7 ms·
http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html is very relevant about how we got here. As Paul Graham said then, the biggest threats to
by btilly 9y ago
http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html is very relevant about how we got here.
As Paul Graham said then, the biggest threats to free thought and speech come from people who have just enough power to enforce taboos, and not enough to be confident in their power. In this case the political ideology that is stifling thought is one that has nationwide lost Congress, the Senate and the Presidency. Which naturally results in a strong "us vs them" mentality, and stronger incentives to require that everyone prove that they are part of "us".
The result is, as I've heard it put, Liberals are tolerant of anything except being conservative.
This is not, of course, one-sided. If you lived in a deeply religious part of the country you'd find similar levels of intolerance towards liberal ideas as a result of feeling like they are on the receiving end of years of losing the culture war. That won't be the problem that you experience in the Bay area. But it is two sides of the same mentality that you are either with us or against us.
- CPLX 9y ago> The result is, as I've heard it put, Liberals are tolerant of anything except being conservative. That's a clever slogan. But the logical response to that would be to say that liberals are tolerant of everything except intolerance. Which as a factual statement is of course arguable, but as a premise is certainly internally consistent.
- btilly 9y agoThe problem with that "logical response" is that it is wrong. Here is a simple demonstration. Consider the conservative argument that when you raise the minimum wage, elementary economics of supply and demand results in fewer jobs for poor people. I guarantee you that if you present this argument to 10 liberal friends, more than half will have a strong emotional response against it. While responding, some are likely to turn an interesting shade of red. Yet there is no intolerance in that argument. Furthermore the argument is fairly well grounded in reality. Supply-demand curves are well-established basic microeconomics. And furthermore if you play around with https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/science-isnt-broken/#part1 https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/science-isnt-broken/#pa... you will find that Republican policies (which include low minimum wages) are consistently better for creating jobs. Just as Democratic ones are better for increasing GDP.
- cortesoft 9y agoNo, the 'logical response' isn't wrong, it just isn't followed by all self-proclaimed 'liberals'. Of course some liberals will have emotional reponses to something that is not actually an intolerant opinion, like your example. There is no admission requirements to be a 'liberal', so we can't deny entry to people who don't understand the difference between a moral question and an implementation question like minimum wage.
- dang 9y agoI think btilly was making more of an empirical observation than arguing from the definition of liberalism.
- btilly 9y agoIn my experience, the "logical response" isn't an accurate description of most liberals. The original statement is. The fact that a liberal thinks that "conservative" should be replaced with "intolerant" is a symptom of the problem that I describe.
- cortesoft 9y agoYou say in your experience, 'most liberals' act in the original statement. Are you willing to entertain the possibility that your impression might be mistaken? You probably don't really think about the times a liberal person is reasonable and logical. You certainly will remember the ridiculous liberal who says illogical things. Might that be skewing your impression of what 'most' liberals believe?
- btilly 9y agoYour assumptions about my political views are mistaken. I was a liberal who moved to libertarian. The statement that I made about minimum wage has the effect that I describe because it is a major liberal-conservative argument. As soon as someone states a position on raising the minimum wage, everyone else around will tend to assume that they know their political position. I could have produced other examples ranging from approving oil pipelines to the wisdom of tax cuts to cost effective ways to produce health care. Now you may be atypical. But most liberals/conservatives respond with the same pattern. They figure out whether you're with/against, and then respond emotionally. And the issues do not neatly divide on "intolerance". More interesting, the dividing issues change over time. Today woman's rights is obviously a liberal issue. If you go back 100 years, allowing women the right to vote was just as obviously a conservative one, because women were a reliable vote for Prohibition, which was a thinly veiled tool to attack blacks, Jews, Irish, and other "undesirables". You can thank the KKK for helping women get the vote in this country. The dividing line really isn't as simple as it seems at the moment. But it is sometimes easier to see this with the perspective of history.
