5 ms·
We can overcome them without removing them, by extending "us" widely enough. This is how a number of religions handled it, leading to their expansion over large
by nine_k 9y ago
We can overcome them without removing them, by extending "us" widely enough. This is how a number of religions handled it, leading to their expansion over large swaths of diverse nations.
Seeing most everyone on Earth as ingroup improves collaboration and thus propels culture / prosperity.
- laretluval 9y agoBut what if there is a group whose strategy is to take advantage of the trusting nature of everyone else for its own gains? In that case it would be advantageous to unite against them. Universal cooperation and trust is great when there are no attackers but it needs to be hardened against attacks somehow. Also, does universal collaboration necessarily bring the best results? Seems like there might be a number of people over which universal coordination becomes infeasible.
- komali2 9y agoIf you mean a culture war scenario, this was discussed briefly in the article - do you focus on the success of your Us, or on the relative success of your Us as compared to your Them? I prefer the former, because it is a pure "improvement" mindset, whereas the latter allows for "success" via subjugation of other people while your Us stagnants.
- undersuit 9y ago>Ingroup favoritism raises a key question—at our core, do we want Us to do “well” by maximizing absolute levels of well being, or merely “better than,” by maximizing the gap between Us and Them? Universal individualism and distrust is great when there are no attackers but it needs to be hardened against cooperative attacks somehow. Also, does universal individualism necessarily bring the best results? Seems like there might be a number of people over which universal individualism becomes infeasible.
- jotm 9y agoAren't most Indians Hindu yet they still judge and separate each other by the shade of their skin or the family they were born in? There is no extending, there's always going to be some arbitrary point for Us vs Them.
- wu-ikkyu 9y agoIt's worth noting the influence British colonialism played in emphasizing caste in India, a strategy otherwise known as divide et impera.
- bluthru 9y ago>Seeing most everyone on Earth as ingroup improves collaboration and thus propels culture / prosperity. Not when this isn't a shared sentiment. Whites are resented, not praised, for their anti-identity politics and inclusiveness. Now we're called racist for trying to ignore race or judging people based on the content of their character instead of the color of their skin. Also it's a pretty radical proposition to overcome nature regarding in-group preferences, since that has a genetic component.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nine_k 9y agoI see your point. The "you're my ingroup by default" approach works best when reciprocated. It still works tolerably well when not, as long as overt hostility is met with an adequate reaction. Otherwise it still works with those who agree to collaborate, and ends up in a disappointment with those who don't. (Moral panic that can grow or not from such a disappointment is another issue.)