4 ms·
Yep, there's a reason populism is commonly derided even in democratic societies. The founding fathers and "The Federalist Papers" [1] talked heavily about this
by dmix 9y ago
Yep, there's a reason populism is commonly derided even in democratic societies. The founding fathers and "The Federalist Papers" [1] talked heavily about this problem (aka the influence of the "lowest common denominator" in popular voting).
Where these popular ideas do matter is in the marketplace. The entire tech industry, including some of the wealthiest companies in the world, will most certainly rebel against any attempt by ISPs to threaten net neutrality. And there will similarly be a revolt by customers.
Google Fiber was created merely to promote the deployment of fiber, Net Neutrality is a far bigger issue than fiber to both the tech industry and ISP consumers.
Even without FCC rules it will still be very dangerous for any ISP to make any significant changes to how the internet works.
The most likely scenario is that a few mobile internet providers may offer niche small packages of limited internet to mobile users for $5-10/month (which so far is the only real world example of "net neutrality" being violated in the world, by a Portuguese ISP)... basically a way to offer cheaper packages to some users who can't afford full broadband. This is basically the only thing I could see ISPs getting away with. I highly doubt any ISP would risk limiting the internet for any average home broadband users. Most American ISPs are public companies who still have worry about their bottom line.
The backlash even without FCC laws will be a significant deterrence.
[1] https://www.wikiwand.com/en/The_Federalist_Papers https://www.wikiwand.com/en/The_Federalist_Papers
- charleslmunger 9y ago> which so far is the only real world example of "net neutrality" being violated in the world, by a Portuguese ISP How would you describe Comcast's throttling of bittorrent or Rogers throttling of all encrypted traffic in Canada?
- dmix 9y agoApologies, I should clarify, my Portuguese ISP example is the only real world example of the "TV-style limited internet packages" being deployed by a real-world ISP (which is the primary scenario nearly ever pro-net neutrality article warns about). > Comcast's throttling of bittorrent Were these FCC laws blocking Comcast from throttling Bittorrent traffic? Canada was also the first country to throttle bittorrent traffic as well and the adoption of encryption in Bittorrent clients was largely able to bypass this issue AFAIK (I haven't experienced any slow downs in years in Canada since I toggled "force encrypted peers"). > Rogers throttling of all encrypted traffic in Canada Source? I used Rogers for years and I've never heard of this problem.
- mratzloff 9y agoYour example from Portugal is a mobile plan where you can buy additional data.
- charleslmunger 9y agohttps://www.wired.com/2008/09/comcast-disclos-2/ https://www.wired.com/2008/09/comcast-disclos-2/ ""Comcast's practices are not minimally intrusive, as the company claims, but rather are invasive and have significant effects," the commission said, demanding an end to the practices by year's end." This was under the Title I classification that was struck down by the verizon lawsuit, where the court said that the way to enforce these rules within the FCC's existing powers was via Title II. As for Rogers, http://www.michaelgeist.ca/2007/04/rogers-packet-shaping/ http://www.michaelgeist.ca/2007/04/rogers-packet-shaping/
- imglorp 9y agoComcast and Verizon both throttled netflix for a while, before getting smacked. What do want to bet that's back in force, as soon as tomorrow perhaps? They've got all the code from last time ready to go. https://ecfsapi.fcc.gov/file/7521304546.pdf https://ecfsapi.fcc.gov/file/7521304546.pdf
- ikeboy 9y agoThere's been no actual proof of throttling. Congestion is not proof of throttling.
- forg0t_username 9y ago> only real world example [Citation needed]. Whatsapp has virtually no competition in Brazil because most carriers do not count it toward the data cap.
- zaccus 9y ago>there will similarly be a revolt by customers. ISPs already do incredibly unpopular things, but it doesn't hurt their bottom line because their customers don't have other provider options. What are they going to do, go without internet? Comcast is one of the most hated companies in the US, but you wouldn't know it by looking at their stock price. The free market is not a solution here.
- dmix 9y ago> ISPs already do incredibly unpopular things Have they pissed off the entire tech industry and attempted to fundamentally change how the internet works? Having poor customer service, high fees, etc seems like a far cry from completely changing how internet billing works and whitelisting websites/throttling the entire internet.
- EvanAnderson 9y agoWhat is the "entire tech industry" really going to do when the ISPs decide to fundamentally change how the Internet works? It seems like access to consumers, which the ISPs control, is pretty important for a large segment of the tech industry.
- dmix 9y ago...I guess we'll have to see, won't we? But first the ISPs have to actually do the things that we were warned they would do if the FCC scraped these laws. No ISP has yet announced or even proposed any specific future changes. I'm not even sure what being "wrong" here will look like in practical terms: - Are average home broadband internet plans going to have their internet filtered unless they pay more for 'unlimited'? With TV-style "grouped" packages? - What websites (tech companies) will be included in these hypothetical filtered packages? - Will they (Netflix/Disney/Facebook/Google/etc) let the ISPs include their brand(s) in marketing these new non-neutral plans? Will they let the ISP include their website in any throttled package in technical terms? - Will ISPs be launching the new plans perfectly in sync with other ISP companies, for the 80% of Americans who have more than one ISP option, so they won't hemorrhage customers to competitors when they completely revamp their billing? Will they grandfather existing users? ...there are far too many questions to properly give you a answer about how the industry will respond. When/if that actually becomes a reality then it will be easier to guess how the trillion dollar industry will react and if the ISP customers will sit idly by with no recourse... at the moment I'm confident there will be plenty to do to make business/life for Comcast/ATT shareholders uncomfortable if they ever were dumb enough to mess with how the internet works for the average American.
- rspeer 9y agoWhy don't you consider T-Mobile's "Binge On" plan to be a violation of net neutrality? I recall it being something like: Netflix data is free, other data is $10/GB. It seems exactly the same as that widely-quoted Portuguese example, which also let you pay a data rate for sites that weren't in their special packages. This happened in the US because net neutrality was weak and never really applied to mobile carriers.
- acomjean 9y agomobile carriers were specifically excluded from net-neutrality rules.
- rspeer 9y agoI know. I'm pointing out that the Portuguese non-neutral mobile carrier is no different than our US non-neutral mobile carriers.
- ohyes 9y agoIt would be but wireless providers weren't covered under net neutrality, it only covered wired connections.
- ASalazarMX 9y ago> The entire tech industry, including some of the wealthiest companies in the world, will most certainly rebel against any attempt by ISPs to threaten net neutrality Have you noticed not many tech companies have complained? Did telecom win by attrition, or did they negotiate after the last failure?
- xocyabencl 9y agoI think you are ignoring the main financial motive for this change - ISPs want to shake down Google, Facebook, and other successful internet companies. Customers won't see this directly. It will have indirect effects by increasing costs for the companies they use, but not in an obvious way that will cause a revolt. In financial terms, this dispute is mainly about these giant companies battling over who gets the fat profits Google and Facebook are currently taking home.