ISPs paid for access to backbone ISPs, which paid (through peering or peering + money) for access to other backbones. End-user ISPs pay the backbones for access, or (in the case of the large ones) may run their own backbone services. Either way the end-user ISP has been paid by their user for access to the backbone ISPs. It's as though the Canadian trucks paid for their gas in Canada, and then get charged an import duty for it upon entering the US.
- stormbrew 9y agoForcing countries to regularize their trade laws with each other is.. kind of the entire point of a trade agreement. What even would a trade agreement that didn't impose laws on its participants be? "Let's be nice to each other and buy each other's stuff if we feel like it?"
- thaumasiotes 9y ago"Let's buy each other's stuff if we feel like it" is a free trade agreement, not common historically. They tend to be very unpopular, so they do need to be formalized. Trade agreements cover all kinds of things. Tariff rates, quantity of whatever that is allowed to be sold, where you're allowed to do it, most favored nation clauses...
- smsm42 9y agoNN is not an international trade law.
- thomastjeffery 9y ago> Wouldn't it be kinda presuming - telling US which laws they have? Unfortunately, this is commonplace, especially with the US on the "telling" end.[0] [0] See international copyright law.
- EdTsft 9y agoAlso FATCA [0], the US is happy to write laws for the banks of other countries. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Account_Tax_Compliance_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Account_Tax_Compliance...
- smsm42 9y ago> especially with the US on the "telling" end. Well, in that case it is certainly presumptuous from US side, and also bad - copyright system is broken enough in the US that spreading it around makes life only worse in other places.
- marcoperaza 9y agoI have a feeling this, along with gender, environmental, and other proposed clauses, is an attempt by Canada to make an opening bid that's unacceptable to the US, in hopes of using these items as bargaining chips in the negotiations. I don't think it's going to work for them, but they're kind of in a desperate situation with the US having a lot less to lose if NAFTA falls apart and therefore almost all of the leverage. So Canada might as well try whatever they can.
- smsm42 9y agoIf anybody knows how to deal with such tactics (for having used it himself countless times) it is Trump. But we'll see how it goes. It's unlikely US would ever say "yeah, we wanted to get rid of those regulations, but since Canadians asked us to have them, we can't now" but of course it never hurts to ask :)
- to_bpr 9y ago>So Canada might as well try whatever they can. This behaviour is largely the Canadian Liberal party appeasing its voter base through virtuous grand-standing over actual effectiveness. I'm very uneasy about the fact that we've Trudeau at the bargaining table here.
- slavik81 9y agoThe US negotiators are making all sorts of ridiculous demands that Canadians will never agree to. I think the Canadian strategy is to counter with their own set of politically infeasible demands, so that they have something to give up when they meet in the middle.
- jmknoll 9y agoI’m not familiar with Canadian law, but we can take an illustrative example from US law. Say you want to stand in the town square with a sign and talk to anyone who will listen about Yemen, or Black Lives Matter, or Universal Basic Income. That is your right, and it’s protected by the First Amendment. Setting up a website where you write about your opinions is likewise protected. Eliminating net neutrality potentially makes it much harder for people’s voices to be heard, much like the city government suddenly converting all roads into toll roads for the duration of your protest. To me, silencing the voices of the people, or allowing them to speak but not to be heard, impinges on freedom of speech and assembly.
- dingo_bat 9y ago> Setting up a website where you write about your opinions is likewise protected. Eliminating net neutrality potentially makes it much harder for people’s voices to be heard All the protections and net neutrality didn't help The Daily Stormer.
- Can_Not 9y agoNet Neutrality helped The Daily Stormer alot. There are no known instances of any ISP, regional monopolies or not, throttling or censoring The Daily Stormer on behalf of the ISP's customers. You might be dishonestly conflating NN into a recent event where The Daily Stormer couldn't find a web host or DNS registrar where inciting violence and terrorism was not prohibited by their terms of service. Whether or not The Daily Stormer has a right to be hosted is a different debate, one that can only had in a world with Net Neutrality.
- freeone3000 9y agoCanadian law allows for governmental content-based restrictions on hate speech. What's hate speech? The government knows it when it sees it. Hosting a nazi rally in Canada won't just have the rally shut down, you'll be criminally prosecuted.
- briandear 9y agoAn ISP is my the government. Under your scenario, Facebook should allow all lawful content. A guy standing in the square is in a public square. That same guy could make a website but that doesn’t mean a private company is obliged to host it — that’s a violation of the owner of the private company’s free speech rights. I am not saying anything about NN, but your example is flawed — everyone has a right to speech, but that right doesn’t imply a right to force others to transmit your message.
- lurr 9y ago> Wouldn't it be kinda presuming - telling US which laws they have Well the US tries to pull that shit all the time. Anyway, > but what this has to do with US and NAFTA ensuring that the market you are agreeing to trade with has reasonably close standards to your own is critical. Otherwise you put yourself at a disadvantage.