4 ms·
>“There are two kinds of people in the world: those who divide the world into two kinds of people and those who don’t.” "Only a sith deals in absolutes" I lov
by komali2 9y ago
>“There are two kinds of people in the world: those who divide the world into two kinds of people and those who don’t.”
"Only a sith deals in absolutes"
I love phrases like these. Not sure what to call them but they're fun. Recursive contradictions?
- nine_k 9y agoEvery blanket statement is wrong! Self-referential jokes like this are always funny. :)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mitchty 9y agoIts just a False Dilemma. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_dilemma https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_dilemma More an artifact of our language and people wanting to condense/compress ideas down too far.
- Kinrany 9y agokomali2's point is that the phrase is self-referential: someone saying "only a sith deals in absolutes" implies that they're also a sith, even though presumably being a sith is a bad thing here.
- mitchty 9y agoIt isn't self referential though. Lets diagram a little, as only a surface level of contemplation could arrive at that viewpoint. Possible sets of people: - sith - non sith Known attributes sith have: - deals in absolutes Presumption of the phrase being used is that the phrase itself is an absolute, thus meaning the person speaking has to be a sith even if they claim not to be a sith. But that is flawed, as there are more than just those sets of individuals as we well know. There are non sith that also deal in absolutes, so thus the statement can't be taken at face value. Thus cannot be self referential. But as with all of this, it also misses the mark by ignoring that describing a state doesn't necessarily mean your state has changed. Its also nonsensical in that if the only definition needed to be in the sith set is to deal in absolutes, the category is likely overbroad and meaningless. Think about it, if we take the statement at face value, everyone is a sith, as everyone at some point will deal in absolutes. Even yoda uses do or do not, there is no try. So we arrive at the fundamental flaw in attributing a description of a thing or group, to the thing being described.
- komali2 9y ago>There are non sith that also deal in absolutes That can't be true if "ONLY a sith deals in absolutes" is true. I think there are only two possible outcomes 1. Obi is wrong - not only Sith deal in absolutes. From a story perspective, this demonstrates the Arrogance of the Jedi. 2. Obi is a Sith.
- jpfed 9y agoThe first isn't a self-contradiction; it just places the speaker in the first camp.
- komali2 9y agoOh, good point. The sith one must be a contradiction, then, because it was said by a Jedi, so clearly both sith and Jedi can deal in absolutes.
- bduerst 9y agoOnly if you believe Obiwan when he says it. The line is more or less pointing out the arrogance of the Jedi with Obiwan's hypocrisy. It comes up a few other places too, but like the rest of the prequels, messages aren't delivered very well.
- lodi 9y agoAlso could be that Obi-wan is secretly a Sith himself.
- Kinrany 9y agoThese two phrases are actually almost equivalent. Both say "I divide people into two groups: bad people who divide people into bad and good people, and good people who don't." Is there a more general formulation?