- munificent 9y ago> as a premise is certainly internally consistent. Karl Popper argued that, in fact, that exact rule is not just consistent but necessary for tolerance to exist: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance
- lr4444lr 9y agoThat's sophomoric, and I'm surprised someone of Popper's renown would even waste time on this argument. In what ethical system is tolerance ever a good for its own sake and not some higher ideal? Upvoted for bringing it to my attention, though. :-)
- Jun8 9y agoAlso this essay is relevant: http://www.paulgraham.com/wids.html http://www.paulgraham.com/wids.html. This was the start of souring of Paul Graham's relationship with the CA political correctness, I guess (do a search on "paul graham sexist" and you'll get a ton of articles from Dec 2013.
- cortesoft 9y agoWell, another way of putting it is "Liberals are tolerant of anything except intolerance" If I want to be a tolerant and accepting person, do I have to accept someone who wants to deny a group of people to marry the person they love? Do I have to tolerate someone who wants to control a woman's body? This is similar to a love of freedom; I want everyone to have freedom, but that means having to restrict the freedom to infringe on other people's freedom. That might seem to be a contradiction, but it is a paradox you have to address.
- kazinator 9y ago> I have to accept someone who wants to deny a group of people to marry the person they love? No, just their freedom to express that they don't like it. Not grant them actual power to interfere in people's lives by implementing the denial. > Do I have to tolerate someone who wants to control a woman's body? We have to tolerate someone who expresses (in a non-harassing way) that it would be a good idea for them to do that; we shouldn't tolerate someone trying to instigate such control. And I mean as a matter of public policy. Whatever you choose not to tolerate personally is up to you as long as your preferences aren't used as the basis for perpetrating discrimination.
- cortesoft 9y agoI think everyone (including me) agrees that you shouldn't arrest or legally stop people from expressing their opinions, no matter how morally reprehensible those opinions are. However, that isn't what the blog post is talking about. It is saying people SHOULD tolerate it personally, and we shouldn't call people 'heretics' for their ideas no matter what those ideas are. I think it is ok for people to say "If you say gay people shouldn't get married, I am going to immediately respond that you are wrong and that it is immoral to hold that belief. If you say and hold that belief, I do not want to be friends with you and I don't want to support your business." Boycotting people and businesses that hold views that go against your moral beliefs isn't wrong, and should not be condemned as blocking progress. Now, I do think we all have the responsibility to make sure we limit the things that we respond to in this way. For example, we shouldn't have the 'shun the person' response if you disagree with what the tax rate should be, or if you think that raising the minimum wage will cause rampant inflation. Those aren't moral beliefs, they are implementation details. Now, it would be different if your belief was "I don't want to raise the minimum wage because poor people don't deserve help", we might run into more issues. It becomes a bit tricky because a lot of horrible, immoral, views are hidden behind false justifications. Sometimes we make mistakes, and people with legitimate beliefs might be caught up in the crossfire, but this doesn't mean we shouldn't take reasons into account when determining the response to an opinion.
- xster 9y ago> Liberals are tolerant of anything except being conservative As a non-American liberal, I'd argue 'liberals' are tolerant of anything except non-American liberals. Try bringing up progressive topics in polite company and see how long you can last before becoming a conspiracy theorist / radical. You agree with every UN member countries wrt Palestine/Israel except 2? Oh, we don't talk about that here. You want to support grassroots primary caucus delegate? Nevada primary co-chairs were expelled from the causes they were chairing for trespassing. You want more than 2 corporate parties? Jill Stein was handcuffed to a chair for hours for attempting to enter the televised presidential debate venue. You're anti war? You must be a Russian spy or literally Hitler for not opposing strawman foreign governments who resist trading oil in petro-dollars.
- ryanwaggoner 9y agoThis is a tired trope: "American liberals aren't real global liberals, they're actually conservatives (or at best, centrists) just masquerading!" Nothing you listed seems even slightly crazy to me, nor anything that a good chunk of American liberals would disagree with. Or a non-trivial fraction of conservatives, for that matter.
- dang 9y agoI know you have real points but bringing them up in this way in this discussion is just going to create a flamewar. That may be part of the problem you're articulating but it's also a fact, and we have to have a fire department here or the place will burn up. So please don't. We have no choice but to work within the window of tolerance of the body of this community. I don't mean 'tolerance' in the virtue sense but in the physical sense of excessive stimulus triggering meltdown.
- xster 9y agoOh I totally agree with you. I feel shutting this down is rational too. I just figured it was the theme of this thread and of the original article.