3 ms·
I wonder if part of the reason for uncited papers being so low is that authors cite their own papers in subsequent papers. For example, an author is studying fi
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
I wonder if part of the reason for uncited papers being so low is that authors cite their own papers in subsequent papers. For example, an author is studying field X, and publishes papers. No one cites the first paper. The author then writes a new paper on X, but cites the first paper. Thus, although no one but the author cited the papers that the author wrote, all but the last one have citations in other papers.
Another way this works is that authors in the same department may cite each other's papers especially if the fields are somewhat related.
I wonder what the data would look like if they excluded citations by the authors of the original paper.
- yesenadam 9y agoExactemente. It's fairly bizarre that this article didn't mention self-citation, huh.
- lokimedes 9y agoI sure hope that the study corrects for self-citations. It’s a pretty simple procedure with Web of Science. That said, who you cite can be a fairly political decision, it’s like who to follow on Twitter, at least in fields with multiple people working on the same topic.
- azernik 9y agoIt explicitly does mention self-citation.
- yesenadam 9y agoThanks. I looked again. Are you referring to that one graph? I couldn't find any mention in the text.
- greeneggs 9y agoIn the methods section, they do say that "first author self-citations were excluded." One of the figures in the Nature article also pulls out self-citations. https://arxiv.org/abs/0809.5250 https://arxiv.org/abs/0809.5250
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y agoDo note however that many times the first author is not the principal investigator (ie the person that has the funding for the study and is often tenure track faculty) but is often a graduate student or a post-doc. The principal investigator may be in the middle or even at the end of the author list. Thus just excluding first author self-citations is probably inadequate. The chances are high that a grad student or post-doc is going to cite their adviser's previous papers.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- azag0 9y agoThe rule to read the author list, simplified: first author did the work. Last author funded the research. Everyone else contributed somewhat.
- thomasfedb 9y agoOne metric used to evaluate publication history is the combined count of first and last authorships for this very reason.
- njarboe 9y agoIt is also traditional that the first author, in addition to doing the most of the scientific work, takes on most of the writing He/She also edits together the various other authors contributions.
- Keysh 9y agoThat’s only true in some areas (e.g. some biological fields). In other areas (e.g astronomy or much of physics), it’s decreasing order of contribution. In mathematics, the author list is usually alphabetical.
- 9y ago