6 ms·
Why are systems like this connected to the internet? Because there are some things that need to be safe; some things that need to be connected to other things;
by michaelt 9y ago
Why are systems like this connected to the internet?
Because there are some things that need to be safe; some things that need to be connected to other things; and some things that need to be on the internet.
Consider an automated warehouse: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dAXdeqcHBp4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dAXdeqcHBp4
Internet <-> Website <-> Stock control system <-> Stock inbound station <-> Conveyor control system <-> Emergency stop monitoring system
It's possible to make such a system safe, of course. But a company making a web browser has their defences tested and their security spending validated by unceasing attack. The same resources might be hard to get in an industrial automation company if the higher-ups think "there hasn't been an attack, and they already have a firewall, a VPN and a virus scanner, whatever those are"
- mcgarnagle 9y agoYou don't make an online purchase when you open your tap to get a drink of water or flip on a switch for the lights. Some systems need to be on the internet. cool story, but, why would critical infrastructure such as this need to be is still unaddressed by your comment.
- pjc50 9y agoWith a smart meter, effectively you do.
- mcgarnagle 9y agono, you don't. When I activate a light switch and consume more power from the grid I am not directly adding more coal/fuel to the fire/generator. This is where the warehousing analogy breaks. Those numbers are looked at on aggregate to determine how much electricity needs to be produced to supply the population. They are directly tied into finance departments to generate your bill, sure, but that is an independent system from the production of electricity. In the case of water supply, same thing. Just because I turn on my tap doesn't mean I am directly affecting the water treatment plant to treat exactly 1 more cup of water today.
- sologoub 9y agoMetering is not a critical/safety component of the grid. It's an important business component, but it does not by itself guarantee safety or preclude safety measures from kicking in. There are other systems that are used to monitor load/draw on the grid and ensure safe operation. Things like smart meters can be connected to the public net and if compromised just cause a headache. Your critical safety system should not be connected to public networks or at least should have strong protections.
- ams6110 9y agoThe emergency stop system should not be connected to the normal conveyor control system. It should be an independent system, since in an emergency the normal controls are presumably malfunctioning.