5 ms·
The numbers are way off. It took around 10 years to get 4" of topsoil on my 80 acres of timber soil (clay). Not 1000 years. And we have 111ft of that kind of s
by JoeAltmaier 9y ago
The numbers are way off. It took around 10 years to get 4" of topsoil on my 80 acres of timber soil (clay). Not 1000 years.
And we have 111ft of that kind of soil here in Iowa. It going to take a hell of a long time to go through that. Its been farmed since the early 1800's. And not all gone, not by far.
I didn't read any further after that, maybe the article does have something to say. But I doubt it.
- Blazespinnaker 9y agoIf the world comes knocking for your soil, you’ll go through it pretty fast.
- nxsynonym 9y agoSorry, but I'm leaning towards trusting the FAO as opposed to anonymous anecdotal evidence. I will give you the benefit of the doubt and believe that you may be on the top end of the world-wide average, but how does your 80 acres of usable soil help the rest of the world when push comes to shove?
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoReally? With the numbers so absolutely at odds, it only takes a single sample to disprove outrageous claims. So don't believe me if you like (though I could go dig a hole and take a picture of the black line that separates topsoil from subsoil), but its probably more outrageous to cling to the idea that somehow Iowa is at the top end of a curve that goes from 10 years to 1000 years.
- yungchin 9y agoThe context for that quote was missing I think (that is, missing from the original article, not your comment), but it makes more sense if they're talking about turning rock into fertile soil. You would have had a whole succession of different types of plants to slowly work the rock surface. Then humans show up, rip out all the trees that kept that hard-won top soil in place, and it all runs off out to sea in no time. Basically it's about places like Iceland, not Iowa, I guess.
- alexanderstears 9y agoNo kidding. When I was younger, my parents moved out into the country and they bought a lot that had been intensively overgrazed and over farmed. Our neighbor farmed hay / alfalfa for the nearby dairy farms and he told us it would be centuries until the land could support a crop. The 'dirt' was dust, rocks, and fossilized manure. Within 3 years of being let alone it recovered enough to support the hardier plants and weeds, that winter we planted barley and rye to add organic matter, compete with the weeds, and put some roots in the soil to stop erosion. After that, it came back with a vengeance. 7 years after our neighbor said it'd be centuries until we could grow anything on it, he bought the rights to plant alfalfa on some of the lot. I have no doubt that people could manage the soil better, but things return to nature pretty quick especially if you can help nature do what it's trying to do.