5 ms·
>The company also wants professional creators to post more videos to the site and make the platform a content hub on par with YouTube, a unit of Alphabet Inc.’s
by nkrisc 9y ago
>The company also wants professional creators to post more videos to the site and make the platform a content hub on par with YouTube, a unit of Alphabet Inc.’s Google.
That's interesting, because I've never been able to find a second time a video that popped up in my feed. For my experience, videos on Facebook might as well be ephemeral. forever vanishing the moment my feed refreshes itself automatically.
- froindt 9y agoI experience the same thing and it's really frustrating. I refuse to install Facebook applications on my phone, and they've needlessly crippled their mobile site (disabling messages except mbasic.facebook.com among many other things). If I so much as check a notification then go back to the newsfeed, it's different content and hit/miss as to whether I can find the top post again.
- Spooks 9y agoafter them crippling their mobile site I deleted facebook, it was not needed... though I just replaced it with whatsapp or hangouts (really hard to get my friends on anything else)
- froindt 9y agoTheir site would literally work just fine as mobile site. It wouldn't give them as much data. Years ago I had the app installed. The fact that they wanted not one, but two hugely bloated apps on my phone is the reason they haven't been on my phone in many years.
- code_duck 9y agoI had to wonder for a second whether I was looking at a post of mine! A year or two ago they made the change to disallow access to messages from m.facebook.com, so I started using mbasic.facebook.com for messages. Recently they blocked the mbasic.facebook.com entirely for iPhones. It's clear that there reason is to force mobile users to install messenger, because messages are still available on m.facebook.com and mbasic if you visit in a desktop browser. I already have a FB app on my phone, Instagram, which is more useful for messaging in my circle and less annoying. I refuse to be forced to install their app, so the only response to this is to stop using messenger. Already my messages are going unchecked and will stay that way until I get to a desktop. The vagaries of finding content you saw minutes before, and the almost entirely random way posts and everything is organized, is frustrating too.
- nkrisc 9y ago>The vagaries of finding content you saw minutes before, and the almost entirely random way posts and everything is organized, is frustrating too. I've found it nearly impossible to search for anything on Facebook that isn't a person, and even that is difficult.
- cortesoft 9y agoI just went to mbasic.facebook.com from my iPhone and it worked? I didn't login because I don't use facebook, does it block you after you login?
- code_duck 9y agoOh, interesting. Thanks for letting me know. I haven't tried in a week or two, and it's back! I was definitely getting redirected to m.facebook.com for a week or two, but apparently see they have restored access, for whatever reason. Edit: does anyone know of somewhere I can be informed of changes about this by Facebook? Searching for previous discussions about this on a Hacker News, I see other people say that the mbasic Does or doesn’t work for them at various times.
- qmalzp 9y agoUse messenger.com?
- gaius 9y agombasic works on my iPhone. Just deleted the app!
- Vinnl 9y agoPeople have been saying that Facebook has removed messaging from their mobile site for quite a while now, and all that time I've been fearing the moment that would happen for me. But it hasn't yet - I wonder why? The main difference I can think of is never having had the app installed, and using Firefox for Android with an ad blocker. You might give that a try and see if it comes back for you.
- niftich 9y agoThis. Facebook is going to have to make efforts to present a better UI/UX if it wants to be a content portal for videos. Their entire UX is based around the algorithmic feed, which obfuscates the true quantity of actual content on the user's timeline, thereby allowing a higher density of ads and other sponsored content without the user necessarily being able to tell or prove [1]. But the sliding window of the feed still moves forward in time, so content that you don't interact with enough to be recorded in the activity log just falls off, never to be seen again. In 2014, Facebook Paper was an effort to reimagine how Facebook surfaces content [2][3], but despite rave reviews it fizzled and was killed in 2016. It was part of a wider effort to pivot into being a publisher of original content and not merely a social aggregator, and although Paper was discontinued prematurely, the effort faced several hindrances, including news publishers' pushback against Facebook's content framing [4] and Facebook's role in the dissemination of fictitious clickbait. Facebook is so multifaceted that its current way of presenting content is woefully inadequate, and doesn't fit their ambitions. [1] Reusing an old line: https://hn.algolia.com/?query=niftich+true+quantity+of+actual+content&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?query=niftich+true+quantity+of+actua... [2] https://www.theverge.com/2014/1/30/5360358/facebook-paper-iphone-app https://www.theverge.com/2014/1/30/5360358/facebook-paper-ip... [3] https://www.wired.com/2014/02/inside-look-at-the-creation-of-facebook-paper/ https://www.wired.com/2014/02/inside-look-at-the-creation-of... [4] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14126073 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14126073
- bcherny 9y agoThose are some interesting points. What would you replace all of that stuff with?
- Veratyr 9y agoIt's also rich, considering video creators have been pissed at Facebook for doing nothing about people stealing their videos: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t7tA3NNKF0Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t7tA3NNKF0Q
- yesimahuman 9y agoNot to mention it's an incredible challenge to share a Facebook video outside of Facebook.
- nkrisc 9y agoIt's a challenge to share anything inside of Facebook! Look at any popular video and all the comments are nothing but people tagging a friend, no actual discussion. It's impossible (or I haven't figured out how) to share something I come across with an individual friend. My wife and I just text each other screenshots of our Facebook feed when we want to share an image or post with each other.
- dingo_bat 9y agoI even saw an ad that I wanted to click on but it just vanished. Never to be seen again.
- a012 9y agoMy feed is always on some dozen of posts constantly show up. Maybe my friends are not posting many, or maybe FB decided that's how many I could view.
- hrktb 9y agoThat should not be far off with the current viral video market though. I follow CGPGrey who does 3~7 min videos, and the main use case is a user looking at it when it pops up, and let it fade into the void after that. Do that for 3M people in roughly 24h, and it’s done. The rest of the life of the video will have minimal financial returns from that point, and the creator can focus on the next viral topic.
- nkrisc 9y agoThat makes sense, considering YouTube videos probably follow a similar pattern even though it's pretty easy to search for them at any time. Though maybe it's just me but I don't go to Facebook looking for video content because I can't actively seek anything I'm interested in or find that cool video my friend told me about. If someone says they saw a cool video in Facebook I go look for it on YouTube first.
- fwn 9y ago> I've never been able to find a second time a video You can see all the videos you watched as a list in your activity log. This link works after inserting your username: https://www.facebook.com/username/allactivity?privacy_source=activity_log&log_filter=videowatch https://www.facebook.com/username/allactivity?privacy_source... It's not working for videos you did not watch long enough.