3 ms·
It doesn't make sense: everybody who have a Facebook login also have a gmail, so why not not just allow people to login with that?
by tomjen3 16y ago
It doesn't make sense: everybody who have a Facebook login also have a gmail, so why not not just allow people to login with that?
- gxti 16y agoStackoverflow does exactly that. They have big buttons for all the major identity providers, including Google, Facebook, etc. and a text field at the bottom for manual openid login.
- sabj 16y agoPersonally I feel a lot better about Twitter + OAuth than FB, but that's just me. As for why not use OpenID? Personally, I don't want to tie my Gmail account to a lot of things -- then people have my email! I don't necessarily want to tie my Facebook to them, either, but in the same breath some forms of OpenID can end up sharing more, depending... This is why I get cranky when people implement Disqus, too -- old comments I made that were supposed to be anonymous but which had my email for the author, etc, are now pulled in and linked to a general identity months or years later. :(
- theBobMcCormick 16y agoWhy would you feel better about Twitter + OAuth than FaceBook + OAuth (which is what the sign on component of FB Connect is)? From a technology perspective, it's the same protocol. Neither company has a good security track record. (not criticizing BTW, just curious)
- desigooner 16y agothe twitter account could be a throwaway account and generally lesser risk of anybody getting too many personal details.. facebook, not so much ..
- benologist 16y agoBecause all the major sites/companies were too busy fighting to be the provider everyone uses and never got around to actually accepting anyone else.
- tomjen3 16y agoBut that isn't really an issue if you want to accept open ids on your site - it is actually a good thing, because the more providers there are the easier it is to find on that has your customers.