8 ms·
This is being added to the browser, outside the realm of security updates, through what is supposed to be a UX improvement program, for commercial purposes. It'
by vorpalhex 9y ago
This is being added to the browser, outside the realm of security updates, through what is supposed to be a UX improvement program, for commercial purposes. It's written by a commercial company that produces advertisement content. It's not clear this code is audited.
Sorry, but I'm uninstalling firefox. They have broken the basic trust I have in them as a user to not push arbitrary code to my machine against my interests.
- benbenolson 9y agoWhat browser are you going to use instead?
- rnhmjoj 9y agoIf you like Firefox but don't trust Mozilla anymore there are plenty of forks to choose from: Waterfox, Pale Moon, Basilisk, GNU IceCat. Personally I build Firefox from source and maintain a set of patches largely based on these: https://aur.archlinux.org/packages/firefox-esr-privacy/ https://aur.archlinux.org/packages/firefox-esr-privacy/
- Grollicus 9y agoI think about doing this as well but heard a lot of bad things about the firefox build process. How long does it take to build for you?
- rnhmjoj 9y agoThey are probably true. Using an i5 @4.3GHz it takes 2.5/3 hours to build. To test changes you must set up a compiler cache or it's going to take forever.
- notanote 9y agoThat seems a little slow. I compile nightly for my own use and it takes around 20 minutes on a haswell i5, using tmpfs for the build directory.
- rnhmjoj 9y ago20 minutes sound like a dream, I don't know why it's so slow for me. Maybe because I'm using Nix to build it and the source is on an SSD. I can't use tmpfs because it doesn't fit in memory without adding swap.
- hjek 9y agoLinks2. http://links.twibright.com http://links.twibright.com No, it doesn't show PDFs or videos, but does that belong in the browser anyway?
- thanatropism 9y agoI wonder if Links2 or lynx can be ported as Chrome add-ons.
- hjek 9y agoYup, https://chrome.google.com/extensions/detail/bjekedpipaedojkbialnhabcecmfpofh https://chrome.google.com/extensions/detail/bjekedpipaedojkb...
- pweissbrod 9y agoFirefox 57's sweeping changes ruined most of my vim-like ui customizations (vimperator, vimfx). For 2 months I've switched to qutebrowser and palemoon as a backup and dont miss firefox at all. If you're looking for a browser with first-class vim compatibility qutebrowser is outstanding. I've also found palemoon to be a perfectly boring/stable/functional variant of firefox without all the drastic/breaking changes (vim plugins work quite well also)
- bigbugbag 9y agoIf you were a vimperator aficionado you might want to have a look at uzbl. Pale moon is not as good as waterfox, at least for me.
- Ajedi32 9y ago> It's written by a commercial company that produces advertisement content. It's not clear this code is audited. Do you have any evidence of this? Assuming their normal processes for SHIELD studies were followed, a _lot_ of different people have to review the plugin before it gets approved: https://wiki.mozilla.org/Firefox/Shield/Shield_Studies#Who_Approves_a_Shield_Study_before_it_ships.3F https://wiki.mozilla.org/Firefox/Shield/Shield_Studies#Who_A... Edit: Also, the contributors list on the plugin's GitHub repo lists exclusively Mozilla employees: https://github.com/gregglind/addon-wr/graphs/contributors https://github.com/gregglind/addon-wr/graphs/contributors
- gorbachev 9y agoUnfortunately the most important person involved didn't get to review the plugin before it was installed on my computer. Me.
- ubernostrum 9y agoOK, I have to rant a bit on this. I worked at Mozilla for about four years (2011-2015), on MDN. It's built as a wiki, with wiki features open to everyone. The code is all open source and on GitHub. Its issues and tasks and roadmap are tracked in a public bug tracker. We operated in a public IRC channel. We didn't have to do that. We could have just built something targeted to only be used by the technical writing staff at Mozilla, and never bothered to open it up or make the code available or make it transparent about who wrote articles and when. In fact, it's much more work to do all the things we did (and not just in terms of implementing features, but also in terms of dealing with spammers and trolls and other malicious people who wouldn't have had access in a less open system), but we did it anyway because Mozilla is a radically open and transparent organization. But... in four years, not many people from outside Mozilla ever joined in and got involved with actually contributing (either code or articles or edits to articles or housekeeping or suggesting/arguing for ideas of how to improve MDN). And I've been doing open source for much longer than that, and I see exactly the same pattern: a handful of folks do all that work, and go to the trouble of being open and transparent and providing ways for people to see what's going on and get involved... but people don't. And then those same people willingly install the software and use it every single day, and complain that they were never consulted, or never got a chance to review, or never got to provide input. You had chances to look at the source code, to see what was being checked in, to read the referenced Bugzilla bugs on commits, to leave comments on them, to submit alternative ideas. You didn't. You did install Firefox, though (assuming your claim is correct that this was installed on your computer). By installing the software while not participating in the process, you absolutely gave your "review" of it, and your "review" was "just make a browser for me for free and don't bug me about how". Now, if you want to be involved, go start watching Bugzilla and the Mozilla project wiki pages, and CC yourself on stuff and join mailing lists. Because it's Mozilla. You can do that. If you don't want to do that, or you don't think it's worth your time to do that, then don't do it. But don't then come charging onto HN to complain that nobody consulted you. People practically got on their hands and knees and begged you to join in the process of making Firefox and other open source software, and you decided not to.
- zie 9y agoHave fun in Lynx. that's probably the only browser that wouldn't do something like this. Well maybe Safari, not because Apple wouldn't, but because they just don't care enough about ad revenue. Chrome: They leech everything they can get away with, granted it goes only to Google, but you know it's just to feed their never-ending ad-revenue goal. MS: They bypassed IE only ads, and went on to build ads into the entire OS.
- kuschku 9y agoYou can also use good old Konqueror, they also won’t do this.
- cjsuk 9y agoGopher. That was content focused and so inflexible that it was hard to be a dick with it.
- smacktoward 9y agoThe original WWW was too. (It didn't have cookies, for instance, so there was no way to track a user from one page to another.) When it got popular, smart people started bending it to make being a dick possible, which is how we got the Web of today. I don't doubt the same would have happened to Gopher, if it had been the one to get popular.
- geofft 9y agoI'm running Firefox via Debian, and I intend to continue running Firefox via Debian - I trust that the outcry in the Debian community would be so huge if the Firefox maintainer (or any other maintainer) allowed this sort of code from upstream through.
- zie 9y agoWell FF did just get caught with their pants down, installing a Mr.Robot (tv show tie-in) Add-on(extension) to FF users, without their consent. Since it was an Add-On that was pushed after a debian install, Debian devs wouldn't have been able catch it before it reached end-users. That said, I still use FF, but I do make sure I keep all the opt-in telemetry and stuff off, since it was one of these settings that "let them" get away with installing the add-on without consent. Granted the add-on by default didn't do anything unless you enabled it, but still.....