5 ms·
Well, another way of putting it is "Liberals are tolerant of anything except intolerance" If I want to be a tolerant and accepting person, do I have to accept
by cortesoft 9y ago
Well, another way of putting it is "Liberals are tolerant of anything except intolerance"
If I want to be a tolerant and accepting person, do I have to accept someone who wants to deny a group of people to marry the person they love? Do I have to tolerate someone who wants to control a woman's body?
This is similar to a love of freedom; I want everyone to have freedom, but that means having to restrict the freedom to infringe on other people's freedom. That might seem to be a contradiction, but it is a paradox you have to address.
- kazinator 9y ago> I have to accept someone who wants to deny a group of people to marry the person they love? No, just their freedom to express that they don't like it. Not grant them actual power to interfere in people's lives by implementing the denial. > Do I have to tolerate someone who wants to control a woman's body? We have to tolerate someone who expresses (in a non-harassing way) that it would be a good idea for them to do that; we shouldn't tolerate someone trying to instigate such control. And I mean as a matter of public policy. Whatever you choose not to tolerate personally is up to you as long as your preferences aren't used as the basis for perpetrating discrimination.
- cortesoft 9y agoI think everyone (including me) agrees that you shouldn't arrest or legally stop people from expressing their opinions, no matter how morally reprehensible those opinions are. However, that isn't what the blog post is talking about. It is saying people SHOULD tolerate it personally, and we shouldn't call people 'heretics' for their ideas no matter what those ideas are. I think it is ok for people to say "If you say gay people shouldn't get married, I am going to immediately respond that you are wrong and that it is immoral to hold that belief. If you say and hold that belief, I do not want to be friends with you and I don't want to support your business." Boycotting people and businesses that hold views that go against your moral beliefs isn't wrong, and should not be condemned as blocking progress. Now, I do think we all have the responsibility to make sure we limit the things that we respond to in this way. For example, we shouldn't have the 'shun the person' response if you disagree with what the tax rate should be, or if you think that raising the minimum wage will cause rampant inflation. Those aren't moral beliefs, they are implementation details. Now, it would be different if your belief was "I don't want to raise the minimum wage because poor people don't deserve help", we might run into more issues. It becomes a bit tricky because a lot of horrible, immoral, views are hidden behind false justifications. Sometimes we make mistakes, and people with legitimate beliefs might be caught up in the crossfire, but this doesn't mean we shouldn't take reasons into account when determining the response to an opinion.
- kazinator 9y ago> I think everyone (including me) agrees that you shouldn't arrest or legally stop people from expressing their opinions That simply isn't the case; definitely not "everyone". > and we shouldn't call people 'heretics' for their ideas no matter what those ideas are Indeed, those people are wrong; if you want to publicly call someone a heretic, or whatever, (in a non-harassing way), that's just your freedom of expression. You don't have to like the fact that someone thinks controlling women's bodies is a good idea, and may call them a backwards idiot or whatever. > Boycotting people and businesses that hold views that go against your moral beliefs isn't wrong, and should not be condemned as blocking progress. Right as far as a personal boycott goes; but now suppose you don't want to let such a person into your restaurant, or give them a job in spite of qualifications. Also note that if you belong to some religion A, then people from a certain other religion B almost by the respective definitions of A and B hold views that go against your moral beliefs.
- cortesoft 9y agoObviously 'everyone' is an exaggeration; a vast majority, then. You should not be able to keep a person out of your restaurant because of their views, but the job one is tricky and nuanced. I think there are certain beliefs that a person could hold that are valid disqualifications for hiring that person; for example, if a person is advocating that women shouldn't be allowed to work and should stay at home because they have nothing of value to offer, how can I possibly hire that person? How is a woman supposed to work side by side with someone who has expressed the view that they have no value in the workplace? I think if your opinion is that some of your coworkers have no value in the workplace, that has to disqualify you to work there. Now, of course, the spectrum of troubling views will eventually reach a point where the answer is not so obvious as to whether they should be hired or not. I don't think I have a strong answer to where that line should be.
- btilly 9y agoDo you support the Civil Rights Act? A person who holds the views that you describe because he is an Orthodox Jew cannot be fired for said views. No, I'm not making that up. Perhaps you should think carefully about what "freedom of religion" means to you!
- Houshalter 9y agoThat's how they justify it, but empirically it doesn't seem to be the case. E.g. liberals are pretty tolerant of minority groups with more extreme opinions than average conservatives. E.g. muslims are pretty strongly against homosexuals among other things. But they don't receive anywhere near the same level of hate and vitriol even moderate conservatives will get. I think it's just based on how much of a threat a group is. If conservatives were a tiny minority of the population like Muslims are, no one would care enough to hate them. >wants to deny a group of people to marry the person they love? Do I have to tolerate someone who wants to control a woman's body? This is super uncharitable btw. Imagine a conservative saying "why do I have to tolerate someone who literally wants to murder children?"
- ThrowAwayFSp 9y agoWhere do you draw the "control a woman's body" line. Let's say a woman choose to abort on partial birth a healthy baby because she do not want it. Is a healthy 9 months gestation newborn part of the woman's body? You're spinning the argument and calling the other side "intolerant". You're part of the problem Altman is mentioning. Sad thing is that probably you are not aware of that.
- dang 9y agoThis is off topic and we definitely don't need what will happen if we go there.
- cortesoft 9y agoObviously, as you get closer to the edges of situations, you are going to run into differences of opinions. There is nuance, and I don't think you should dismiss people who disagree about the details of that nuance. However, no one is arguing for a woman to be able to abort a fully healthy baby at 9 months. That isn't an operation that happens, so it is a complete straw man to try to argue it.
- smacktoward 9y ago> liberals are pretty tolerant of minority groups with more extreme opinions than average conservatives. E.g. muslims are pretty strongly against homosexuals among other things. But they don't receive anywhere near the same level of hate and vitriol even moderate conservatives will get. This is because American Muslims are nowhere near powerful enough to write their prejudices into law, whereas conservatives control all three branches of the Federal government and 31 state legislatures (see https://ballotpedia.org/Partisan_composition_of_state_houses https://ballotpedia.org/Partisan_composition_of_state_houses). You will always find that people consider your opinions worthy of much closer scrutiny when you reach a position from which you can impose them on everybody else.
- agarden 9y agoIf you want to be an accepting person, you have to first decide who it is you are wanting to accept. If you are simply wanting to be as accepting and tolerant as you can possibly be, then it would seem that you would want to accept as many people as possible. That would suggest that you would rather accept the >30% of the country that considers homosexuality unacceptable than the <15% that actually is homosexual. In other words, you would prefer the status quo, which is to say, you would choose to be conservative. Almost everyone is happy to tolerate everyone who doesn't try to interfere with them, their preferences, and their beliefs. Racists are generally happy to tolerate black people as long as they sit in the back of the bus, use their own drinking fountains, and remember to say 'sir'. Even racists tolerate those who tolerate them.
- btilly 9y agoThat is not another way of putting it. That is a very different statement that comes from you defining conservatives as being against what you are for. But that is generally not the case. They are for something different than you are, and sometimes it comes into opposition with what you want. This is in principle no different a substitution than pro-life people defining pro-choice ones as pro-murder. Obviously you see why that one is unfair. Can you see why the other is as well?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]