4 ms·
Sobotics: The Bots of Stack Overflow Moderation
- azinman2 9y agoThe webpage is quite unclear as to exactly what this is.
- artofcode- 9y agoYeah, it's not a great website. TL;DR: SOBotics creates bots to help in moderating Stack Overflow.
- azinman2 9y agoBut it also made it sound like there was a chat room associated with them?
- artofcode- 9y agoSure is, https://chat.stackoverflow.com/rooms/111347/sobotics https://chat.stackoverflow.com/rooms/111347/sobotics
- hawktheslayer 9y agoWhile I too had a hard time reading through the website, I was amused by the author's style (e.g. "the moderators visit the room frequently and can bust your bubble") and also enjoy the names of the bots such as Guttenberg, as a nod to the famous plagiarism scandal in Germany. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guttenberg_plagiarism_scandal https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guttenberg_plagiarism_scanda...
- bhargavrao 9y agoSpeaking of names, the vandalism detector is named "Belisarius" https://stackapps.com/questions/7473/belisarius-detecting-vandalism-on-stack-overflow https://stackapps.com/questions/7473/belisarius-detecting-va.... (The other names have some back story behind them, mostly internal to the sobotics team)
- bhargavrao 9y agoTrue. We are lacking a dev who knows how to do some good UI design stuff. We do plan to add more details to the site soon, and have stuff on different pages instead of one dump. We hope that some day we will find some dev who knows some web site stuff!
- artofcode- 9y agocough
- fredley 9y agoAlthough is not anything like at the scale of YouTube/Twitter, the model they have for moderation (volunteers, supported directly by staff, BYO bots, as well as company-owned bots for grunt work like spam removal) works amazingly well. Much much better than any other site with the same volume of new content. It does make me wonder why companies like Google, Facebook and Twitter, which have much much greater resource to throw at the problem, still struggle with content moderation. Just hire good people, give them the right tools, and engage the community. Disclosure: I am a volunteer moderator on a Stack Exchange site.
- RandomTrees 9y agoThe number of FB comments must be multiple orders of magnitude larger than SO comments; the average user's education and comment quality much lower, so easier said than done.
- Friberg 9y agomeeh number of comments to process do not really make any difference for bots.
- chrisaycock 9y agoI too was a moderator years ago for a Stack Exchange site. I was always amazed by the sheer amount of tooling that I had access to. I could instantly tell when there were sock-puppet accounts, voting rings, auto-flagged low-value postings, etc. One thing that Stack Exchange does very differently from other sites is that they emphasize professionalism. Since Facebook and YouTube allow memes and off-topic material, there is an expectation that low-value postings will be tolerated by the community. And that's exactly what those places get. SE sites prohibit garbage. On the Quant Finance site, for example, we required people who post there to actually work in the industry. That metric made it very easy to distinguish ourselves from other QF forums; we didn't have "How do I become a quant?" or "What programming language should I use?" for every other question. Another community that has some bar of professionalism is Hacker News. There's no requirement that people be entrepreneurs or programmers here, but there is an expectation that anything posted must valuable and high quality.
- denzil_correa 9y agoShamless Plug - I have published a couple of research papers which focuses on prediction of "Closed" (https://arxiv.org/pdf/1307.7291.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1307.7291.pdf) and "Deleted" (https://arxiv.org/pdf/1401.0480.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1401.0480.pdf) questions on Stack Overflow. It might help some of the bots.
- Friberg 9y agoVery nice, we have bots that search for close voting, but to be honest the amount of questions that needs to be closed are to huge for us we can't handle'em, so we have concentrate more on Non Answer, Plagiarism, Rude comments, Bad edits etc where it is easier for us to make a difference
- Friberg 9y agoSOBotics is people (volunteers) having fun developing bots (reporting in chat) that helps to moderate StackOverflow. If you like to join there is lots of stuff to dev see http://www.sobotics.org/contribute/ http://www.sobotics.org/contribute/, just get 20 reputation points and join us in chat https://chat.stackoverflow.com/rooms/111347/sobotics https://chat.stackoverflow.com/rooms/111347/sobotics