3 ms·
That's because most people who take more than a cursory glance sees that there are multiple different ideologies lumped under the same name there, diverse enoug
by vidarh 9y ago
That's because most people who take more than a cursory glance sees that there are multiple different ideologies lumped under the same name there, diverse enough that the supporters of some have historically been the most brutal persecutors of supporters of others - Among the millions dead you list are huge numbers of communists that fought against the regimes you complain about, in many cases in open armed conflicts.
Raise more specific ideologies, like Stalinism or Maoism or even Leninism and you will certainly meet a lot more opposition, and rightly so, because many on the left are closest ideologically to victims of the followers of those ideologies. E.g. one thing most people forget about the October "revolution" was that it wasn't a revolution at all, but a coup against the socialist provisional government - it was the Bolsheviks overthrowing the revolutionary socialist/communists and largely Marxist groups that had popular support after the elections to the constituent assembly went against them.
So painting them all with one brush is not just ignorant, but offensive to the many socialists and communists who took up arms, and fought and died to try to stop those regimes.
Your example is pretty much equivalent to complaining about capitalism because various governments allowing some variation of private ownership of capital have committed atrocities.
- barry-cotter 9y ago> That's because most people who take more than a cursory glance sees that there are multiple different ideologies lumped under the same name there, diverse enough that the supporters of some have historically been the most brutal persecutors of supporters of others This argument would be more credible if the least awful Communist regime wasn’t a toss up between Cuba and Yugoslavia. Every single attempt at actual communism has gone so terribly that any rational person would flee a country that was about to turn communist with the clothes on their back.
- vidarh 9y agoThis is a ludicrous argument. You're free to argue that actual Marxist socialism is somehow impossible, given that it has not been demonstrated other than at a small scale. That's a matter of opinion. But the failure of these regimes does not change the fact that they were so far ideologically divorced from Marxist socialism and communism that most of them have met armed resistance from socialists and communists. And does not change the fact that the name has been used by groups with diametrically opposed world views. The point was not to argue whether or not socialism is possible or viable in any particular form, but to point out why communism gets treated differently from nazism: There are only totalitarian nazis, while among people who call themselves communists you find people ranging from totalitarian via supporters of parliamentary democracy, to anarchists, and within those groups the former have throughout the last century been among the ones who have murdered most of the latter. E.g. during the Spanish Civil War, Stalins Comintern agents were more successful at murdering high-ranking anti-Stalinist communist leaders than Franco's fascists was. Anti-Stalinist socialists and communists are as opposed, or more so, to the type of regimes you talk about as they are to the nazis or facists I've personally faced Stalinists who believed I belonged in labour camps because my views on socialism includes a firm belief in democracy, and I've personally made it clear to very same people that if they were to ever gain power, I'll take up arms against them same as I would against fascism or nazism.