5 ms·
This is where countries with some sort of mandatory service may have us beat. And maybe it explains why American policy was so focused after the big national wa
by legitster 9y ago
This is where countries with some sort of mandatory service may have us beat. And maybe it explains why American policy was so focused after the big national wars. I don't think there's a better way to force camaraderie. But then it becomes Us vs Them on the other side of the border.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y ago>But then it becomes Us vs Them on the other side of the border. Yeah, maybe that's better on the other side than inside though. Like if President Trump started a huge "Beat China" campaign all about making sure America stays the world hegemon, that could bring a lot of neighbors together even if it widens the gulf between me and someone on the other side of the world. It's hard to say.
- jotm 9y ago"Beat China" after being the one who empowered it... that will go well.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- creaghpatr 9y agoI am very in favor of mandatory service as a strategy to improve nations but I do want to point out that some of the most impressive ones (South Korea and Israel come to mind) are extremely homogenous.
- oblio 9y agoIs Israel really homogeneous?
- creaghpatr 9y agoNo and I didn't put a clear context- only Jewish, Druze, and Circassian citizens of Israel have mandatory conscription, Arab citizens are exempt. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conscription_in_Israel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conscription_in_Israel
- vkou 9y agoIsrael is an apartheid state. That is neither homogenous... Or particularly impressive.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- otakucode 9y agoI have never understood this idea. Why would it be beneficial to have your citizenry trained to kill?
- DanAndersen 9y agoThere's several possible benefits: - Enemy nations will be somewhat less motivated to invade if they know they will be facing a population that is entirely armed and ready to resist. - Putting the population into the service of the country helps build a sense of national cohesion by giving a shared sense of mission and duty. - Training the citizens to fight could also be a tool to help prevent dictatorships where the military persecutes the people; a military of citizen-soldiers would be less likely to see their own people as a "them" and more as an "us."
- eric_h 9y agoA counter point: I work with some people in Armenia (which has mandatory conscription) - and from what I've observed that military service made the Us v. Them between Armenians and Azerbaijani stronger than perhaps it would have been without said military service (a drunken encounter between one of said Armenians and an Azerbaijani person outside of Armenia literally came to blows for no real reason I could observe except Us v. Them (well, and alcohol)).
- BeetleB 9y agoNot all mandatory service involves the military. I believe Singapore has/had one where you are part of their civil service (firefighters, etc).
- otakucode 9y agoOh, that is fascinating! I had never heard of anything like that, and that actually sounds like a wonderful idea. Especially for areas where there are underserved regions (rural areas that might not have a high enough population to support a fire department or police or something like that) that could be supported by conscripted people. And unlike with military training, the training would leave participants both with a willingness to help their neighbors and skills to do so. I'm going to have to read up more about nations which do mandatory civil service rather than just military.
- cconroy 9y agoDevil's advocate: but what is wrong with a homogenuous country? edited: punctuation
- creaghpatr 9y agoTheoretically, nothing.
- SamReidHughes 9y agoSingapore comes to mind.
- alexanderstears 9y ago"forced camaraderie" misunderstands camaraderie. The US GOV didn't force people to work together in WWII, it invited them to work together and people rose to the occasion. Nationalism gives people a way to draw the friend/enemy distinction at the border and a way to resolve differences without civil war. To the extent that America draws its friend/enemy distinction inwards, civil war becomes inevitable. It's a real bummer that we think of nationalism as a dirty thing, in its highest form it should be collaborative. One can believe that America is for Americans and illegals need to go back AND believe that those people should improve their own country. The MAGA crowd wouldn't resent Mexico for doing well, or at least there'd be less resentment than the status quo where Mexican nationals come here and misbehave.
- pjc50 9y agoWhen did America integrate its armed forces anyway? It was some time after WW2.
- zarkov99 9y agoYes, this works, as does joining a gym where you do some sort of group activity, say a BJJ or other combat sport.
- legitster 9y agoI disagree - at a gym, the experience is completely voluntary and the group is self-selecting. You may be bonding, but with people already like you. The key with military is being forced to do something you hate alongside complete strangers with little opportunity to socialize outside of the group, under threat of court martial for leaving. And the group of strangers may change at any time. You really have to learn to get along, or work people you don't respect or hate.
- zarkov99 9y agoEverybody is like you in some way or other but in a BJJ gym, for example, you will be forced to engage with people of different genders, ages, political affiliations, religious beliefs, intensity, IQ, toughness, education. I do not discount the diversity of the military - if service is mandatory - but in civilian life a BJJ gym might be the most practical analogue.
- zardo 9y agoIt could be mandatory service in something more like the Peace Corp than the Marine Corp.
- dang 9y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15934367 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15934367 and marked it off-topic. The root comment was connected to the topic, of course, but its off topic component has a stronger magnetic pull... that's the way these things grow.
- BeetleB 9y ago>This is where countries with some sort of mandatory service may have us beat. I doubt it. Turkey has it yet there are plenty of problems between religious people and secular people, as well as between Kurds and other Turks. The book Influence by Cialdini dives deep into some of the elements needed. Some takeaways that I remember: Forcing people to be together in unpleasant circumstances, without a common goal they can work towards, does not reduce the us vs them mindset. His example was school, but anything "mandatory" would qualify. If people are forced to be together, and they work together voluntarily to solve a problem (e.g. by one side needing the other side's skills), then you have reduced polarization.