2 ms·
To me, the text feels more like a set of notes that are meant to be read by the author. Even the "introduction" must be completely incomprehensible to a reader
by Koshkin 9y ago
To me, the text feels more like a set of notes that are meant to be read by the author. Even the "introduction" must be completely incomprehensible to a reader who is uninitiated in whatever topic the author is trying to present.
Geometric Algebra is a beautiful subject (best explained in Hestenes' Oersted lecture). On the other hand, in practice, as the proposed "geometry of physics" it has been long replaced by the machinery of differential forms, with a vast amount of literature devoted to it; a short introduction to this you can find, for example, in an article by Ted Frankel: http://www.math.ucsd.edu/~tfrankel/the_geometry_of_physics.pdf http://www.math.ucsd.edu/~tfrankel/the_geometry_of_physics.p....
(The Geometric Algebra being discussed here is not to be confused with the subject of the marvelous book by Artin that bears the same title.)
- vanderZwan 9y agoThe author is pretty much in agreement with you. From the preface: > These notes are more journal than book. You’ll find lots of duplication, since I reworked some topics from scratch a number of times. In many places I was attempting to learn both the basic physics concepts as well as playing with how to express many of those concepts using GA formalisms. The page count proves that I did a very poor job of weeding out all the duplication. These notes are (dis)organized into the following chapters